[Suggestion] Fiture: Add Reason Before Giving Negative Karma

[Dinid]

Nice suggestion from bro Wildan.

After click Punish, and before karma point will be sent, it might be better if there is a reason box first. After type the valid reason, the Punisher can click OK button. Well done 👏👏👏, a negative karma point is being sent automatically

This is just to make sure to the punisher (sender) about his/her action.
Simply click punish button feature might be lead to the wrong action easily (the sender accidentally click punish button, even he/she do not want to send it).

Karma court ? I think karma court is just for "critical case", not for "accidental karma sending".

[Quantum X]

Hi everyone. Well, here I have an idea how if before giving negative karma we must give a reason first why we gave it. I am worried about the abuse of negative karma.

I don't think this is necessary. The forum rules are clear and the admin can always contact the one who gave the negative karma if there is going to be a dispute at our forum court.

My own suggestion:
I think having a "karma history" is enough since some of us do not really monitor Karma count. No need to include the names, just the dates when you got the positive/negative karma. Everything else is working fine.

I agree with karma history but it should be better if the karma giver will include to and the post which the reason of receiving the + or - karma.

[Goku01]

As there is proof you can easily detect who gave you karma and for which reason. If you think you don't deserve negative for the post you can complain to admin or moderator.

Can you elaborate on this? I am curious to dead to know who gave me karma(s)? Like you said, if one day total member of forum reaches 2 million and everyone receiving negative karma wants to complain to admin or moderator, what else can mod/admin do aside from resolving those complaints?

Talking about "karma", I think it's the combination of "merit" and "trust" in the forum X and everyone knows that the trust system is being seriously abused (people can give negative trust to other with some shady reasons, that's not to mention the right to give positive/negative trust is centralized in some people's hands). It'd be better to let karma system work like karma in Reddit. If you got positive karma then your total karma increases and if you get negative karma, your total karma decreases.

Who changed my karma
Whose karma have I changed

It will be two option.  In which there we can see who give me karma and which post and reason. on the other hand 2nd option you can see which post you gave karma. Do you get it now?? If you don't i can make a image like what i have said.

[wildanmr]

This is a good idea but I don't know if technically possible and for sure involves a lot of additional work and resources.

There is a log in which Admin has a lot of useful informations about issued karma.

As for now all court cases were resolved without a problem and we have ni complains so the karma system is already checked and seems to be working good.

Don't try to repair something which already works.

Thanks to respond my thread
For now maybe yes for involves additional work especially on website system.
OK sir, I just convey my idea

[Collinberg]

This is a wonderful suggestions and the admins should really look into this, if not anybody with anbeef with another person would just gather his/her friends and they would all give the person negative karma.

[wildanmr]

Nice suggestion from bro Wildan.

After click Punish, and before karma point will be sent, it might be better if there is a reason box first. After type the valid reason, the Punisher can click OK button. Well done 👏👏👏, a negative karma point is being sent automatically

This is just to make sure to the punisher (sender) about his/her action.
Simply click punish button feature might be lead to the wrong action easily (the sender accidentally click punish button, even he/she do not want to send it).

Karma court ? I think karma court is just for "critical case", not for "accidental karma sending".

Ohh I see. Do you mean adding dialog box to confirm action?
That's also nice idea bro to reduce Karma push accident.

[hair]

I totally agree, so we will not make the same mistakes that can make negative karma again. when this is implemented I look forward to it.