Altcoins Talks - Cryptocurrency Forum

Crypto Discussion Forum => Forum related => Topic started by: admin on November 01, 2017, 04:36:09 PM

Title: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: admin on November 01, 2017, 04:36:09 PM
The +karma/-karma links under each profile avatar are responsible for karma, to thank (+) as well as punish (-) users
Senior members and above (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=191961.0) have the ability to issue karma. Don't abuse it, otherwise you will have your issuance revoked (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0)


How Karma works:




When you will get Positive Karma:

When you will get Negative Karma:



Appealing negative karma in court (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=13682.0): (with points)

Removing negative karma with ALTS (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=182908.0) (and points):

Updated ALTS values as of 2nd Halving (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=184079.0) of Points to ALTS (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=124991.0), December 16th 2020.
Title: Re: Karma - applaud / smite - thank /punish
Post by: Cordillerabit on November 25, 2017, 12:34:22 AM
since there is a plan for reward with high karma. each member have multi account that initiate karma pharming should be ban what do you think sir
Title: Re: Karma - applaud / smite - thank /punish
Post by: admin on December 12, 2017, 08:37:05 PM
since there is a plan for reward with high karma. each member have multi account that initiate karma pharming should be ban what do you think sir
I agree, but positive Karma will be like a random bonus.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on December 12, 2017, 10:49:10 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: admin on December 12, 2017, 11:13:25 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.

for now only full members and above can grant karma, maybe later we can restrict it to senior and above
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: admin on December 12, 2017, 11:36:37 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.

for now only full members and above can grant karma, maybe later we can restrict it to senior and above

Also i have a log, so i can detect abuse of power easily.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on December 13, 2017, 01:34:44 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.

for now only full members and above can grant karma, maybe later we can restrict it to senior and above

Also i have a log, so i can detect abuse of power easily.

Ah OK. Thank you for your response. Didn't know about that.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Cordillerabit on December 13, 2017, 02:42:05 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.

I definitely agreed with your opinion sir   ;) but the admin is wise he create log to know whose the one can abuse the power of giving Positive (+) & Negative (-) Karma to monitor everyone in short if someone give Negative karma without any valid reason the admin will give them Negative karma. this is only my opinion correct me if im wrong admin  :)
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: admin on December 13, 2017, 04:45:56 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.

I definitely agreed with your opinion sir   ;) but the admin is wise he create log to know whose the one can abuse the power of giving Positive (+) & Negative (-) Karma to monitor everyone in short if someone give Negative karma without any valid reason the admin will give them Negative karma. this is only my opinion correct me im wrong admin  :)

kindof, i will neutralize abusive karma, and issue warnings
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on December 13, 2017, 04:55:14 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.

I definitely agreed with your opinion sir   ;) but the admin is wise he create log to know whose the one can abuse the power of giving Positive (+) & Negative (-) Karma to monitor everyone in short if someone give Negative karma without any valid reason the admin will give them Negative karma. this is only my opinion correct me im wrong admin  :)

kindof, i will neutralize abusive karma, and issue warnings

Everything is clear now.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: okstefen on December 23, 2017, 12:11:24 PM
There are times when you say or do something, and you feel like wow! This is awesome. On that occasion, is it possible that someone gives himself a positive karma? Or you have a program monitoring that too?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: admin on December 23, 2017, 01:01:45 PM
There are times when you say or do something, and you feel like wow! This is awesome. On that occasion, is it possible that someone gives himself a positive karma? Or you have a program monitoring that too?

lol, self gratification is not technically possible  ;)
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: okstefen on December 23, 2017, 04:21:07 PM
Now I see.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: arpappu17 on December 27, 2017, 06:38:07 AM
We have to carefull guys😅
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: eshan007 on December 27, 2017, 01:20:28 PM
what about positive karma?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: a515t on January 15, 2018, 03:30:20 PM
Thank you, for this!. Now i see it, so i have to carefull before commenting or posting.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: baobao2000 on January 27, 2018, 08:42:38 AM
I got 2 negative karmas just in one day. There were not warning.
I didn't know how and why I got it. To punish someone heavily isn't important
that at least to let they know the reason, so they dom't do the same mistake again?

If by any chance that the punishment for a wrong reason? !!!
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Hugobro on February 03, 2018, 03:43:01 PM
What are Points for?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: admin on February 03, 2018, 03:44:16 PM
What are Points for?

