Altcoins Talks - Cryptocurrency Forum

Further Discussions => Economics , Sociology & Politics => Topic started by: DrBeer on January 31, 2024, 06:17:39 PM

Title: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on January 31, 2024, 06:17:39 PM
India is the new leader of the global south .... And a replacement for China ?

China has recently started to openly surrender its position. both politically and economically.
Politics is not the place to discuss, but the economy leaves much to be desired. Although it is partly a consequence of politics.

But to the main point - in the "Global South" today there is a situation when yesterday's leader, China, can no longer fulfill this role (although it wants to), and no one can take this place except India, due to many reasons.

At the same time, India looks much more attractive to the "Global West" than China, which has decided to go into a dictatorship inside, and has a rather dubious foreign policy. China has ceased to be a profitable global factory, plus purely political contradictions with the West. It was the outflow of Western investments, and the decline in demand of the Western market for products manufactured in China, that became the catalyst that accelerated the 3 processes:
- Import growth
- Reduced exports.
- And as a consequence, a shrinking trade surplus.

At the same time, a very complicated situation is brewing inside China with a chain of bankruptcies of budget-forming companies. Of course, China will hide it, but as they say "you can't cheat arithmetic, and 2+3 will never be 10". Another problem is the relocation of Western assembly sites from China. Large regional high-tech companies are also leaving Chinese sites - for example, Samsung.

And guess where all this is moving to ? That's right - to INDIA ! Stable, predictable, adopting the Western vector of development, and moving away from contacts with "dubious countries". India does not "beat in hysterics of dedolarization", does not conduct dubious negotiations, and does not support economic terrorism of some other countries against the world economy. India benefits from stability, long-term mutually beneficial relations with the developed world, a well-deserved place in the world economy and financial system, and realization of its regional ambitions, which China is beginning to lose by failing to implement 2 projects:
- "Yuanization" of the BRICS countries
- An attempt to "put the same BRICS club members on the needle" of importing Chinese products.
It was a poorly concealed but absolutely understandable attempt to save the economy, but ...

What about India? A country with a huge territory and great human potential, developed industry, and long-established ties with the Western world. India has a very good education, and not a small middle class, with good education from western educational institutions. In India, stealing Western technology is not part of the economy as it is in China, for example. In terms of logistics to EU and African countries, India is more conveniently located. Plus in India there is no problem of population aging, which started to give itself in China "thanks to" the policy - "one family - one child". It is also worth paying attention to the IT market - it is perfectly developed in India and continues to compete with other markets. Plus - wiser, more balanced and liberal business policy is what China is losing and will not contribute to the free development of the economy.


So the question is - what do you think about India's potential, opportunities and prospects, in light of the idea of India becoming at least the economical "Head of the Global South", and possibly "one of the poles of the world system" ?
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: Peter90 on January 31, 2024, 08:13:03 PM
India's gold demand to rise in 2024 (https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/indias-gold-demand-rise-2024-despite-subdued-march-quarter-wgc-2024-01-31/)

Higher purchases in the world's second-biggest gold consumer could support prices , which are trading near record highs.

India's gold demand has been stuck between 700 and 800 metric tons in the past five years, but it is expected to break out of this range and rise to between 800 and 900 tons in 2024, Somasundaram P.R., CEO of WGC's Indian operations told Reuters.

"Given the fact that high prices have now been absorbed and economic growth is robust, demand is resetting its base to 800 to 900 tons," he said.


Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy?
I don't know. What I know...
China = 1st gold consumer
India = 2nd gold consumer
After the upcoming world currency reset they will become... 2 world superpowers!  8)
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: electronicash on January 31, 2024, 08:27:21 PM

if India is the new leader of the south, the US government would have want to war with them already. obviously they are not interested to nuke India.

that's how the world works as far as i know. the aging leader whose fire power is draining everyday and not respected by the Houti group in West Asia would surely want to show their strength to overpower a coming leader. much the same as the Alpha wolf being challenged by new Alpha.

China's economy could be crumbling too but which one will crumble the most especially they fall?  the world know very well that Russia isn't as rich as China and India isn't as rich as China too. but they don't have a huge debt to China.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on January 31, 2024, 09:37:44 PM

if India is the new leader of the south, the US government would have want to war with them already. obviously they are not interested to nuke India.

that's how the world works as far as i know. the aging leader whose fire power is draining everyday and not respected by the Houti group in West Asia would surely want to show their strength to overpower a coming leader. much the same as the Alpha wolf being challenged by new Alpha.

