Request for karma rewards be shown by topics and comments it was awarded.

[Cryptsafe]

I was wondering if it would be possible for karma rewards be attached to the top of a thread or topic or comment it was awarded to since the name of the sender would not be shown. This would be nice because it would give members the opportunity to keep track of their post, comments or topic created that got the karma so as to develop themselves towards that aspect of their contributions to the platform.
I understand that admin want the karma activities to be anonymous but I think if the karma reflect on the topic or post it was given, that would add more beauty to the platform engagement and would result to more engagements here and also one would be able to keep track of their activities that got them rewarded with karma and put more efforts to doing more as it relates to their own personal development.
I think this should be put into consideration to enable members develop themselves on a particular aspect of their strengths and help them keep track of their karma rewards.

[PX-Z]

Most existing karma topic suggestions and replies that can be read on this board and on the Suggestion Box are related and almost the same as what you mentioned, and I guess creating another thread is simply redundant, you can simply reply on one of those topics, or else put/move this to Suggestion Box board too.

[Yamane_Keto]

Since karma is linked to the account and not the posts, modifying it to become for the posts means rewriting the code again. A change like this will require a lot of time from the admin and will change the idea of karma to something closer to the Merit system.

[yahoo62278]

The admin has already responded many times to the Karma issue. Just do a little looking around and you could easily find an answer. I would post a link here for you, but I think you need to learn how to look around the forum before people just do the work for you. Not trying to be mean, trying to help you.

[bitterguy28]

Since karma is linked to the account and not the posts, modifying it to become for the posts means rewriting the code again. A change like this will require a lot of time from the admin and will change the idea of karma to something closer to the Merit system.

Indeed , i don't know why many teleported accounts wanted this forum to be more look a like Bitcointalk , there are separate admins in both forums so let them have their own style and strategy to make their forum unique and focusing in details that is more practical than just copying what BTT already does.
and also now that there are more of us who teleported here , admin is busy in dealing with lots of relevant things .

[Jokers]

admin already stated that revealing information about for which post karma was given is in his to do list. Let's wait if it can be implemented. No need to hurry up.

[bayu7adi]

Back then, a lot of people used to ask about karma, including me. But as time went on, I just got used to the different system of this forum. The admins here are still around, and I'm sure they'll announce something about this in the near future.
Since some suggestions like this come from teleportation users, including me, it's a good idea for you to check out the forum first. Read some other posts and become an active member.

[Faisal2202]

I think this should be put into consideration to enable members develop themselves on a particular aspect of their strengths and help them keep track of their karma rewards.

I understand your suggestion here, although it looks very familiar to older ones, in which many members asked admin to add a feature that would tell us who gave us positive or negative karma but in this post, you specifically asked about on which post or topic we got the karma so we could improve that, and AFAIK this suggestion is also been shared by some members before. But I don't think this is going to happen any time soon.

Because as you aforementioned admin wants to keep stats about karma hidden IDK why but it must be for the best of all of us. I liked your way of representation and if it gets approved, it really will become easy for us to keep track of on which post we got merit, when I get a notification on my TG bot that I got karma, I start to wonder on which post I might have earned that? And that post might be the latest one or might be the oldest one.

[Agbe]

Since karma is linked to the account and not the posts, modifying it to become for the posts means rewriting the code again. A change like this will require a lot of time from the admin and will change the idea of karma to something closer to the Merit system.

Indeed , i don't know why many teleported accounts wanted this forum to be more look a like Bitcointalk , there are separate admins in both forums so let them have their own style and strategy to make their forum unique and focusing in details that is more practical than just copying what BTT already does.
and also now that there are more of us who teleported here , admin is busy in dealing with lots of relevant things .

It is just a suggestion and it is not a bad idea and just that such threads and topics have been created by many and as others have said the admin has answered a lot from these kind of threads. And you know why the teleported users are interested to know or see those features it will make them to understand what they comment or post to warrant the +karma and -Karma. And in bitcointalk things we make like and easy for them to see things in that format. So when they came things are not working tht way then it come complicated for them.  And just like you were using a phone and the phone got spoiled so you bought new phone the all the functions and features are strange to you so you have to reset everything to your taste before things will be alright and that is what is happening here and unfortunately they can't do things by themselves but the admin.

[Fivestar4everMVP]

If I am not mistaken, this suggestion is not new at all, it's one that several users (including myself) have suggested to the admin in the past, and I personally believe that admin have taken note of this and possibly have added it into his to-do list.

Building the forum is not easy, so, we must give the admin enough time to build and implement all the suggestions that are good and would bring progress to this forum, like this one, asside the fact that this has been suggested multiple times before like I said earlier, this will always remain a good suggestion and one I would alwsy support, the feature can be made to just show the number of Karma (positive or negative) a post, or comment got, without revealing who gave it.

[Cryptsafe]

I think this should be put into consideration to enable members develop themselves on a particular aspect of their strengths and help them keep track of their karma rewards.

I understand your suggestion here, although it looks very familiar to older ones, in which many members asked admin to add a feature that would tell us who gave us positive or negative karma but in this post, you specifically asked about on which post or topic we got the karma so we could improve that, and AFAIK this suggestion is also been shared by some members before. But I don't think this is going to happen any time soon.

