Altcoins Talks - Cryptocurrency Forum
Crypto Discussion Forum => Forum related => Topic started by: admin on February 15, 2019, 11:43:32 PM
-
We have switched to Activity rank system : https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96515
this post is to answer any of your questions, please ask below
-
Rank will drop if you do not have the required post count for new rank
if you have the required new post count you can escape the new factors
if not you will have to fullfill the other requirements to rank up
-
No wonder I'm shocked and my ranking is down!
Okay, No Problem, if this is the best for Altcoinstalks forums, please do it and I will support it. LOL
-
"Rank will drop if you don't have the required post count for new rank."
We can conclude the above statement:
how many posts to become HERO?
how many activities to become a HERO?
-
- Post requirement have been reduced, thus now shorter post count in the count post.
Please don't remove this.
If not, then increase post counts of Sr. Members also to maybe 200. Full members to 100.
EDIT: I missed this one
- Post count will be increasing for all ranks, thus you might experience a rank drop if you fall under the new post count requirement.
- Plagiarism and spam will be penalized and can affect your future ranking.
A much needed rule.
------------------------------
I think these changes increases the integrity of the forum and also adds to the confidence of ICO/STO teams to launch their bounty campaigns here.
-
"Rank will drop if you don't have the required post count for new rank."
We can conclude the above statement:
how many posts to become HERO?
how many activities to become a HERO?
As far as I know:
Before: 500 posts to become HERO
Now: 500 activities (and maybe some karma) to become HERO
But I'm not sure what's the difference between post and activity. Maybe it's a little bit similar to forum X.
-
Sir, actually I think the change is still not really clear. I advise you to make it more detail.
For example, I have some questions below :
Post count will be increasing for all ranks
Can you specify about the number of posts/activities needed for each ranks
1. Newbie : ............ posts/activities
2. Baby steps : ............ posts/activities
3. Jr member : ............ posts/activities
4. Full member : ............ posts/activities
5. Senior Member : ............ posts/activities
6. Hero : ............ posts/activities
7. Legend : ............ posts/activities
Registration date: the older your account is, the easier it will be to rank up
1. Newbie : 0 day
2. Baby steps : how long? ............
3. Jr member : a week
4. Full member : how long? ............
5. Senior Member : how long? ............
6. Hero : how long? ............
7. Legend : how long? ............
Karma : It is required for certain ranks
1. Newbie : 0 karma
2. Baby steps : 0 karma
3. Jr member : 0 karma
4. Full member : ............ karmas
5. Senior Member : ............ karmas
6. Hero : ............ karmas
7. Legend : ............ karmas
For a better understanding among member : At least, three aspects above that are very needed to be explained more in detail. Thanks
-
By the way, I have an advise to appreciate the old members or existing members.
I think a new regulation or change, should be applied for the future way to reach the ranks. While for the existing members that already reach the current ranks, shouldn't reduce to lower ranks. It is to appreciate them who already become the pioneer on altcoinstalks forum.
We will feel very appreciated if you consider this suggestion. Thank you Sir..
-
We have switched to Activity rank system : https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96515
this post is to answer any of your questions, please ask below
Mine is not a question but a word of praise. This is a very good step in the development of this forum. Keep adding more Tobit as you have said. I really like the system but please as I do say, let's not forget the reason why most people are here.
This is altcoinstalk and not bitcointalk so bounty managers can not put pressure on the administrative board of this forum. Please relax and let altcoinstalk be altcoinstalk. We are not any other forum, let that be in mind. If the really want to advertise here, they should follow what is here.
-
"Rank will drop if you don't have the required post count for new rank."
We can conclude the above statement:
how many posts to become HERO?
how many activities to become a HERO?
for higher ranks, this will change gradually , till it reaches aprox. double the current amount
however that will be gradual over a 1-3 month period
-
Sir, actually I think the change is still not really clear. I advise you to make it more detail.
For example, I have some questions below :
Post count will be increasing for all ranks
Can you specify about the number of posts/activities needed for each ranks
1. Newbie : ............ posts/activities
2. Baby steps : ............ posts/activities
3. Jr member : ............ posts/activities
4. Full member : ............ posts/activities
5. Senior Member : ............ posts/activities
6. Hero : ............ posts/activities
7. Legend : ............ posts/activities
Registration date: the older your account is, the easier it will be to rank up
1. Newbie : 0 day
2. Baby steps : how long? ............
3. Jr member : a week
4. Full member : how long? ............
5. Senior Member : how long? ............
6. Hero : how long? ............
7. Legend : how long? ............
Karma : It is required for certain ranks
1. Newbie : 0 karma
2. Baby steps : 0 karma
3. Jr member : 0 karma
4. Full member : ............ karmas
5. Senior Member : ............ karmas
6. Hero : ............ karmas
7. Legend : ............ karmas
For a better understanding among member : At least, three aspects above that are very needed to be explained more in detail. Thanks
the forum is made to interact as a community, unfortunately many only wish to rank up,
thus for now, i will not give further info.
all what i can say is that active and helpful members will have no problem ranking up.
-
Most importantly, do not anything similar to merit. Merit is a dead-end branch of a similar forum. Merit - their very big mistake.
-
Most importantly, do not anything similar to merit. Merit is a dead-end branch of a similar forum. Merit - their very big mistake.
Agree. I hope karma won't play the big role in the ranking system. Merit system was the worst thing BTT did. And I hope we won't do the same mistake here on altcoinstalks. On the other hand, I fully agree with the tíme restriction.
-
"Rank will drop if you don't have the required post count for new rank."
We can conclude the above statement:
how many posts to become HERO?
how many activities to become a HERO?
for higher ranks, this will change gradually , till it reaches aprox. double the current amount
however that will be gradual over a 1-3 month period
I registered this account on the altcoinstalks forum since August 2018 and until February it was around 7 months.