China's economy could be crumbling too but which one will crumble the most especially they fall?  the world know very well that Russia isn't as rich as China and India isn't as rich as China too. but they don't have a huge debt to China.

Very erroneous opinion !
First of all, India is a country that has chosen the path of development, the Western vector of interactions, economic ties, and even in the direction of military-industrial direction - also the Western vector.
For the Western world, India is a leader in the region, which is predictable, not inclined to aggression and support of dubious regimes and groups.  The West is interested, after China chose the path of aggravation of relations with the West, in transferring investments and production to India, which is already being observed. India is a more open and much more decent partner in international relations.
India is the largest country in the world by population, and to build a stable community - they are very interested in deep integration into the western economy, on a mutually beneficial relationship.
So you are not very justified in accusing the US of such intentions.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on January 31, 2024, 09:43:22 PM
India's gold demand to rise in 2024 (https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/indias-gold-demand-rise-2024-despite-subdued-march-quarter-wgc-2024-01-31/)

Higher purchases in the world's second-biggest gold consumer could support prices , which are trading near record highs.

India's gold demand has been stuck between 700 and 800 metric tons in the past five years, but it is expected to break out of this range and rise to between 800 and 900 tons in 2024, Somasundaram P.R., CEO of WGC's Indian operations told Reuters.

"Given the fact that high prices have now been absorbed and economic growth is robust, demand is resetting its base to 800 to 900 tons," he said.


Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy?
I don't know. What I know...
China = 1st gold consumer
India = 2nd gold consumer
After the upcoming world currency reset they will become... 2 world superpowers!  8)

Leadership is a very unstable title, especially when today's leader has begun to suffer from inflated self-esteem, and has begun to unconsciously or consciously destroy his former greatness and power. The flight of Western capital and technology from China is making China's feet sandy, without which China will not be able to further develop its export-oriented economy. it looks like China is becoming a "paper tiger", and the place of a leader, especially of such an interesting region, will never be empty. And objectively, there are no other candidates for this role except India in the region. At least, I do not see others in the space from the Asian-African region to the ocean.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: Peter90 on February 01, 2024, 08:48:42 AM
What about India? A country with a huge territory and great human potential, developed industry, and long-established ties with the Western world. India has a very good education, and not a small middle class, with good education from western educational institutions. In India, stealing Western technology is not part of the economy as it is in China, for example. In terms of logistics to EU and African countries, India is more conveniently located. Plus in India there is no problem of population aging, which started to give itself in China "thanks to" the policy - "one family - one child". It is also worth paying attention to the IT market - it is perfectly developed in India and continues to compete with other markets. Plus - wiser, more balanced and liberal business policy is what China is losing and will not contribute to the free development of the economy.

... plus political stability ...

(https://assets.zerohedge.com/s3fs-public/styles/inline_image_mobile/public/inline-images/Approval-of-World-Leaders-2024.jpg?itok=foLelTr6)


zerohedge.com (https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/modi-first-scholz-worst-ranking-approval-ratings-world-leaders)
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 01, 2024, 10:38:56 AM
What about India? A country with a huge territory and great human potential, developed industry, and long-established ties with the Western world. India has a very good education, and not a small middle class, with good education from western educational institutions. In India, stealing Western technology is not part of the economy as it is in China, for example. In terms of logistics to EU and African countries, India is more conveniently located. Plus in India there is no problem of population aging, which started to give itself in China "thanks to" the policy - "one family - one child". It is also worth paying attention to the IT market - it is perfectly developed in India and continues to compete with other markets. Plus - wiser, more balanced and liberal business policy is what China is losing and will not contribute to the free development of the economy.

... plus political stability ...

(https://assets.zerohedge.com/s3fs-public/styles/inline_image_mobile/public/inline-images/Approval-of-World-Leaders-2024.jpg?itok=foLelTr6)


zerohedge.com (https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/modi-first-scholz-worst-ranking-approval-ratings-world-leaders)

