First of all, I'd like to thank The Hunter (the plaintiff) for his efforts in helping the forum in fighting cheating in campaigns and multi-accounts. I need to emphasize that we as judges always use facts and legal rules in making decisions. We are of course always on the neutral side in deciding every case.
Based on what the plaintiff conveyed, we have carried out further investigation and analysis regarding this case.
With the facts provided, we can draw several important points regarding this case:
1. There is only 1 type of evidence, namely proof of transactions between wallets.
2. There is no supporting evidence that the sending wallet and the recipient's wallet are owned by one person.
3. The defense given by Anshor1 is reasonable because it is supported by logical reasons.
4. The assumption of similarity in writing style or other things must be proven in detail. It cannot be measured just based on conclusions from the use of one or two words whose use is not massive. Meanwhile, for similarities in the time of account activity on the forum, further evidence is needed (in the form of photos, screenshot, data, etc.).
5. Communities are not prohibited on the altcoinstalks forum.
From the points above, the evidence provided is still weak because it lacks supporting admissible evidence. The judge cannot find the suspect guilty on weak evidence. Even though there are assumptions conveyed, they cannot be strong admissible evidence without the support of theory, data, photos, and other admissible evidence. Debate and differences of opinion in this prosecution are normal, but judges only draw conclusions based on the available admissible evidence. Admissible evidence that has clear benchmarks and is not abstract and subjective.
We close this case with the following conclusions:
Declare that the accused is not been proven guilty of what was alleged by the plaintiff.
Thank You
"If the prosecution cannot prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, the jury or judge must acquit them"
https://thedefenders.net/blogs/acquittals/
https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/beyond_a_reasonable_doubt