I also got karma 5 from reporting a lot of SPAM in this forum to you admin.
~ however that will be gradual over a 1-3 month period ~
I have to work again for about 3 months (the longest) from February --- >> March, April, May. For a day I made 2 posts at 3 months = 180 posts
my activity is now around 540 + 180 = 720 activities.
Awesome dev 8)
PS : I don't deserve to be a Hero because when I asked:
- how to make tokens, I can't
- How to make coins, I can't
- Because on the basis of it, I can only trade Bitcoin with altcoins at Binance.
-
Most importantly, do not anything similar to merit. Merit is a dead-end branch of a similar forum. Merit - their very big mistake.
Agree. I hope karma won't play the big role in the ranking system. Merit system was the worst thing BTT did. And I hope we won't do the same mistake here on altcoinstalks. On the other hand, I fully agree with the tíme restriction.
I think the main mistake of BTT is that (s)merit is very limited, mainly hoarded by a small number of high ranking individuals, and rarely distributed unless it's as a merit trade, if not simply sold for profit. Fortunately on here there is "nothing to lose" by granting positive karma, as it's not a scare commodity, unlike on BTT where you have "used up" your ability to give merit, due to it's limited/regulated supply which is a deterrent to do so in itself. Therefore, karma is nothing like merit imo.
I agree that karma shouldn't take a main role in ranking up, and that it is better based on activity (rather than posts), but I wouldn't be opposed to users requiring a neutral/+ merit in order to become higher rank, due to the number of Sr Members with bad karma, who have the power to grant karma, which we've already seen as an issue in the case of plagiarism reporting. I'm not saying that they should need +K to rank up to certain levels, but that they need to not have -K.
Anyway, I digress. I hope this addresses the issue of high ranking negative karma members who generally speaking have negative karma for good reason... You're not a Hero to the forum if you're a spammer with -K, and you're certainly not a Legend with -K unless it's as a Legendary Spammer ;)
-
Agree. I hope karma won't play the big role in the ranking system. Merit system was the worst thing BTT did. And I hope we won't do the same mistake here on altcoinstalks. On the other hand, I fully agree with the tíme restriction.
You are right. I am afraid this will bring bad impacts to the number of active members. And possibly cause a large number of members to move to other forums.
I also agree about the the time restriction. BUT don't agree for the significant change to the number of posts/activities to reach the next rank.
-
~snip~
thus for now, i will not give further info.
~snip~
It's no problem for now. But It should be created next. We cannot apply new rules without clear details.
~snip~
the forum is made to interact as a community, unfortunately many only wish to rank up,
all what i can say is that active and helpful members will have no problem ranking up.
If you found some people only wish to rank up, you can send them warning and punishment if they keep repeating.
I think the problem is not in our rules, but in the punishment system.
-
You are right. I am afraid this will bring bad impacts to the number of active members. And possibly cause a large number of members to move to other forums.
I also agree about the the time restriction. BUT don't agree for the significant change to the number of posts/activities to reach the next rank.
I am the opposite for entering karma to achieve ranks. This will get rid of unnecessary spam.
The idea of "Merit" on BTT is good in itself. But it needs to be improved. Here, a great solution would be karma. It is given in unlimited quantities in contrast to Merit.
-
I am the opposite for entering karma to achieve ranks. This will get rid of unnecessary spam.
The idea of "Merit" on BTT is good in itself. But it needs to be improved. Here, a great solution would be karma. It is given in unlimited quantities in contrast to Merit.
Applying karma to achieve ranks without providing proper rules will cause massive karma abuses. We have already had many cases about this.
I assume we need to let everyone know where karma comes from, I mean from what posts.
-
We have switched to Activity rank system : https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96515
this post is to answer any of your questions, please ask below
Mine is not a question but a word of praise. This is a very good step in the development of this forum. Keep adding more Tobit as you have said. I really like the system but please as I do say, let's not forget the reason why most people are here.
This is altcoinstalk and not bitcointalk so bounty managers can not put pressure on the administrative board of this forum. Please relax and let altcoinstalk be altcoinstalk. We are not any other forum, let that be in mind. If the really want to advertise here, they should follow what is here.
I remember your suggestion before to change the ranking system and admin finally made the necessary change.
On bounty, I believe the admin made the right call of listening to the request of bounty teams. With the change, we expect more users to really engage and contribute to discussions, read other comments and not just post some random words.
-
Most importantly, do not anything similar to merit. Merit is a dead-end branch of a similar forum. Merit - their very big mistake.
The merit system on the bbt forum virtually halted the movement in ranks. She secured a privileged position on the forum for some and lack of rights for others. Changes in this forum are necessary, however, the participants must have a prospect for growth by rank, even if it is difficult.
-
Agree. I hope karma won't play the big role in the ranking system. Merit system was the worst thing BTT did. And I hope we won't do the same mistake here on altcoinstalks. On the other hand, I fully agree with the tíme restriction.
You are right. I am afraid this will bring bad impacts to the number of active members. And possibly cause a large number of members to move to other forums.
I also agree about the the time restriction. BUT don't agree for the significant change to the number of posts/activities to reach the next rank.
the new ranking system is conceived in a very rational way,
the new requirements are pretty logical and within reach
if we do not make our ranks valuable, bounties will continue ignoring our members
-
the new ranking system is conceived in a very rational way,
the new requirements are pretty logical and within reach
if we do not make our ranks valuable, bounties will continue ignoring our members
It's okay you make it harder to rank up but I think at least you should make everything more clear.
Requirements:
The requirements will be changing,
- Post count will be increasing for all ranks, thus you might experience a rank drop if you fall under the new post count requirement.
- Registration date: the older your account is, the easier it will be to rank up, and to reach higher ranks, this will be made harder in the future.
- Forum activity: For certain ranks, we are taking in consideration forum activity, to avoid letting users create farm accounts to rank.