This is also a good indicator for India. I have several acquaintances in China, I talk to them from time to time, and according to them, "Xi Jinping is not the one we need". The approval rating there is far from Modi's. At the same time, we realize that we will not see the rating for China, or it will be the "official" version with a rating close to 110% :).
Stability and predictability is something that has always been valued in the West, used to the fact that a partner (politics, economy, any other alliance) will be predictable, stick to its commitments. And this is something that China has clearly completely lost. As you know - it takes a couple of seconds to ruin your image, but it can take years and decades to restore it. That is why the west will be looking for and supporting a new leader in the region as China has lost its credibility and political face
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: joniboini on February 01, 2024, 10:47:11 AM
I have several acquaintances in China, I talk to them from time to time, and according to them, "Xi Jinping is not the one we need". The approval rating there is far from Modi's. At the same time, we realize that we will not see the rating for China, or it will be the "official" version with a rating close to 110% :).
Is this sentiment prevalent on a national scale, or just a minority coming from an opposition party/opposing group? I'm not sure it is possible to change the political system in China anyway, so this stability is probably not a thing that they even consider. Especially if they can shut down any opposition easily without any repercussions. It would be a miracle if a revolution happened though. On the other hand, SEA is also growing rapidly, although most of them are consumers or low-paid workers. Some of them have relations with China still, considering how many infrastructure projects use their capital to build. CMIIW.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: electronicash on February 01, 2024, 06:51:21 PM

if India is the new leader of the south, the US government would have want to war with them already. obviously they are not interested to nuke India.

that's how the world works as far as i know. the aging leader whose fire power is draining everyday and not respected by the Houti group in West Asia would surely want to show their strength to overpower a coming leader. much the same as the Alpha wolf being challenged by new Alpha.

China's economy could be crumbling too but which one will crumble the most especially they fall?  the world know very well that Russia isn't as rich as China and India isn't as rich as China too. but they don't have a huge debt to China.

Very erroneous opinion !
First of all, India is a country that has chosen the path of development, the Western vector of interactions, economic ties, and even in the direction of military-industrial direction - also the Western vector.
For the Western world, India is a leader in the region, which is predictable, not inclined to aggression and support of dubious regimes and groups.  The West is interested, after China chose the path of aggravation of relations with the West, in transferring investments and production to India, which is already being observed. India is a more open and much more decent partner in international relations.
India is the largest country in the world by population, and to build a stable community - they are very interested in deep integration into the western economy, on a mutually beneficial relationship.
So you are not very justified in accusing the US of such intentions.

well it is known to all parts of the world how the US government subdue most of the countries that tries to rise up. from Argentina, Germany, Russia, China to Japan. the little ones, the tiny countries are just peony to them a regime change are the answers to subdue them but the rest can turn to trade wars to financial sanctions.

so for India to rise without Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) i doubt that. because China had already covered almost the entire Middle East or the one they now started calling East Asia.

so lets say India is the leader of the south, which bloc did they create again? because so ffar its only BRICS and SCO that exist that has the most dominant rivaling NATO or the G7.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: 0t3p0t on February 02, 2024, 01:30:47 PM
what do you think about India's potential, opportunities and prospects, in light of the idea of India becoming at least the economical "Head of the Global South", and possibly "one of the poles of the world system" ?
Based on my observation regarding India's progress and it's economic growth, there is really huge possibility of dethroning China in terms of being the new King of the south. Foreign investments in China is fleeing and possibly be investing and making business with India. The new trend of selling military hardware India has an edge on this as they have huge market compared to China which is only their few allies buying arms from them as they lost their trust from it's closest neighbors which is switching to Indian products.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 03, 2024, 09:13:22 AM
well it is known to all parts of the world how the US government subdue most of the countries that tries to rise up. from Argentina, Germany, Russia, China to Japan. the little ones, the tiny countries are just peony to them a regime change are the answers to subdue them but the rest can turn to trade wars to financial sanctions.

so for India to rise without Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) i doubt that. because China had already covered almost the entire Middle East or the one they now started calling East Asia.

so lets say India is the leader of the south, which bloc did they create again? because so ffar its only BRICS and SCO that exist that has the most dominant rivaling NATO or the G7.


I will say at once - you make a dubious statement that "the whole world knows..." and then, based on this erroneous opinion, build your answer. I disagree, because the first statement is not true. Or let's put it this way - arguments and evidence in favor of your opinion ? But preferably not only manifestations but also voice the reasons, so it will be clear and transparent where you or I was wrong ? Ok? Let's try again?

Regarding "China has covered all of Asia" is also very controversial.  I for example can argue and will provide proof that China is very insidious, giving its investment and then taking 100 times more, ruining the one to whom it gave the loan. We can discuss such examples. And I think that many countries have already guessed the predatory concept of Chinese investment. And China uses bribery, corruption and many other things that Western countries have never dreamed of.