10 points = 1 ALTS token
they are a replacement to the old system of rank distribution
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Bounty_hunter on February 09, 2018, 07:42:39 AM
its  very tough to get positive karma in this forum i think and it takes a lot of time for positive karma
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on February 22, 2018, 05:12:38 PM
Is there a limit to the amount of punishing and rewarding you can do, at least per member? I've just noticed this option since becoming a Sr Member.
It seems a bit worrying if it's limitless as Sr Members can just punish someone repeatedly for no reason... Please correct me if I'm wrong!
It's ironic as now I can give karma so I'm more likely to receive it right? As a simple karma trade off? This isn't what I'm suggesting but critiquing.
I currently don't see how this is meant to work in a positive way. Please enlighten me.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: zazzy on March 11, 2018, 01:22:47 PM
Is there a way how to see which of my posts got karma (no matter if positive or negative)?

I'm asking since i got a positive one but have no clue what for.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on March 11, 2018, 01:39:58 PM
Is there a way how to see which of my posts got karma (no matter if positive or negative)?

I'm asking since i got a positive one but have no clue what for.

No there isn't. It's probably a good thing so people don't spend there time trying to repeat the same thing in order to gain more karma.
You got +1 karma for doing something good. Continue doing good things and you'll get more karma, this is the lesson learnt here.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: zazzy on March 11, 2018, 01:53:53 PM
Is there a way how to see which of my posts got karma (no matter if positive or negative)?

I'm asking since i got a positive one but have no clue what for.

No there isn't. It's probably a good thing so people don't spend there time trying to repeat the same thing in order to gain more karma.
You got +1 karma for doing something good. Continue doing good things and you'll get more karma, this is the lesson learnt here.

Thank you ver much for your fast response. Good to know and seems reasonable to me. I will try to stay a valuable member to this Forum! I have to say the community here seems way more empathic compared to bitcointalk. Really enjoying this site so far!
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on March 11, 2018, 02:46:48 PM
Glad to hear it. Enjoy your stay here  :)
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: RianDrops on March 17, 2018, 08:31:58 AM
How to add positive karma?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on March 17, 2018, 08:36:51 AM
How to add positive karma?

There is a Thank button below karma when you reach a high enough rank.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: RianDrops on March 17, 2018, 09:50:35 AM
Now I know that we need to wait 10 hours to use karma again.  :D :D
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: okstefen on March 17, 2018, 07:12:13 PM
I noticed that my 1 Kama has disappeared from my profile. Any explanation for this will be appreciated
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: admin on March 17, 2018, 07:42:23 PM
I noticed that my 1 Kama has disappeared from my profile. Any explanation for this will be appreciated
any karma related issue could be caused by referral links in posts or replies,
i will grant you a +1

Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: RianDrops on March 20, 2018, 02:20:28 PM
Excuse me admin. What do you mean by "Positive Karma will grant bonus from time to time" ? When will it be?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Zain_24 on March 23, 2018, 07:35:16 AM
Thank you for this important knowledge related to this forum.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: lucario21 on March 23, 2018, 05:32:49 PM
To prevent on abusing of karma, I'll suggest that only the moderator are allowed to grant it for those members that might contributes in our forum. But we can help into our fellow members by recommending them on a specified thread about karma recommendation what do you think?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Pandu Kelana on March 24, 2018, 05:34:00 AM
To prevent on abusing of karma, I'll suggest that only the moderator are allowed to grant it for those members that might contributes in our forum. But we can help into our fellow members by recommending them on a specified thread about karma recommendation what do you think?
Agree with this.
For addition admin and moderators can punish users who abuse karma.
Actually, I'm thinking about user who active in their local board? There is many of meaningfull post in local section, but no awards to OP.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Geey on March 24, 2018, 06:38:38 PM
To prevent on abusing of karma, I'll suggest that only the moderator are allowed to grant it for those members that might contributes in our forum. But we can help into our fellow members by recommending them on a specified thread about karma recommendation what do you think?
Agree with this.
For addition admin and moderators can punish users who abuse karma.
Actually, I'm thinking about user who active in their local board? There is many of meaningfull post in local section, but no awards to OP.

there are some local moderators who are not active in their assignment and some are active. Maybe from there we can see why the reason OP can not award
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Claus on April 01, 2018, 10:28:24 AM
The Thank / Punish links under each profile avatar are responsible for the karma.

Karma is to be granted to people providing good answers and interesting questions.
Active members have the ability to thank and punish users *don't abuse it!