- KYC verification: It has a positive aspect on ranking up.
- Karma : It is required for certain ranks, in the future will be rendered more difficult.
--> How many posts/activities/karmas does it need for each rank in the new ranking system? How long does it require to reach that rank?
I have a feeling that you're trying to satisfy bounty managers but those bounty managers can change their signature campaign reward if they find forum's rankings are not worth it.
-
--> How many posts/activities/karmas does it need for each rank in the new ranking system? How long does it require to reach that rank?
Admin already replied to a similar question, just check previous comments.
I have a feeling that you're trying to satisfy bounty managers but those bounty managers can change their signature campaign reward if they find forum's rankings are not worth it.
It does not matter to me if admin is trying to satisfy bounty managers. That is his prerogative. We should just focus on making contributions to the forum and not on rankings.
-
Agree. I hope karma won't play the big role in the ranking system. Merit system was the worst thing BTT did. And I hope we won't do the same mistake here on altcoinstalks. On the other hand, I fully agree with the tíme restriction.
You are right. I am afraid this will bring bad impacts to the number of active members. And possibly cause a large number of members to move to other forums.
You have said it clearly and this is my experience.
I have a friend and he became a Community Manager at forum X, and I was told to move there, and he said there would be 3 Bounties ready to launch, the MPV platform was already running.
I hope that I'm still on the Altcoinstalks Forum because I think Altcoinstalks is more comfortable than other Forums.
-
Admin already replied to a similar question, just check previous comments.
He did but I don't find anything clear from his answer.
It does not matter to me if admin is trying to satisfy bounty managers. That is his prerogative. We should just focus on making contributions to the forum and not on rankings.
Does the bolded words sound familiar to you? I saw it everyday on forum X: "make contribution and you'll get merit", "forget about merit and contribite, merit will come"...
Clearly a lot of members come here because of it's easier to rank up than forum X. Do you think this is fair to ranked up member? Of course you don't cause you're not demoted like other heroes & legendaries on that forum.
I hope that I'm still on the Altcoinstalks Forum because I think Altcoinstalks is more comfortable than other Forums.
-
It does not matter to me if admin is trying to satisfy bounty managers. That is his prerogative. We should just focus on making contributions to the forum and not on rankings.
Does the bolded words sound familiar to you? I saw it everyday on forum X: "make contribution and you'll get merit", "forget about merit and contribite, merit will come"...
Clearly a lot of members come here because of it's easier to rank up than forum X. Do you think this is fair to ranked up member? Of course you don't cause you're not demoted like other heroes & legendaries on that forum.
1. I was demoted from Legendary just like most of us here.
2. The ranking may have been more strict now but it is still easier than Bitcointalk especially when it comes to getting +Karma. The parameters set by admin to rank up is way more achievable than the merit system implemented by Bitcointalk.
3. The way you are complaining about "contributions", it looks like you do not have the patience and do not have the passion to engage in discussions. Perhaps you are not suited to join forums.
-
So that's why my rank goes down but it does not matter to me. As long as I can interact with the forum and the post count requirement for specific rank is unknown which is exciting. I think it is a Good Update.
-
Alright guys, One question already answered.
For Legendary rank - you will need 1,200 post count. For the other parameters, only admin can shed light to that.
My guess for other ranks:
Hero - atleast 700 posts
Sr. Member - atleast 200 posts
-
Admin already replied to a similar question, just check previous comments.
He did but I don't find anything clear from his answer.
Specifically, the answer was:
the forum is made to interact as a community, unfortunately many only wish to rank up,
thus for now, i will not give further info.
all what i can say is that active and helpful members will have no problem ranking up.
PS - I'm loving the new spammer rank though, maybe it'd be good to have a Plagiarist rank too. These guys deserve badges too if you ask me :)
(https://i.imgur.com/0tUaWHX.png)
-
Alright guys, One question already answered.
For Legendary rank - you will need 1,200 post count. For the other parameters, only admin can shed light to that.
My guess for other ranks:
Hero - atleast 700 posts
Sr. Member - atleast 200 posts
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
-
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
Hi Chief!
I'm afraid to ask what are the conditions for achievement a Mythical rank ... or in order to keep it ... :o
-
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
We actually do not mind for the new rules as long as it is not an extreme change. But I think legend from 1000 to 2000 and Hero from 500 to 1000, is too significant change. I assume what Zion03 said will be more acceptable to all..
For Legendary rank - you will need 1,200 post count. For the other parameters, only admin can shed light to that.
My guess for other ranks:
Hero - atleast 700 posts
Sr. Member - atleast 200 posts
I agree with this guess. It makes sense.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have some forums as competitors, we need to consider what can be acceptable for all members. If you make too strict rules, we have a possibility to lose many members. I just remind you to anticipate the worst impacts.
-
We have some forums as competitors, we need to consider what can be acceptable for all members. If you make too strict rules, we have a possibility to lose many members. I just remind you to anticipate the worst impacts.
thats right bro. this new rules make me sad. why? because it is very significan. not dificult but it take more time to level up. i not really like it.
-
We have some forums as competitors, we need to consider what can be acceptable for all members. If you make too strict rules, we have a possibility to lose many members. I just remind you to anticipate the worst impacts.
thats right bro. this new rules make me sad. why? because it is very significan. not dificult but it take more time to level up. i not really like it.
On the other hand, altcoinstalks forum is a young forum, few months ago we have celebrated its birthday, but it has too many users with hero and legend rank. I agree that at least for hero rank and above we need time restriction.
-
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
I guess this means that we must continue to be active in the forum even if we reached legendary rank if we do not want to be demoted. With the restriction of minimum characters already removed, I think getting to 2,000 over a period of time won't be that difficult.
I hope the implementation of the future changes will be announced sooner (at least 1 week before) and that the requirement for the Mystical rank will not change.
thats right bro. this new rules make me sad. why? because it is very significan. not dificult but it take more time to level up. i not really like it.