Regarding BRICS. If earlier it was an alliance for realistic solutions to economic issues of allied countries, now it has become purely political, and some of the participants are trying to manipulate others, solely for their own political benefit, which many have already begun to guess and began to openly talk about it. For example, India. It does not want countries with dubious reputations to circumvent the sanctions they deservedly received. I am sure that others are beginning to realize what they are being used for by the BRICS allies who are not clean in their hands. So the prospects for BRICS are very dim as a real powerful counterweight to the G7.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: electronicash on February 03, 2024, 08:57:58 PM
well it is known to all parts of the world how the US government subdue most of the countries that tries to rise up. from Argentina, Germany, Russia, China to Japan. the little ones, the tiny countries are just peony to them a regime change are the answers to subdue them but the rest can turn to trade wars to financial sanctions.

so for India to rise without Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) i doubt that. because China had already covered almost the entire Middle East or the one they now started calling East Asia.

so lets say India is the leader of the south, which bloc did they create again? because so ffar its only BRICS and SCO that exist that has the most dominant rivaling NATO or the G7.


I will say at once - you make a dubious statement that "the whole world knows..." and then, based on this erroneous opinion, build your answer. I disagree, because the first statement is not true. Or let's put it this way - arguments and evidence in favor of your opinion ? But preferably not only manifestations but also voice the reasons, so it will be clear and transparent where you or I was wrong ? Ok? Let's try again?

Regarding "China has covered all of Asia" is also very controversial.  I for example can argue and will provide proof that China is very insidious, giving its investment and then taking 100 times more, ruining the one to whom it gave the loan. We can discuss such examples. And I think that many countries have already guessed the predatory concept of Chinese investment. And China uses bribery, corruption and many other things that Western countries have never dreamed of.

Regarding BRICS. If earlier it was an alliance for realistic solutions to economic issues of allied countries, now it has become purely political, and some of the participants are trying to manipulate others, solely for their own political benefit, which many have already begun to guess and began to openly talk about it. For example, India. It does not want countries with dubious reputations to circumvent the sanctions they deservedly received. I am sure that others are beginning to realize what they are being used for by the BRICS allies who are not clean in their hands. So the prospects for BRICS are very dim as a real powerful counterweight to the G7.

how can China ruin the country that loans to them when their interests is lower than IMF interest?
"the whole world knows." not everyone knows i guess because only the ones who think logically knows, the rest who don't think are swallowed by what the media says.
NATO is also political. everything is political even the sports today, have you noticed its only UFC that can speak against the woke?

the democracy that they know is the individual's democracy but what China offers is the country's democracy. every country has to have democracy that they can develop their own. African countries has a choice. BREXIT for example. Britain had exit but what is the catch to them? they don't have the choice to say NO when US government wants them to build up their army, they have to otherwise they'd be sanctioned. now EU have to fight Russia because they said so.

middle east is getting rich they are now developing and turning the desert to green and even extending the sea on their desert so what US military doing there which every corner in that region has military camp.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 04, 2024, 12:01:29 PM
....

how can China ruin the country that loans to them when their interests is lower than IMF interest?
"the whole world knows." not everyone knows i guess because only the ones who think logically knows, the rest who don't think are swallowed by what the media says.
NATO is also political. everything is political even the sports today, have you noticed its only UFC that can speak against the woke?

the democracy that they know is the individual's democracy but what China offers is the country's democracy. every country has to have democracy that they can develop their own. African countries has a choice. BREXIT for example. Britain had exit but what is the catch to them? they don't have the choice to say NO when US government wants them to build up their army, they have to otherwise they'd be sanctioned. now EU have to fight Russia because they said so.

middle east is getting rich they are now developing and turning the desert to green and even extending the sea on their desert so what US military doing there which every corner in that region has military camp.


Yep, I see what you mean :)
NATO and EU should already fight against Russia  ;D

Let me try to help you get back to reality.
1. the EU and the US and Britain and the entire civilized world fighting Russia is a response to terrorism and the violation of all the commitments made. I guess you won't deny that this "struggle" didn't happen until 2014 for some reason ? And what happened then? So the conclusion is that you are confusing cause with effect, or deliberately forgetting about the causes.  But let's finish about politics, it's a separate topic, and let's get back to China!

