Altcoins Talks - Cryptocurrency Forum

Crypto Discussion Forum => Forum related => Topic started by: alltalk on September 18, 2018, 05:09:48 PM

Title: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: alltalk on September 18, 2018, 05:09:48 PM
I have experienced to analyze and observe for many postings (comments and topics) that are made by many members on our forum. I can say that there is a good progress or improvement of their postings. Then, I realize something about this, that there are many of our members still not active in applying the Karma, especially for + Karma (positive). I don't know about the reasons but maybe some of them feel afraid to give Karma or they don't care about the Karma. Do you think this happen because of the lack awareness of members? Or this is normal and don't think to be discussed?

~Let's discuss about this. I really appreciate about your comments. And I want to make this case be clear~

Thank You   
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: admin on September 18, 2018, 05:34:57 PM
only snr and above can apply , mods are asked to be generous when possible
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: alltalk on September 18, 2018, 05:45:41 PM
only snr and above can apply , mods are asked to be generous when possible

Okay, got it. Thanks Admin, I am very happy that you want to give attention for this case.  :)
In addition, one of the reasons that I create this posting is to make "Senior and above" be aware in participating more about Karma.
~Not only focus in increasing their total posts or points~   
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Unknown on September 19, 2018, 07:17:39 AM
only snr and above can apply , mods are asked to be generous when possible
May i know admin, does sr.members and above can give karma for limited karma only? What are the restrictions? Can you give a link admin thanks
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: LogiC on September 19, 2018, 12:20:04 PM
only snr and above can apply , mods are asked to be generous when possible
May i know admin, does sr.members and above can give karma for limited karma only? What are the restrictions? Can you give a link admin thanks

Same question, can senior members and up can give how many karma points for example you only have 1 karma? Does restriction will be if you have 1 karma only 1 post can give this per day? I think this is the case I just want confirmation.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on September 19, 2018, 02:39:48 PM
I try to answer you. Se. members and above can give as many karma as they want. But there is the restriction - 100 hours between karma for the same user. The reason is abusing of the karma.

And the answer to second question. Users for example with 1 karma can give more karmas. YOu can give karma also if you don't have any. Of course you have to be Sr. member and above.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: LogiC on September 19, 2018, 03:04:41 PM
I try to answer you. Se. members and above can give as many karma as they want. But there is the restriction - 100 hours between karma for the same user. The reason is abusing of the karma.

And the answer to second question. Users for example with 1 karma can give more karmas. YOu can give karma also if you don't have any. Of course you have to be Sr. member and above.

Ahh I see almost 3days gap for giving karma with the same user. Nice system for karma giving. Also, if I become senior member even without karma points I can give karma to post with highly appreciated content. Nice, I thought only senior member and up plus those who have karma can give karma, even without karma points as long the that rank attained can. Thank you so much now much clearer.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: alltalk on September 19, 2018, 05:31:55 PM
I try to answer you. Se. members and above can give as many karma as they want. But there is the restriction - 100 hours between karma for the same user. The reason is abusing of the karma.

And the answer to second question. Users for example with 1 karma can give more karmas. YOu can give karma also if you don't have any. Of course you have to be Sr. member and above.

Very helpful information, Mate. I guess many members don't know about this. This information should be disseminated to all members. But firstly, Let me summarize it:

1. There is a restriction to give the next karma for the same user. It is 100 hours between the karmas.
2. A Senior and Above can give karma even when he has no karma. 