Relax. This is for the betterment of the forum. I believe these changes will bring in more trust into the forum. We may even become at par with Bitcointalk in terms of number of bounty campaigns.
-
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
Hi Chief!
I'm afraid to ask what are the conditions for achievement a Mythical rank ... or in order to keep it ... :o
objective is 6-7k
but i will not touch this rank now, this will be updated in last phases
-
We have some forums as competitors, we need to consider what can be acceptable for all members. If you make too strict rules, we have a possibility to lose many members. I just remind you to anticipate the worst impacts.
thats right bro. this new rules make me sad. why? because it is very significan. not dificult but it take more time to level up. i not really like it.
that is the objective
as long as the ranking up is easy bounties will avoid us, why ? logic ... because they do not want to be cheated !
if it is easy to create 4-10 accounts and rank them to senior then you will be effectively cheating the bounties,
that's why ranking up should be harder.
-
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
We actually do not mind for the new rules as long as it is not an extreme change. But I think legend from 1000 to 2000 and Hero from 500 to 1000, is too significant change. I assume what Zion03 said will be more acceptable to all..
For Legendary rank - you will need 1,200 post count. For the other parameters, only admin can shed light to that.
My guess for other ranks:
Hero - atleast 700 posts
Sr. Member - atleast 200 posts
I agree with this guess. It makes sense.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have some forums as competitors, we need to consider what can be acceptable for all members. If you make too strict rules, we have a possibility to lose many members. I just remind you to anticipate the worst impacts.
there are more than a 100 crypto forums,
only bitcointalk had activity based rank, thus being the only one hard to rank in,
all other forums were ignored by bounties due to different factors , but ease of ranking up is one of these factors.
we are making the forum harder to cheat bounties, but at the same time now they have no reason to offer our members smaller bounty rewards.
since i implemented the new rank, we are at par with bitcointalk ranking value wise.
with the exception of the merit system which we will not implement but have karma replace it in certain ranks.
-
Rank will drop if you do not have the required post count for new rank
if you have the required new post count you can escape the new factors
if not you will have to fullfill the other requirements to rank up
What kind of requirement is this? Its far more worse than BitcoinTalk. Unless BitcoinTalk retain the users previous rank while AltscoinTalk demoted What kind of practises is this Im sure it will be a huge blow. to AltcoinsTalk subcription its not good.
-
Alright guys, One question already answered.
For Legendary rank - you will need 1,200 post count. For the other parameters, only admin can shed light to that.
My guess for other ranks:
Hero - atleast 700 posts
Sr. Member - atleast 200 posts
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
"but also will increase slowly"
What do these mean for these words?
-
Alright guys, One question already answered.
For Legendary rank - you will need 1,200 post count. For the other parameters, only admin can shed light to that.
My guess for other ranks:
Hero - atleast 700 posts
Sr. Member - atleast 200 posts
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
Thanks for this. Atleast we now have a clearer idea on the new rules.
"but also will increase slowly"
What do these mean for these words?
It means the change will be gradual.
Right now, what is clear is that you need 1,200 posts to rank up to Legendary according to Zion03.
Admin said the target for Legendary is 2,000 posts so expect the current 1,200 to increase again in a few months.
I assume that the next increase is 300 posts (total 1500 for legendary) and will be applied in 3 months time.
Then another change after that, until it reaches 2000 posts.
I believe all these changes will happen within the year.
@Admin,
With this parameter added " Time active on the forum : this applies for some but not all the ranks", perhaps our time spent on forum can also be added next to our profile.
-
@Admin,
With this parameter added " Time active on the forum : this applies for some but not all the ranks", perhaps our time spent on forum can also be added next to our profile.
yes good idea, will put it on my to do list
-
Rank will drop if you do not have the required post count for new rank
if you have the required new post count you can escape the new factors
if not you will have to fullfill the other requirements to rank up
What kind of requirement is this? Its far more worse than BitcoinTalk. Unless BitcoinTalk retain the users previous rank while AltscoinTalk demoted What kind of practises is this Im sure it will be a huge blow. to AltcoinsTalk subcription its not good.
we are now using same requirements as btt , except we do not require merit, karma is only used for higher ranks, and as a stopper if negative.
i didn't demote users, i increased the post requirements as a results, the users that did not have the new post count got demoted
I would like to ask you to try to rank up on bitcointalk, it's not possible, their system made it impossible to rank up to any member, due to merit, we don't have this, here it is still similar to old btt ranking.
-
Alright guys, One question already answered.
For Legendary rank - you will need 1,200 post count. For the other parameters, only admin can shed light to that.
My guess for other ranks:
Hero - atleast 700 posts
Sr. Member - atleast 200 posts
objective for legend is around 2 000 , but i will be increasing that slowly over a couple month at least
Hero should be around 1000, but also will increase slowly
Sr. is around 300
Jnr around 40
"but also will increase slowly"
What do these mean for these words?
means will increase the requirement slowly till it reaches the objective
if objective is 2000
and now it's 1200, then in a month it would be 1400, the next month 1600 the one after 1800 then finally 2000
or something like that
-
Not a question.
With the new rules, I believe we will see signature campaigns not just from ICOs but also from projects already listed on CMC in this forum. A good example is this https://twitter.com/mylalaworld/status/1097774148917460992
-
Rank will drop if you do not have the required post count for new rank
if you have the required new post count you can escape the new factors
if not you will have to fullfill the other requirements to rank up
What kind of requirement is this? Its far more worse than BitcoinTalk. Unless BitcoinTalk retain the users previous rank while AltscoinTalk demoted What kind of practises is this Im sure it will be a huge blow. to AltcoinsTalk subcription its not good.
we are now using same requirements as btt , except we do not require merit, karma is only used for higher ranks, and as a stopper if negative.
i didn't demote users, i increased the post requirements as a results, the users that did not have the new post count got demoted
This is good to hear, could you elaborate on if there is a karma requirement for higher rank, or whether it's only as a stopper if negative?