And here I will try to show you the real picture.
Yes, China does give cheap loans. You're right. The only thing you are mistaken about is your estimation of what it leads to.
First of all, loans, whether from China or the IMF, do not destroy a country.
Secondly - China does not aim to destroy an investment. It aims to IMPROVE the investment. Do you understand what this means? No ? Still think China is nice and friendly?  Then a simple example from life, which you can check, and then look for other data about other "friendly investments" of China. So. Sri Lanka, port hub project. I won't give the actual figures, I don't remember, but the gist remains.
1. China is promoting a maritime hub project at the Sri Lankan government level, which can bring huge profits to the country. Okay, it looks nice. The government takes the bait.....
2. China says - listen, we have a huge experience, we will make you a business plan, and we are ready to invest, for example 10 billion dollars. Of course for small projects, not like the IMF. The government takes the bait....
3. Chinese specialists make a business plan, it looks very attractive, and yes its value is 10 billion dollars. The government signs the contract and the work is done.
But there are small nuances
- China says - we are not the IMF, we are your friends, let our specialists do the project documentation! We are friends, what do you care who you pay money to? Ok? Ok !
- And let our companies supply equipment and materials ! We are friends, not IMF! Okay? Ok !
and many other things Chinese companies do. Does he realize what's going on? China has given 10 billion loan, receives interest for it, plus most of the loan is already returned to .... China. And Sri Lanka still has to pay the 10 billion + interest.
But that's not all.
The construction is finished, everything is fine. The government launches the hub.... and nothing happens! No queue of ships, no contracts, no nothing ! You haven't guessed who's responsible for this yet?  :)
Some time passes and China says - dear friends, we are not the IMF, but why are you not making profits and why is the project not working, which according to our calculations should already be paying off !?? Perhaps you are doing something wrong and violating our friendly obligations.  And the friendly pressure begins...  China is demanding loan payments, Sri Lanka doesn't have the money, but we do. And when the Sri Lankan government throws up its hands and says - we have no money to pay ! And FRIENDLY china says ok, no problem. Let's do this - we buy this project for 10% of its value, this amount will be written off as a loan that you owe us ! And so it happens with the majority of Chinese friendly investments - study the subject area, you will understand what really happens ! Isn't that IMF ? Is it true that China does not destroy but only helps ? :)

Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: electronicash on February 04, 2024, 07:46:07 PM
lol

clearly there is a huge disconnection of the media versus the real world here.  everyday the politicians are saying China is the greatest threat and should be decoupling from China yet the most consumers of Alibaba are from US. just recently Consumer Electronic Show (CES) in Vegas was participated by 1/3 of the 400 tech companies have connections back to mainland China.

politicians keep demonizing China making the world thinks its the bogey man when they have not bombed countries. but they are rising sure and they will be the leader too. if India can build factories in Mexico like the Chinese did, I shall believe it but i don't see it happening.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: Peter90 on February 05, 2024, 11:47:25 AM

if India is the new leader of the south, the US government...

India is the new leader of the south  :D
 

(https://images.moneycontrol.com/static-mcnews/2024/01/WhatsApp-Image-2024-01-15-at-18.41.17.jpeg)                                                (https://cdn.statcdn.com/Infographic/images/normal/31587.jpeg)



(https://caribbeannewsglobal.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/oecd_prj-2025.jpg)

Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: bitbit97 on February 05, 2024, 12:08:34 PM
Dont know what positions China is loosing, but (it might sound bad or disappoint someone, so sorry in advance) India is easier to be manipulated than China. I am talking about army or firepower. Imho India is no match for China. When someone tries to control China, it can show teeth. Can India do the same? Or it will accept every offer from any foreign country, even if it is less profitable than offer to China ? Also generations will pass, when people will change their «China = cheaper» vision. What I say that even if India takes economical leadership, people will still prefer China.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 05, 2024, 08:46:20 PM
Dont know what positions China is loosing, but (it might sound bad or disappoint someone, so sorry in advance) India is easier to be manipulated than China. I am talking about army or firepower. Imho India is no match for China. When someone tries to control China, it can show teeth. Can India do the same? Or it will accept every offer from any foreign country, even if it is less profitable than offer to China ? Also generations will pass, when people will change their «China = cheaper» vision. What I say that even if India takes economical leadership, people will still prefer China.

That's your opinion, and it has a right to exist too :)

I'll tell you what China is losing. And this is not my fantasy, it will be facts that you can easily check.
- Investment.
- Access to technology.
- Access to institutions of higher education in technological areas (pharmaceuticals, medicine, etc.).
- Investment attractiveness
- Markets (western countries)
- Political weight in the developed world


PS The times of "Chinese=deshovny" are long gone. The growth of the market has led to increased competition in the labor market, which led to an increase in wages, which ultimately affected the cost of production. as you understand - it has increased. The second thing that affects the cost is investment in production. Large companies are modernizing and this is also reflected in the cost of production. Yes, while it is a little cheaper than for example European goods, but you and the standard of living do not compare ! And there are still many manufacturers who have "China = cheap and low quality", this is sold to "brotherly countries", where the population's income does not allow you to buy quality and therefore more expensive goods.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: electronicash on February 05, 2024, 09:31:48 PM
Quote
China = cheap and low quality

didn't the Chinese build some bridges in US?
how can China lose access to technology when they are the first to have 5G and they are already up developing 9G.  they also have the space exploration advantage which they even partnered with spaceX.