Because as you aforementioned admin wants to keep stats about karma hidden IDK why but it must be for the best of all of us. I liked your way of representation and if it gets approved, it really will become easy for us to keep track of on which post we got merit, when I get a notification on my TG bot that I got karma, I start to wonder on which post I might have earned that? And that post might be the latest one or might be the oldest one.

I had to make emphasis on this proposal because I know how it feels seeing your efforts being recognised and rewarded. As a normal human being,  you will feel that satisfied to see your efforts produce good results and being rewarded but here you get rewarded in the form of karma and yet you have no idea where the exact place the karma was sent to. All you see is that you have received karma and can not see where it was sent to and who sent it. Atleast if we don't know, let us see the destination the karma was sent to.
Nevertheless, I have no doubt about the karma system  as it would begin to yield results very soon.

[bitmover]

I was wondering if it would be possible for karma rewards be attached to the top of a thread or topic or comment it was awarded to since the name of the sender would not be shown. This would be nice because it would give members the opportunity to keep track of their post, comments or topic created that got the karma so as to develop themselves towards that aspect of their contributions to the platform.
I understand that admin want the karma activities to be anonymous but I think if the karma reflect on the topic or post it was given, that would add more beauty to the platform engagement and would result to more engagements here and also one would be able to keep track of their activities that got them rewarded with karma and put more efforts to doing more as it relates to their own personal development.
I think this should be put into consideration to enable members develop themselves on a particular aspect of their strengths and help them keep track of their karma rewards.

I made the same suggestion a few weeks ago. It will work basically like any other social media/forum platform, good posts will have some +1 in their title...

This is a must in my opinion

[Faisal2202]

I had to make emphasis on this proposal because I know how it feels seeing your efforts being recognised and rewarded. As a normal human being,  you will feel that satisfied to see your efforts produce good results and being rewarded but here you get rewarded in the form of karma and yet you have no idea where the exact place the karma was sent to. All you see is that you have received karma and can not see where it was sent to and who sent it. Atleast if we don't know, let us see the destination the karma was sent to.
Nevertheless, I have no doubt about the karma system  as it would begin to yield results very soon.

I got your point here and you have proposed a good suggestion. Although you must add a little bit more to it, like don't show on what post we get karma, at least show us that we have gave karma to which post. As, sometimes when I give karma to another member, I then come to open that thread or topic again and think of giving karma again, besides this, I don't see any confirmation notification that I successfully gave the karma (+ or -) or not.

I hope these simple features will be added, to avoid multiple mistakes, for example if I want to give positive karma to someone but instead while using phone I mistakenly click on negative karma button and it added a negative karma to the member's post, then what I will do. What if that member is new, and have zero karma but after clicking on negative karma mistakenly it shows -1 on his profile. This will disheart that users greatly. That's why we need these little upgradtions also.

[yahoo62278]

I had to make emphasis on this proposal because I know how it feels seeing your efforts being recognised and rewarded. As a normal human being,  you will feel that satisfied to see your efforts produce good results and being rewarded but here you get rewarded in the form of karma and yet you have no idea where the exact place the karma was sent to. All you see is that you have received karma and can not see where it was sent to and who sent it. Atleast if we don't know, let us see the destination the karma was sent to.
Nevertheless, I have no doubt about the karma system  as it would begin to yield results very soon.

I got your point here and you have proposed a good suggestion. Although you must add a little bit more to it, like don't show on what post we get karma, at least show us that we have gave karma to which post. As, sometimes when I give karma to another member, I then come to open that thread or topic again and think of giving karma again, besides this, I don't see any confirmation notification that I successfully gave the karma (+ or -) or not.

I hope these simple features will be added, to avoid multiple mistakes, for example if I want to give positive karma to someone but instead while using phone I mistakenly click on negative karma button and it added a negative karma to the member's post, then what I will do. What if that member is new, and have zero karma but after clicking on negative karma mistakenly it shows -1 on his profile. This will disheart that users greatly. That's why we need these little upgradtions also.

IMO a record of who we give karma to is irrelevant. You can keep that record on your own easy enough on a google sheet if it's really that important to you. Even if you mistakenly do it on your phone and give the wrong thing, you can reverse it by giving the opposite. If you gave a person a neg karma, just give a positive and problem solved.

[Faisal2202]

IMO a record of who we give karma to is irrelevant. You can keep that record on your own easy enough on a google sheet if it's really that important to you. Even if you mistakenly do it on your phone and give the wrong thing, you can reverse it by giving the opposite. If you gave a person a neg karma, just give a positive and problem solved.

yeah, I also thought the same solution but it's time-consuming and energy wasting, why do we do such work manually when this work can be automated, Although I am not that expert programmer that can automate such work, but I hope the admin and his/her developer have enough time to add such feature. And talking about pos and neg karma, I also thought of the same solution. But I also thought Admin might think of it as a scam.

Like first we gave karma and then negative karma, And I also have doubt that we can do that either, because there is an 10 hour time difference between giving karma to the same member, Although we can do it after 10 hours, but who keeps records of such things in today world. Besides this, there is not doubt that keeping record of whom we gave karma is of lesser importance in compared to from whom we got the karma.