-
Rank will drop if you do not have the required post count for new rank
if you have the required new post count you can escape the new factors
if not you will have to fullfill the other requirements to rank up
What kind of requirement is this? Its far more worse than BitcoinTalk. Unless BitcoinTalk retain the users previous rank while AltscoinTalk demoted What kind of practises is this Im sure it will be a huge blow. to AltcoinsTalk subcription its not good.
we are now using same requirements as btt , except we do not require merit, karma is only used for higher ranks, and as a stopper if negative.
i didn't demote users, i increased the post requirements as a results, the users that did not have the new post count got demoted
This is good to hear, could you elaborate on if there is a karma requirement for higher rank, or whether it's only as a stopper if negative?
it is both, however i am rolling the karma part very slowly, need to observe effects while rolling it
thus not sharing much info about this for now, because this part is not 100% set yet
-
Not a question.
With the new rules, I believe we will see signature campaigns not just from ICOs but also from projects already listed on CMC in this forum. A good example is this https://twitter.com/mylalaworld/status/1097774148917460992
With the new rules, I hope to see less comments about Altcoinstalks like this one
(https://i.imgur.com/mGNvRIz.png)
-
My rank hasj just dropped to Full Member again. I am ok with it. If this rank rules will continue. But still it is not seems true that dropping somehow. I saw many forums that they changed the rank status. But never saw the rank drop. It should be valid for from now on.
Still we love this forum and will follow its rules!
-
My rank hasj just dropped to Full Member again. I am ok with it. If this rank rules will continue. But still it is not seems true that dropping somehow. I saw many forums that they changed the rank status. But never saw the rank drop. It should be valid for from now on.
Still we love this forum and will follow its rules!
Snr rank and below will no longer experience any more rank requirement changes for now
maybe in the far future i might change the requirements again, but there are no plans to do so for now.
-
Not a question. Even though I got de-ranked I really love these new changes it is for the good of Altcointalks and for anyone that is angry/sad about this I want to say look at the bright side your account is now more valuable so this change is also good for you.
A question I do not know if it is related or not but can we have the option to see from where our Karma come from? I mean the reason I got +1 or -1 karma? I think adding this will be nice since the higher ranking will require Kamra!
-
.... karma is only used for higher ranks, and as a stopper if negative.
Previously, only Sr. members and above can give +/- karma. What about now? My rank went down to Full member from Sr. Member but my option to give +/- karma was retained.
-
~snip~
means will increase the requirement slowly till it reaches the objective
if objective is 2000
and now it's 1200, then in a month it would be 1400, the next month 1600 the one after 1800 then finally 2000
or something like that
I am surprised with this requirement type. So, the number of posts will change depending on the time for rank up. And it will be permanent around 2,000 posts someday.
it is both, however i am rolling the karma part very slowly, need to observe effects while rolling it
thus not sharing much info about this for now, because this part is not 100% set yet
Karma system must be more strict as well if you want to make this forum become the same with forum X.
Note :
I've no idea anymore, just hope it really works to improve forum.
But I still cannot imagine how strict our forum regulation with the large number of posts requirement + karma system.
-
"Rank will drop if you don't have the required post count for new rank."
We can conclude the above statement:
how many posts to become HERO?
how many activities to become a HERO?
for higher ranks, this will change gradually , till it reaches aprox. double the current amount
however that will be gradual over a 1-3 month period
Here we are in the process of making ALTCOINS TALKS more interesting and exceeding efforts is necessary to support the platform. Assuming this forum will become more strict in postings and regulations to upgrade the ranking and discussion into another level. This will become great place where everyone helps each other as much as they can.
-
.... karma is only used for higher ranks, and as a stopper if negative.
Previously, only Sr. members and above can give +/- karma. What about now? My rank went down to Full member from Sr. Member but my option to give +/- karma was retained.
the rank change involved too many factors and took me close to a month of coding and testing,
what i can say is now i am taking a break, and later will head into this again and see how to tune things for the benifit of users and bounties
-
.... karma is only used for higher ranks, and as a stopper if negative.
Previously, only Sr. members and above can give +/- karma. What about now? My rank went down to Full member from Sr. Member but my option to give +/- karma was retained.
the rank change involved too many factors and took me close to a month of coding and testing,
what i can say is now i am taking a break, and later will head into this again and see how to tune things for the benifit of users and bounties
It is really crucial to implement new terms which there are possibility of getting hurt the community that gives color to make the forum much better or bitter, to distract or attract them.
Being the admin is necessary to look every aspects of the present, past, and the future situation. The evaluation of activities, members, postings quality, and campaigns or businesses partnership should always be considered because this is not about short term platform rather the long term quality forum.
Normally the reactions are pro or anti.
Hopefully we take this change as great opportunity as we are in the first stage of ALTCOINS TALKS greatness. Still we are in the process of making things right and better.
-
This new rank system has dropped many members' rank but it will really benefit the members of this forum as well as the projects CEOs who will bring bounties in this forum. I support this rank system. Any new update should be clear from admin like how many activity will be required for specific rank. Some ranks is now clear from this discussion but we need more info.
-
I hope and think, for the sake of new rules, more valuable bounties will be listed on the forum. And to rank up is still easy, especially for new members. Even 300 activities for Sr. Member is not that much. On the other hand, I agree with other members that Karma should not be required for lower ranks. Altcoinstalks is a very promising forum but new members should be motivated too.
-
I hope and think, for the sake of new rules, more valuable bounties will be listed on the forum. And to rank up is still easy, especially for new members. Even 300 activities for Sr. Member is not that much. On the other hand, I agree with other members that Karma should not be required for lower ranks. Altcoinstalks is a very promising forum but new members should be motivated too.