~I give you 1 karma for the very useful information~
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Cheratu Mesir on September 20, 2018, 07:19:14 AM
As far as I see and read in this forum, giving karma can only be given by a minimum senior member rank and cannot be done by the rank below. I think maybe the assessment of the quality of the posts by each member is different. There might be someone who likes the uniqueness of the writing, and there are also those who like it from the information provided.
I am a little curious, can we see who gave us karma? I see there is 6 positive karma that you get, but i can't see which of your posts is given positive karma. Thank you for responding to my question, sir.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: LogiC on September 20, 2018, 10:19:58 AM
As far as I see and read in this forum, giving karma can only be given by a minimum senior member rank and cannot be done by the rank below. I think maybe the assessment of the quality of the posts by each member is different. There might be someone who likes the uniqueness of the writing, and there are also those who like it from the information provided.
I am a little curious, can we see who gave us karma? I see there is 6 positive karma that you get, but i can't see which of your posts is given positive karma. Thank you for responding to my question, sir.

Nice question indeed. Have the same question but still none response from the thread I've asked. In my opinion, they want to limit the karma givers to this rank so lower rank members can learn first and familiarize the forum itself. It's not about how someone differs on taste of the quality of the content shares right. But that's their rule easy to follow actually. Let's say someone even at newbie rank can judge other post but he can't push it or insist it since there is a rule.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: alltalk on September 20, 2018, 02:09:58 PM
~snip~
I see there is 6 positive karma that you get, but i can't see which of your posts is given positive karma. Thank you for responding to my question, sir.

I also don't know who give the Karmas to me. For now, we don't have access to know it, only Admin knows about it.

~snip~In my opinion, they want to limit the karma givers to this rank so lower rank members can learn first and familiarize the forum itself~snip~

To limit the karma givers is a must, we need to avoid the misused of karma.

~snip~It's not about how someone differs on taste of the quality of the content shares right. ~snip~
 

Cek here, how you can get the karma: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=657.0. Admin has explained about how you can get the karma.

"Karma is to be granted to people providing good answers and interesting questions.
Active members have the ability to thank and punish users *don't abuse it!"

Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Cheratu Mesir on September 20, 2018, 08:05:55 PM
(...) In my opinion, they want to limit the karma givers to this rank so lower rank members can learn first and familiarize the forum itself. It's not about how someone differs on taste of the quality of the content shares right. But that's their rule easy to follow actually. Let's say someone even at newbie rank can judge other post but he can't push it or insist it since there is a rule.
Thank you for your explanation. Indeed, beginners are required to understand the rules of the forum and discuss according to the topic to find solutions to problems. Personally, i am very interested in the karma system, which requires beginners to learn a lot and establish friendships and discuss politely. As long as the beginner does not violate the rules, that member will not get negative karma. Is that true?

(...)
I also don't know who give the Karmas to me. For now, we don't have access to know it, only Admin knows about it.
I began to understand. I think maybe this limited access is done to reduce conflict between members due to negative karma giving. I means this idea really maintains good relations between members. Thank you for the keyword, sir.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: alltalk on September 20, 2018, 11:10:36 PM
~snip~As long as the beginner does not violate the rules, that member will not get negative karma. Is that true?
~snip~
Of course, if someone does not violate the rules, he won't get negative karma. Try to avoid: (1.) Posting in wrong section, (2.) Being aggressive, or impolite without any reason, and (3.) Spam referral link or website. Good luck guys..  :)
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Quantum X on September 21, 2018, 07:18:45 AM
only snr and above can apply , mods are asked to be generous when possible

Okay, got it. Thanks Admin, I am very happy that you want to give attention for this case.  :)
In addition, one of the reasons that I create this posting is to make "Senior and above" be aware in participating more about Karma.
~Not only focus in increasing their total posts or points~   
I like how you put concern on this matter so I give you a + karma. Regarding to this we can not expect more than what we have now since there are senior members that are being inactive for more than a week or even a month. Since senior and above are the only allow for giving karma, their absence for some time really affect the karma statistics.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: alltalk on September 23, 2018, 02:32:00 AM
~snip~
Okay, got it. Thanks Admin, I am very happy that you want to give attention for this case.  :)
In addition, one of the reasons that I create this posting is to make "Senior and above" be aware in participating more about Karma.
~Not only focus in increasing their total posts or points~   
I like how you put concern on this matter so I give you a + karma. Regarding to this we can not expect more than what we have now since there are senior members that are being inactive for more than a week or even a month. Since senior and above are the only allow for giving karma, their absence for some time really affect the karma statistics.