stop watching the news, the media is totally disconnected to the reality. and this disconnection is pretty much what they feed to the minds of the people.

i'm not from China but basically, if they have been favored by the African countries and the Middle East countries, its because of how they helped them develop projects in the region with all the new technology they have which united them all. no one does that but China even i they are yet not the leader.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 05, 2024, 10:42:20 PM
Quote
China = cheap and low quality

didn't the Chinese build some bridges in US?
how can China lose access to technology when they are the first to have 5G and they are already up developing 9G.  they also have the space exploration advantage which they even partnered with spaceX.

stop watching the news, the media is totally disconnected to the reality. and this disconnection is pretty much what they feed to the minds of the people.

i'm not from China but basically, if they have been favored by the African countries and the Middle East countries, its because of how they helped them develop projects in the region with all the new technology they have which united them all. no one does that but China even i they are yet not the leader.


You have selected some "indicative" examples.
Yes, there are areas where China is in a good position. But we need to understand where it all came from, where the technology comes from, where the specialists come from (training, experience, practice). You probably know that the United States and the EU are now reducing the access of Chinese residents to higher educational institutions (technological) and are also introducing very strict controls regarding access to information and technologies of Chinese citizens in other countries. the reason is banal - theft, massive, of all technologies that Chinese specialists can get their hands on. So the fact that they have something of really high quality does not mean that they developed it :)
And the question is why, after the United States sharply limited China’s access to technology and planned to move high-tech sites outside of China, China began to get very nervous and began to actively seek dialogue with the United States, if they are doing so well with their technologies?! Try to explain this "phenomenon" :)
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: Agbe on February 05, 2024, 11:46:48 PM
I am not too good in international Growth Domestic Product {GDP} analysis for each countries for now because I am not focusing on that at the moment. But even at that base on productive and their uses in the whole whole world, and if I am not mistaken, China's products are still more the in the African international market and some other global markets in the world so to what extent do you know that India is the highest has the highest GDP against China.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 06, 2024, 09:18:33 AM
I am not too good in international Growth Domestic Product {GDP} analysis for each countries for now because I am not focusing on that at the moment. But even at that base on productive and their uses in the whole whole world, and if I am not mistaken, China's products are still more the in the African international market and some other global markets in the world so to what extent do you know that India is the highest has the highest GDP against China.

The slight nuance is that the main export revenue to China was generated by the Western market. This was the case until about 2021/2022 (I may be wrong, but it is approximately so).
No offense to other regions, but for example the African region cannot give such a volume in absolute terms and in terms of profit. Yes I know that China sells a lot of goods to African countries, but these are goods with lower production costs and lower added value than goods sold to the US, EU, Canada,.....  Plus China needs freely convertible currency, which is mostly provided by western consumption markets and less by African/Asian markets
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 06, 2024, 06:35:34 PM
Just today's news: There is a major shift in global markets as investors are pulling billions of dollars out of China's "collapsing" economy and funneling it to India and other fast-growing countries. This is reported by Bloomberg.

Two decades ago, investors bet on China as the country with the world's fastest economic growth. However, now the situation is rapidly changing. China is suffering from chronic economic problems and deteriorating relations with the West.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-06/goldman-morgan-stanley-bet-on-india-stocks-as-wall-street-shifts-from-china

As we can see - the success of the Chinese economy is nothing but a consequence of Western investments.... And I am sure - if China's prospects were attractive, such investors would not leave China. Let's draw conclusions...
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: electronicash on February 06, 2024, 08:12:27 PM

Quote
China = cheap and low quality

didn't the Chinese build some bridges in US?
how can China lose access to technology when they are the first to have 5G and they are already up developing 9G.  they also have the space exploration advantage which they even partnered with spaceX.

stop watching the news, the media is totally disconnected to the reality. and this disconnection is pretty much what they feed to the minds of the people.

i'm not from China but basically, if they have been favored by the African countries and the Middle East countries, its because of how they helped them develop projects in the region with all the new technology they have which united them all. no one does that but China even i they are yet not the leader.