You have said right. 300 activities are't too much for Sr. Member. Admin is trying to develop this forum by doing very hard work. Thanks admin for his dedication.
-
We have switched to Activity rank system : https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96515
this post is to answer any of your questions, please ask below
Hey just joined the forum today, searched through the forum for how the ranks work but all efforts proved abortive, any information on how it works and how I can rank up to legendary on the forum would help, thanks in advance.
-
We have switched to Activity rank system : https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96515
this post is to answer any of your questions, please ask below
Hey just joined the forum today, searched through the forum for how the ranks work but all efforts proved abortive, any information on how it works and how I can rank up to legendary on the forum would help, thanks in advance.
Welcome!
Here's what is known so far with the new rules:
1. You need 1,200 posts to reach legendary rank (this number will increase gradually in the future since the target for legendary rank is 2000 posts).
2. Ranking depends on three parameters:
- Registration date : to limit speedy spam ranking.
- Time active on the forum : this applies for some but not all the ranks.
- Karma : this applies for some but not all ranks.
-
~snip~ Even 300 activities for Sr. Member is not that much. ~snip~
You have said right. 300 activities are't too much for Sr. Member. ~snip~
Do you follow the further information about the number of posts required for Sr. Rank on your local boards? In my local board [Indonesia], some members have been successful to reach Sr. Rank with the number of posts around 313 -315 posts or even more.
-
Do you follow the further information about the number of posts required for Sr. Rank on your local boards? In my local board [Indonesia], some members have been successful to reach Sr. Rank with the number of posts around 313 -315 posts or even more.
The exact amount, as it was counted, is 312 activity for Senior member for now. Posts number could be less than activity, so only activity is important to up rank. :)
-
~snip~
The exact amount, as it was counted, is 312 activity for Senior member for now. Posts number could be less than activity, so only activity is important to up rank. :)
Yeah, maybe in a certain case, the number of activity can be different than post. But commonly, in altcoinstalks, the number of both activity and post are the same.
By the way, thank you mate for the additional explanation. :)
-
Yeah, maybe in a certain case, the number of activity can be different than post. But commonly, in altcoinstalks, the number of both activity and post are the same.
Your activity is 1065 and post count is 1136, my activity is 1428 and post count is 1472. So it differed even before new rank rules. And now some users find that their activity stop grow until they stay at the forum the exact amount of days (it differs for different ranks), so post count could grow while activity — not. :)
By the way, thank you mate for the additional explanation. :)
You are welcome! :)
-
I was indeed educated by the loads of questions and answers I had to digest here. I think the admins considered all possibilities and the end result is fair enough. The new ranking system will surely add values to the rank and ranking up still very achievable
-
@admin Will accounts with Plagiarism strike be eligible to rank up?
I just noticed an account with that "badge" and now with +K. That same user was also given multiple -K due to plagiarism before.
-
@admin Will accounts with Plagiarism strike be eligible to rank up?
I just noticed an account with that "badge" and now with +K. That same user was also given multiple -K due to plagiarism before.
plagia strikes can not withdraw alts
and would face punitive actions from time to time
-
Your activity is 1065 and post count is 1136, my activity is 1428 and post count is 1472. So it differed even before new rank rules. And now some users find that their activity stop grow until they stay at the forum the exact amount of days (it differs for different ranks), so post count could grow while activity — not. :)
Forcing someone to post in the forums is not actual way to develop it.
Can you tell me how many posts are required for JR member, full member and so on.
I read somewhere 40 posts, but it didn't change for me till now.
-
Your activity is 1065 and post count is 1136, my activity is 1428 and post count is 1472. So it differed even before new rank rules. And now some users find that their activity stop grow until they stay at the forum the exact amount of days (it differs for different ranks), so post count could grow while activity — not. :)
Forcing someone to post in the forums is not actual way to develop it.
Can you tell me how many posts are required for JR member, full member and so on.
I read somewhere 40 posts, but it didn't change for me till now.
It is around 40 posts. So it can be more or less. I think you will reach Jr. Member soon.
-
Forcing someone to post in the forums is not actual way to develop it.
I mean they weren't forced to create an account in the forum. Posting shouldn't be a problem if they intend to become part of the community. Ranking up is just a benefit of contributing and being actively engaged in the discussions.
-
It is around 40 posts. So it can be more or less. I think you will reach Jr. Member soon.
It is at 45 posts but not for less posts.
Forcing someone to post in the forums is not actual way to develop it.
I mean they weren't forced to create an account in the forum. Posting shouldn't be a problem if they intend to become part of the community. Ranking up is just a benefit of contributing and being actively engaged in the discussions.
We all create for making money in the forums, however some may wish to post regular and some can't like I went offline for a year and returned to this forums again. Posting here really helps to everyone including forum traffic rank, but some won't like to be a regular poster.
I read somewhere in this thread that if someone don't post then their points would get lost. I read something like this in this thread.
-
Your activity is 1065 and post count is 1136, my activity is 1428 and post count is 1472. So it differed even before new rank rules. And now some users find that their activity stop grow until they stay at the forum the exact amount of days (it differs for different ranks), so post count could grow while activity — not. :)
Forcing someone to post in the forums is not actual way to develop it.
Can you tell me how many posts are required for JR member, full member and so on.
I read somewhere 40 posts, but it didn't change for me till now.
It is around 40 posts. So it can be more or less. I think you will reach Jr. Member soon.
Right, She is now enjoying Jr.Member rank. She can post constructive post regularly to increase forum rank but it should be remembered that copy paste is strictly prohibited in this forum.
-
~snip~ Even 300 activities for Sr. Member is not that much. ~snip~
You have said right. 300 activities are't too much for Sr. Member. ~snip~
Do you follow the further information about the number of posts required for Sr. Rank on your local boards? In my local board [Indonesia], some members have been successful to reach Sr. Rank with the number of posts around 313 -315 posts or even more.