~Thank you so much for your appreciation~  :)
That's true. One of the problem is "they are being inactive for more than a week or even a month". But it seems admin has created a regulation related the problem. So, I hope it can be effective way to fix it and bring positive impacts for karma statistics. 
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: ZionRTZ on October 21, 2018, 08:49:08 PM
How can you give karma when a lot of topics posted here are simply copied from other forum?
I am even more surprised to see that a plagiarist here has a positive karma.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: alltalk on October 22, 2018, 10:27:38 AM
How can you give karma when a lot of topics posted here are simply copied from other forum?
I am even more surprised to see that a plagiarist here has a positive karma.

Not all topics, mate. I mean here, the quality topics that are created by good one. There are still many quality topics on our forum. Give appreciation for them.  :) 

For plagiarism, we can report them on : https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=62494.0. You can also contribute to report them. But you must remind that it is only for the case of copy-paste. If someone rewrites the topic with their own ways, it is not plagiarism.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: PRIBO247 on October 28, 2018, 04:26:27 PM
I have experienced to analyze and observe for many postings (comments and topics) that are made by many members on our forum. I can say that there is a good progress or improvement of their postings. Then, I realize something about this, that there are many of our members still not active in applying the Karma, especially for + Karma (positive). I don't know about the reasons but maybe some of them feel afraid to give Karma or they don't care about the Karma. Do you think this happen because of the lack awareness of members? Or this is normal and don't think to be discussed?
~Let's discuss about this. I really appreciate about your comments. And I want to make this case be clear~

Thank You   

As I understand this, only senior members and above can give karma. Now my question is,  does the receiving of karma begin from a certain rank level? Or can any rank receive karma, even baby steps? Secondly, are there parameters to use in judging that a post merits a karma? Finally, can two or three persons give a particular person karma at the same time?
Tnx for the answers in advance.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Leonardo on October 28, 2018, 05:40:11 PM
As I understand this, only senior members and above can give karma. Now my question is,  does the receiving of karma begin from a certain rank level? Or can any rank receive karma, even baby steps? Secondly, are there parameters to use in judging that a post merits a karma? Finally, can two or three persons give a particular person karma at the same time?
Tnx for the answers in advance.
Everyone ranking from Newbie can receive karma. There is no specific standard in judging a post, as admin once stated:
Karma is to be granted to people providing good answers and interesting questions.

Of course two or three people can give karma to a person at the same time. It seems like you're new to forum. Read all the sticky threads to know how it works.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: PRIBO247 on October 28, 2018, 08:25:38 PM

Of course two or three people can give karma to a person at the same time. It seems like you're new to forum. Read all the sticky threads to know how it works.
[/quote]

Thank you for your replies. I have read the rules of the forum and I am still reading them. But you must admit that karma giving is a kind of sticky issue.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Collinberg on November 01, 2018, 11:42:04 AM
I think it is happening because of lack of awareness because to be honest, if it wasn't for this your message, I would not know about Karma and what it means.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Zed0X on November 04, 2018, 12:02:10 PM
I think it is happening because of lack of awareness because to be honest, if it wasn't for this your message, I would not know about Karma and what it means.

It's not that it is lacking awareness, many members are lazy to read. Kama rules are already pinned in this board so I don't know how you missed it also.
Title: Re: The current problem related to applying Karma
Post by: Zed0X on November 04, 2018, 12:09:29 PM
I made my own observations regarding those accounts getting Karma, I think some are too generous in giving it or some are just being fooled by "intelligent comments". They tend to give Karma without checking whether or not a comment or post was simply copied from other sources. I made several reports already but it still not enough. Sr. Members above should be more careful in giving out Karma.