You have selected some "indicative" examples.
Yes, there are areas where China is in a good position. But we need to understand where it all came from, where the technology comes from, where the specialists come from (training, experience, practice). You probably know that the United States and the EU are now reducing the access of Chinese residents to higher educational institutions (technological) and are also introducing very strict controls regarding access to information and technologies of Chinese citizens in other countries. the reason is banal - theft, massive, of all technologies that Chinese specialists can get their hands on. So the fact that they have something of really high quality does not mean that they developed it :)
And the question is why, after the United States sharply limited China’s access to technology and planned to move high-tech sites outside of China, China began to get very nervous and began to actively seek dialogue with the United States, if they are doing so well with their technologies?! Try to explain this "phenomenon" :)

what are you talking about? lol  china's been developing more tech than any countries today.  didn't china the first to invest gun powder?

anyway, if the US government will have debts from India as big as their debt from China, i would then believe India will be the next leader but as long as China never get involve in war as seem to be what is pushed today, none can prevent China from rising.
media seem to be pushing war India vs China even when they are both in BRICS. jesus.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: retreat on February 07, 2024, 08:02:59 AM
India is very likely to be able to replace China as the country with the largest economy in the world, if its economic growth can be stable at 8-9% per year, if India cannot achieve this it will be very difficult for them to be able to displace China and America who are currently in positions 1 and 2. We don't need to discuss dreams for the next 10-20 years, let's just see how the Modi government is now and how it decides to bring India to achieve economic growth above 8%, if he can't do that then India will still be in the top 3-5 positions in the world.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 07, 2024, 09:13:30 AM
.....
what are you talking about? lol  china's been developing more tech than any countries today.  didn't china the first to invest gun powder?

anyway, if the US government will have debts from India as big as their debt from China, i would then believe India will be the next leader but as long as China never get involve in war as seem to be what is pushed today, none can prevent China from rising.
media seem to be pushing war India vs China even when they are both in BRICS. jesus.

Sorry, but this myth is very easy to debunk :)
What I agree with is that China is still the "world's factory". But it doesn't have as much of its own technology as it would like. Let me remind you once again, it sounds not very pleasant, but the fact is that China has been and remains the largest "illegal user of other people's technologies", this is a very mild description of the essence, so as not to offend anyone.
It produces a lot at the expense of Western technology. I am not saying that 100% of "appropriated technologies", but a LARGE part.

And let me remind you once again - if China is so good with its own technologies and high-level research and development, why do they strive to get education, practice, high-tech equipment and technologies from the West? And they get very "worried" when the West starts limiting access to them !
China became modern China thanks to Western money and Western technology. Now this situation is changing, that is why China is frantically looking for a way out, realizing that being cut off from investments and technologies, it will slip back to the level of China of the 70s of the last century.

PS About the war - are you serious?! :) Is someone pushing China? Probably the reptiloids and definitely the USA? :)))) Study the history of this conflict and it will become easier for you, because you will lose the hard dissonance in many questions !
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 07, 2024, 09:21:22 PM
India is very likely to be able to replace China as the country with the largest economy in the world, if its economic growth can be stable at 8-9% per year, if India cannot achieve this it will be very difficult for them to be able to displace China and America who are currently in positions 1 and 2. We don't need to discuss dreams for the next 10-20 years, let's just see how the Modi government is now and how it decides to bring India to achieve economic growth above 8%, if he can't do that then India will still be in the top 3-5 positions in the world.

It is probably still too early to talk about the ability of any country or union to reach the level of the USA. even the EU economy could not do it, and I think that for any individual country - it is still from the realm of almost fantasy. That's the reality. It is possible to talk about it, provided that the US economy "drops" a lot. And I think this is a topic for a separate discussion.

Regarding India and the indicators you mentioned, I would rather agree than disagree. These are very good indicators that GUARANTEE strong growth of the Indian economy, and accordingly the growth of investment attractiveness, and this is the strongest dope (in a good sense) for the development of entire industries and the economy as a whole! At the same time, I do not exclude that in case of further decline and degradation of the Chinese economy, a few percent lower indicators will be acceptable for India. But let us not guess, we will observe the development of the situation, including the global situation
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: Peter90 on February 10, 2024, 08:37:09 AM
Crazy Rich Asians... (https://www.zerohedge.com/personal-finance/crazy-rich-asians)


(https://cdn.statcdn.com/Infographic/images/normal/23648.jpeg)



The Ambanis’ wealth remains more than double that of the next clan in the ranking of Asia's richest families, the Hartonos of Indonesia's Djarum brand.

It also earns them rank 8 among the world’s wealthiest legacy families. All in all, the 2024 ranking now features four Indian families in the top 10, up from just two last year.

New additions are the Jindal family, who made their wealth in different industrial sectors, and Birla family, who run conglomerate Aditya Birla Group.