In my local board, i have observed that account having 330 activities (posts) can enjoy rankup to Sr.Member. But at first some members got rankup after 350 activities. Probably registration date and other few factors impact on rank system.
-
Your activity is 1065 and post count is 1136, my activity is 1428 and post count is 1472. So it differed even before new rank rules. And now some users find that their activity stop grow until they stay at the forum the exact amount of days (it differs for different ranks), so post count could grow while activity — not. :)
Forcing someone to post in the forums is not actual way to develop it.
Can you tell me how many posts are required for JR member, full member and so on.
I read somewhere 40 posts, but it didn't change for me till now.
It is around 40 posts. So it can be more or less. I think you will reach Jr. Member soon.
Right, She is now enjoying Jr.Member rank. She can post constructive post regularly to increase forum rank but it should be remembered that copy paste is strictly prohibited in this forum.
I am he not she and who is enjoying as a Junior member also what the person get fro being a jr member?
The forum is too much inactive and the alexa rank is too boring here. I am seeing the forum is quiet inactive for most of us.
-
The discussion is going off-topic here.
I am he not she and who is enjoying as a Junior member also what the person get fro being a jr member?
The forum is too much inactive and the alexa rank is too boring here. I am seeing the forum is quiet inactive for most of us.
Are your questions related to the new forum rank answered? If yes, then we can stop here unless you have another on-topic concerns or questions.
If you have other questions/concerns/suggestions, you can open a new topic for that. I'm pretty sure the admin welcomes good contributions from the community.
-
The discussion is going off-topic here.
I am he not she and who is enjoying as a Junior member also what the person get fro being a jr member?
The forum is too much inactive and the alexa rank is too boring here. I am seeing the forum is quiet inactive for most of us.
Are your questions related to the new forum rank answered? If yes, then we can stop here unless you have another on-topic concerns or questions.
If you have other questions/concerns/suggestions, you can open a new topic for that. I'm pretty sure the admin welcomes good contributions from the community.
Hi Thanks for your suggestion, but I was looking from past few days about the ranking system and requirement. I got once on a time that thread and later I can't find also did a search. Could you locate for the thread or post about the levels, where the admin mentioned for required posts for each membership level. Just leave the above poster as it is totally offtopic.
-
Hi Thanks for your suggestion, but I was looking from past few days about the ranking system and requirement. I got once on a time that thread and later I can't find also did a search. Could you locate for the thread or post about the levels, where the admin mentioned for required posts for each membership level.
The ranking system will change from time to time until the final stage. Following the discussions on this particular thread, admin mentioned about the following activity levels to rank up:
Jr. Member - 40 activity
Sr. member - 300 activity
Hero member - 1,000 activity
Legendary - 2,000 activity
Mythical - 6,000 - 7,000 activity
The above hasn't implemented them yet and it will be slowly rolled out by the admin.
References:
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96516.msg600015#msg600015
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96516.msg601005#msg601005
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96516.msg600248#msg600248
If my assumptions are correct, these are the current activity levels for each rank:
Jr. Member - 40 activity
Sr. member - 300 activity
Hero member - 700 activity
Legendary - 1,200 activity
Mythical - 5,000 activity
For activity parameters, check here https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96515
Edit: Here's another table
Newbie = 0 activity
1st step = 1-4 activity
Baby Steps = 5-40 activity
Jr. Member = 46-130 activity
Full Member = 136-300 activity
Sr. Member = 312 activity
Hero Member = 700 activity
Legend = 1200 activity
Mythical = 5000-6000 activity
Baby Steps - after 40 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 7 days had passed.
Jr Member - after 130 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 30 days had passed.
Full Member - after 300 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 60 days had passed.
Sr. Member -?
Hero Member -?
Legend -?
Mythical - after 6000 messages posted, the amount of activity stopped until 186 days had passed.
-
I see their is no full member and the admin made a good decision because of inactive members so their can fall down by this new method.
Thanks for your post as it helped me to understand about the levels.
-
I see their is no full member and the admin made a good decision because of inactive members so their can fall down by this new method.
There is a full member rank. The activity levels would be in between that of junior and senior member. Check also the table I inserted below when I edited my post yesterday. Though it is different from my assumptions, it's not that far off.
-
The admin should be make a post for the ranking system. Most of the member have not any idea about ranking up. So, please create a proper post on Raking. If already created then, please send me the link. I also want to know how to ranking up my altcointalk profile.
-
The admin should be make a post for the ranking system. Most of the member have not any idea about ranking up. So, please create a proper post on Raking. If already created then, please send me the link. I also want to know how to ranking up my altcointalk profile.
Just read my comment above. You should be able to understand why admin hasn't made a definitive post about rankings yet. Instead of worrying about your rank, you can just focus on making contributions to the forum. Ignore your post count or your activity.
-
The admin should be make a post for the ranking system. Most of the member have not any idea about ranking up. So, please create a proper post on Raking. If already created then, please send me the link. I also want to know how to ranking up my altcointalk profile.
, you can just focus on making contributions to the forum. Ignore your post count or your activity.
It is all about loving altcoinstalks forum. Easy ranking is more about quantity. We are after quality not just quantity.
-
The topic is interesting and it strikes me that others are saying it is hard but to be honest, it isn't as harsh as btt forum ranking, in fact, it is way easier and more engaging.
But I am confused in one thing. Let's just say I always online for about 2-3 hours a day in the forum. Does that count as 1 day already or just 2-3 hours total time to get that 7/30/60 days limit in a certain rank?
Because I am a member of btt and the only total time that I have is around 30 days or 1 month and I have been around for like 3 years now. If 2-3 hours is all that counts, that will get me at least 3 years more or less to get Jnr level which is a lot of time if you'd ask me.
