how can I know which topic gave me more karma?

[bitmover]

Which topics am I getting karma from?

I know it is possible to also get karma by reporting posts, but I would like to know where I got my from

[Ambatman]

Only certain group(admin) can see karma logs.the function isn't available to users, except maybe karma judge(s) which am not sure if it's just admin or there are others among.

Maybe @admin can help you with the post that gave you the most karma.

[robelneo]

Which topics am I getting karma from?

I know it is possible to also get karma by reporting posts, but I would like to know where I got my from

I also want to know what posts and actions I got my karmas so we can improve our actions here in our forum, I tried to check my profiles to see if there a karma stats but I cannot find them, I hope that stat will be available in the future for members references, the community now is growing so stats that will make them improve their performance here in altcoinstalk.

[tbct_mt2]

We don't need to earn Karma to have things like Sendable Karma.

I don't know how many Karma, both Positive and Negative, one user can leave on another user, within 24 hours or within 30 days.
Because no requirement to send +/- Karma, it can be abused. It can be abused more if there are no limits for 24 hours or 30 days.

Admin, please teach me on this issue. I am new here.

I also want to know what posts and actions I got my karmas so we can improve our actions here in our forum, I tried to check my profiles to see if there a karma stats but I cannot find them, I hope that stat will be available in the future for members references, the community now is growing so stats that will make them improve their performance here in altcoinstalk.

To see it, you will need like a Karma blockchain with Karma transactions and a Karma explorer to check. I like your request because it can help posters to know what posts are appreciated by community, and they can try to make more quality, appreciated posts.

Generally, it will help the forum gains better quality discussions.

Only certain group(admin) can see karma logs.the function isn't available to users, except maybe karma judge(s) which am not sure if it's just admin or there are others among.

Please, where is the source of this information? Could you share me the source link, please.

[bitterguy28]

I don't know where to find or how to check which or whom gave us karma though I have received negative Karma recently in which I don't know why I was awarded when I did nothing wrong from my Migration here and so I need to directly PM the Admin and it seems that there are also some abusers here that sending Negative karma for no reason at all , but its good that the admin acted as i reported the abuse and now its gone in my profile.
but I am also interested to see where and how can earn such Positive Karmas , anyway Thank you for the Admin/s for their fast action towards abuses .

[Freemind]

No user can know in which topics or which users give or take away karma. I think only the administrator (and maybe someone else) has access to the logs, to give an example, I only have access to the moderation logs, but not the karma logs. Knowing which topics (or creating them) have a more general interest can give us an idea if we post interesting things.

@tbct_mt2 here you have more information about karma:

Karma - thank/punish: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=657.0

Karma abuse: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0

[tbct_mt2]

Karma abuse: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0

Thank you for two topics.

I read the topic for Karma abuse and figure out that it is impossible to report Karma abuse or Karma abusers because as normal forum member, I don't know who is abusing Karma issue, who is making incorrect Karma (negative) like personal fighting or attack.

[Ambatman]

Please, where is the source of this information? Could you share me the source link, please.

This was a reply by @joker to a user that asked why their karma disappeared. The limit of karma sendable was also clarified.

How many times can some give a single user a positive karma?

As many times as you see really good posts left by this user.
Not more often than once per some period of time.

Is there a limit to karma awarding?
Or can you provide more information about karma, its benefit to users and to earn and share it?

No limit. https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=657.0

This is disastrous. If you have a hater the person might decide to be giving you a negative karma everyday untill your karma points turn to negative. There should be a strong way to check abuse.

If someone persistently gives -karma just because he doesn't like someone, it is an abuse and an abuser can face with penalties. https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=96965.0


Admin can learn karma logs and if karma abuse is found, all wrong karma can be canceled and the abuser will be penalized. Please, stay friendly, use karma system wisely!