Two families each hailing from Hong Kong and Thailand are also among the top 10, with Thai Red Bull inventors, the Yoovidhyas, in rank 6.


Chinese emigrants are quite common among the list of Asia’s most wealthy families.

Chearavanont patriarch Chia Ek Chor came to Thailand from Southern China in 1921 and started out importing and exporting seeds, vegetables and animal products between Bangkok, China and Hong Kong.

Outside of the top 10, the Pao/Woo family (rank 11) and the inventors of Oyster Sauce, the Lee family (rank 17), made their fortunes in Hong Kong after emigrating from Mainland China. The story is similar with the Sy family (rank 14) who are conglomerate owners in the Philippines.

Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 12, 2024, 07:42:33 PM
And some more positive news from India:
"India is set to distance itself from its biggest arms supplier, amid Russia losing its ability to supply ammunition and spare parts for military hardware, after launching an invasion of Ukraine.
It is noted that the world's largest arms importer is slowly turning to the West as the United States seeks to strengthen its position in the Indo-Pacific region, hoping to contain China.
It is pointed out that over the past 20 years, India has spent about $60 billion for arms purchases and more than 65% of the supplies were provided by the Russian Federation. However, Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine has forced it to look for other options for defense cooperation."

And there are some excellent points here:
1. India will not be an indirect sponsor of the Russian military-industrial complex
2. India has already been "burned" by contracts with Russia (development of helicopter, airplanes and other weapons), and does not want to take any more risks due to non-fulfillment of contract terms by the Russian side.
3. The simple purchase of arms from Russia gave nothing but costs and dependence.
4. The West offers joint production of weapons, which means access to technology, new production, new jobs and new taxes to the state treasury!
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on February 28, 2024, 09:31:02 AM
According to reports, Germany is in talks with India regarding the supply of artillery shells of the main 155 caliber. The primary order is to support the AFU forces in opposing the Kremlin regime and to destroy Russian occupation forces. In the future, India is seen as the largest contract supplier of these and other weapons to NATO member states in the EU. Considering the situation, such contracts may become not only very long term, but also very large-scale and have a huge impact on the country's budget and new investments in the country's military-industrial sector. India is choosing the right vector !
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: Peter90 on March 15, 2024, 11:49:51 PM
monthly record for silver imports into India

(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GIuO0S4XQAACka9?format=png&name=900x900)




India imports 2200 tons of silver in February (approx 70 mil oz), after total imports in 2022 were 3,625 tons.
After 2 months India is at almost 3,000 tons, with the annual record being 9600 tons in 2022.

(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GIuM3iCXUAAYAE9?format=png&name=900x900)
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: Peter90 on March 16, 2024, 12:04:38 AM
In 1 single month - last February - India has imported 7-8% of 2023 global production.
On an annual basis India is importing the whole 2023 global production.
India doesn't produce silver.
One single country is importing all the silver mined worldwide in 2023.

A silver shortage is inevitable

This was nickel's shortage in 2022 at LME (London Metal Exchange)

(https://www.ft.com/__origami/service/image/v2/images/raw/https%3A%2F%2Fd6c748xw2pzm8.cloudfront.net%2Fprod%2Ff9559f10-9eb5-11ec-baa7-6b3331b2e708-standard.png?source=next-article&fit=scale-down&quality=highest&width=700&dpr=1)

Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: EluguHcman on March 16, 2024, 10:23:10 AM
India posseses the potentials of to undertake the keen role of the position of the global economy withstanding the fact of the significant opportunities to foster developments and economical growths.

However, India has been one of the topmost ranking countries in terms of global economy GDP nominal.
With the system of India legislative governing system in a global overseers and economy infrastructures, India can be eligible to also ascend prominent leadership keen position as time may determine.
Title: Re: Will India be able to take China's place in the world economy ?
Post by: DrBeer on March 16, 2024, 04:12:56 PM
And here is the first, really unpleasant news for China:

The Indian government has launched a $15 billion project to build three factories to produce semiconductor integrated circuits.
This was reported by Hindustan Times with reference to the words of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
Tata Electronics Private Limited is expected to build a chip factory in the western state of Gujarat, which will be the country's first semiconductor manufacturing facility.
Another company from the same industrial group will build a semiconductor assembly and testing plant in the northeastern state of Assam.
Another plant where chips will be assembled and tested will be created by the Indian electrical equipment manufacturer CG Power and Industrial Solutions Limited in the state of Gujarat.
The Indian government estimates that the total investment in the three projects will be more than 1.25 trillion rupees, or about $15 billion.

The monopoly on the production of mass chips is beginning to slip away from China's hands....