I hope I get an answer :)
-
The topic is interesting and it strikes me that others are saying it is hard but to be honest, it isn't as harsh as btt forum ranking, in fact, it is way easier and more engaging.
But I am confused in one thing. Let's just say I always online for about 2-3 hours a day in the forum. Does that count as 1 day already or just 2-3 hours total time to get that 7/30/60 days limit in a certain rank?
Because I am a member of btt and the only total time that I have is around 30 days or 1 month and I have been around for like 3 years now. If 2-3 hours is all that counts, that will get me at least 3 years more or less to get Jnr level which is a lot of time if you'd ask me.
I hope I get an answer :)
The days limit is counted from the date of registration. You even do not need to visit the forum every day for now. ;) But it is expected that the spent online time can become one of characteristics which can influence on rank upgrades in the future. :)
-
The days limit is counted from the date of registration. You even do not need to visit the forum every day for now. ;) But it is expected that the spent online time can become one of characteristics which can influence on rank upgrades in the future. :)
I see, thank you for explaining that in detail. Looking forward to seeing more updates that would make the forum better in the future. ;D
-
online time is being implemented in ranking
-
Can this campaign join also our users? Because on the mycryptoview site there is only possibility to check Bitcoin Talk Signature.
Another note. Here at the altcoinstalks forum we dont have rank Member:
Jr. Member: 1 stake
Member: 3 stakes
Full Member: 5 stakes
Sr.Member: 10 stakes
Hero/Legendary: 20 stakes
added the rank Member to make things a bit easier for bounties
It sounds like a new rank "Member" has been added. Anyone have any specific detail for it?
-
It sounds like a new rank "Member" has been added. Anyone have any specific detail for it?
Only admin has got this information. ;)
-
a standard rank, to have a similar hierarchy to btt, making it easier for bounty hunters
another change in highest ranks is coming
-
a standard rank, to have a similar hierarchy to btt, making it easier for bounty hunters
It's a good decision. This will make bounty managers easier to do their work. And with this decision, I hope will be more bounties to come.
another change in highest ranks is coming
Highest rank? Will we have another higher rank? I think we have already many kinds of ranks.
-
Awaiting details of the new ranking system. Although I don't understand the need to change to make it easier for bounty hunters.
-
Awaiting details of the new ranking system. Although I don't understand the need to change to make it easier for bounty hunters.
Most of the bounties are initially created at the bitcointalk forum and because there is one rank (Member) between Jr. Member and Full Member, bounty managers are confused or didn't change it for altcoinstalks forum. And then arised the problem with the stakes for signature campaign here at the altcoinstalks. So rank Member was also added here.
-
~ snip ~
You are right, bro. Adding member rank should minimize the problem related to ranks and the number of stakes. I remembered we had problems because of having a bit of difference with bitcoin talk. It must be avoided to make the bounty managers feel comfortable. We must support them to be easier to work on two forums at the same time.
-
Hi Thanks for your suggestion, but I was looking from past few days about the ranking system and requirement. I got once on a time that thread and later I can't find also did a search. Could you locate for the thread or post about the levels, where the admin mentioned for required posts for each membership level.
The ranking system will change from time to time until the final stage. Following the discussions on this particular thread, admin mentioned about the following activity levels to rank up:
Jr. Member - 40 activity
Sr. member - 300 activity
Hero member - 1,000 activity
Legendary - 2,000 activity
Mythical - 6,000 - 7,000 activity
The above hasn't implemented them yet and it will be slowly rolled out by the admin.
References:
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96516.msg600015#msg600015
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96516.msg601005#msg601005
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96516.msg600248#msg600248
If my assumptions are correct, these are the current activity levels for each rank:
Jr. Member - 40 activity
Sr. member - 300 activity
Hero member - 700 activity
Legendary - 1,200 activity
Mythical - 5,000 activity
For activity parameters, check here https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96515
Edit: Here's another table
Newbie = 0 activity
1st step = 1-4 activity
Baby Steps = 5-40 activity
Jr. Member = 46-130 activity
Full Member = 136-300 activity
Sr. Member = 312 activity
Hero Member = 700 activity
Legend = 1200 activity
Mythical = 5000-6000 activity
Baby Steps - after 40 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 7 days had passed.
Jr Member - after 130 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 30 days had passed.
Full Member - after 300 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 60 days had passed.
Sr. Member -?
Hero Member -?
Legend -?
Mythical - after 6000 messages posted, the amount of activity stopped until 186 days had passed.
Thanks for the guide im newbie in this forum and i want to understand how to rank up. Is there a limit when i want to post in this forum? so i can avoid being a spam. thanks
-
Thanks for the guide im newbie in this forum and i want to understand how to rank up. Is there a limit when i want to post in this forum? so i can avoid being a spam. thanks
Try not to quote long posts if it is not really needed. There are no exact limits for posting while you do it for real communication. If you see an interesting topic and want to say something important for you, then do post, no need to stop. But if you are just going to achieve another one activity number, than you should not. By the way, if you'll start posting too fast, your activity just'll stop adding for posts for a while, so no problems, but it will not help in faster rank achieving. ;)
-
I have learnt about different ranks in the forum. But I didn't get any clear idea about the requirements for qualifying the higher rank. I know more and more unique posts are required for attaining higher rank but I still don't know how many posts are required for every rank. Can you clear the idea if any one know it?
-
I have learnt about different ranks in the forum. But I didn't get any clear idea about the requirements for qualifying the higher rank. I know more and more unique posts are required for attaining higher rank but I still don't know how many posts are required for every rank. Can you clear the idea if any one know it?
We will not get you the exact numbers. ;) But here: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=10554.msg689649#msg689649 you can find some approximations. We don't want to publish it because some users just try to rank up instead of being active member.
-
Now Altcointalk forum add member rank with minimum 90 post /comments.