[SamReomo]

No user can know in which topics or which users give or take away karma. I think only the administrator (and maybe someone else) has access to the logs

I think it would be better if every user can see that who has sent the karma and I also believe that negative karma should be removed from the forum as that won't be helpful at all. People may take advantage of the Karma system with that negative karma and many users may get negative karma without doing anything shady.

In Bitcointalk forum sent merits are fully visible to everyone I believe something like that should also be present on this forum. The users who send karma should be shown to those who received karma and also the other members should be able to see the karma senders.

[taufik123]

I think it would be better if every user can see that who has sent the karma and I also believe that negative karma should be removed from the forum as that won't be helpful at all. People may take advantage of the Karma system with that negative karma and many users may get negative karma without doing anything shady.
-snip-

It is still possible to be taken advantage of badly so that hated users have negative karma.
There should be an overhaul or adjustment of the Karma System, and every karma sent by someone should be transparent or visible to anyone.
This would be a fair assessment for posts or members who deserve it.

[Jokers]

I think it would be better if every user can see that who has sent the karma and I also believe that negative karma should be removed from the forum as that won't be helpful at all. People may take advantage of the Karma system with that negative karma and many users may get negative karma without doing anything shady.

In Bitcointalk forum sent merits are fully visible to everyone I believe something like that should also be present on this forum. The users who send karma should be shown to those who received karma and also the other members should be able to see the karma senders.

When you just want to transfer something from some other forum just as it done there, you forget that there is a system of different things which make forum work. Negative karma is important to fight with low quality posters, with those ones who answer the first post on the 20th page and many other things. Many of this will not be moderated, but users themselves can show that they are disappointed with such behavior.

Knowing who give you karma, especially negative karma, can lead to karma wars, which will lead to penalties to many users. We don't need it.

AltcoinsTalks is not BTT, we have our own history and traditions.

[SamReomo]

There should be an overhaul or adjustment of the Karma System, and every karma sent by someone should be transparent or visible to anyone.
This would be a fair assessment for posts or members who deserve it.

Yes, I think that's the most important step which the forum administrator needs to take because everyone deserves to know that who sent them the karma and for which posts they have received the karma points.

Negative karma is important to fight with low quality posters, with those ones who answer the first post on the 20th page and many other things.

If negative karma doesn't gets removed then the user who sent that negative karma should at least show his/her reason for sending that negative karma. Another important thing can be done is to have a report against that user like members of Bitcointalk does on reputation board.

If others agree that the user who sent the negative karma is justifiable then it should be allowed otherwise the user should be able to remove that negative karma if the main reason for sending that was a personal issue.

I know altcoinstalks is a different forum and it has its own history but if something that could be helpful for all members then why not to somehow implement it.

[Hatchy]

Which topics am I getting karma from?

I know it is possible to also get karma by reporting posts, but I would like to know where I got my from

It much harder to tell, which topic earns you karma. I hope the system is slightly changed in the future as it would be nice to know what post earned me a positive or negative karma so as to help me improve or learn and give a better response on my next encounter with such questions or post. Well as for me I do sometimes leave a hint of me dropping off some karma to the individual something like

+1

it's my way of telling that I gave out the karma to op or the poster.

[Ambatman]

Well knowing who sent a karma isn't Really that important because of the existence of negative karma. It would definitely sprang a war like some kind of revenge. @Hatchy nearly wrote same thing you just said. Thank Goodness i read your reply😅. Knowing what post gave you karma would help alot as well as assisting in knowing if a person was given negative karma out of a fight.

But like i would always say the forum is more than 5 years and this wouldn't be the first time this was brought up, so there's a reason it might still be ongoing.

[PX-Z]

It much harder to tell, which topic earns you karma. I hope the system is slightly changed in the future as it would be nice to know what post earned me a positive or negative karma so as to help me improve or learn and give a better response on my next encounter with such questions or post.

Yes, this is a reasonable request to have for users to improve and learn what kind of respond they did, why they get positive or negative karma. You don't need to know who gives you karma but a stat should be available for what topic or reply where you got it. Hope admin can reconsider such purpose.