Update:
  • Positive Karma will grant bonus from time to time
  • Negative Karma will remove an amount of points from the user's score.
  • The negative karma score goes up by a factor of4:
    • 1 negative karma: - 100 points
    • 2 negative karma: - 400 points
    • 3 negative karma: - 1600 points

If you have negative Karma, you can appeal it:
http://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=2705.0
but first show that you are a valuable member of this community!!

The Paid group: Immortals is not influenced by negative Karma.


When you will get Negative Karma:

1. Posting in wrong section.
2. Being aggressive, or impolite without any reason.
3. Trying to spam your referral link or your website.

So let's say you give someone a positive Karma. Is it going to be subtracted from your own accumulated Karma? Or it's the system that will grant the person that Karma without taking it from your own
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: fairy_fries on April 02, 2018, 04:43:58 PM
How to give positive Karma? Can any member give it to anyone?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: RianDrops on April 02, 2018, 05:02:27 PM
what about positive karma?

It'll give you additional points from time to time.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on April 04, 2018, 12:53:07 PM
I have read all answers and one thing is obvious to me. Karma is a great tool and the only issue is with abuse of negative karma which could be used as a weapon against somebody. Despite that Admin has a log and we have a court abuse can and will happen especially when there will be more members.

That is why I will propose if this is technically possible to leave only one button for every member only with positive karma (this could not be abused) and negative karma should be only visible for high-rank members (legendary), moderators, and trusted members with very high karma or chosen by admin.

If there will be any sort of abuse then we have court and everybody has right to start a case.

What do you think fellow Talkers?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: admin on April 07, 2018, 04:02:46 PM
I have read all answers and one thing is obvious to me. Karma is a great tool and the only issue is with abuse of negative karma which could be used as a weapon against somebody. Despite that Admin has a log and we have a court abuse can and will happen especially when there will be more members.

That is why I will propose if this is technically possible to leave only one button for every member only with positive karma (this could not be abused) and negative karma should be only visible for high-rank members (legendary), moderators, and trusted members with very high karma or chosen by admin.

If there will be any sort of abuse then we have court and everybody has right to start a case.

What do you think fellow Talkers?

i can't do that, they are linked
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: claudio2 on April 07, 2018, 07:06:14 PM

So let's say you give someone a positive Karma. Is it going to be subtracted from your own accumulated Karma? Or it's the system that will grant the person that Karma without taking it from your own

If you give a positive karma to another user, the system will not subtract it from your own karma count.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: cryptothief on April 18, 2018, 03:32:49 PM
I like the Karma system, was slightly confused at first when awarded one randomly and no way of checking what it was for. But after thinking about it, I came to the conclusion that it makes sense, if you don't know what earns Karma, then you can't only concentrate on posts that earn you it. Keeps the forum varied and informative at the same time. Still trying for my first referral though, any time now...
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on April 18, 2018, 08:18:50 PM
I like the Karma system, was slightly confused at first when awarded one randomly and no way of checking what it was for. But after thinking about it, I came to the conclusion that it makes sense, if you don't know what earns Karma, then you can't only concentrate on posts that earn you it. Keeps the forum varied and informative at the same time. Still trying for my first referral though, any time now...


This is very accurate observation. I didn't think about it that way before. Just didn't like it because I have bad experiences with merit in bitcointalk but now I've started to appreciate this system. I like to read posts which could influence and change my point of view. I would give +1 if I could.


I have seen lately admin posted about new rule in post counting. There has to be so and so many symbols in each post to be counted as valid, I think. With this feature we can to some extend deal with spam and together with karma we have all needed tools to grow this forum so much better than Bitcointalk. I think we will see a lot of new members soon.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: jakeshadows27 on April 25, 2018, 05:55:15 AM
Only moderator can give karma it depend moderator if our post are good  or not other comment not all  moderator  always online i hope i can get 1 karma  here but thank for info it help me alot about but little confusing about system
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on April 25, 2018, 12:22:39 PM
Only moderator can give karma it depend moderator if our post are good  or not other comment not all  moderator  always online i hope i can get 1 karma  here but thank for info it help me alot about but little confusing about system

Hi jakeshadows27,

you aren't right. Not only moderator can give karma. Karma can give user with rank Full Member and higher.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: sheerah on April 27, 2018, 07:04:26 AM
I salute you admin. Thank you for handling this community in a brilliant and fair way.  This will be our assurance and reminders as well so all of us will be a responsible member.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Sukma W on April 28, 2018, 04:34:04 AM
The Thank / Punish links under each profile avatar are responsible for the karma.

Karma is to be granted to people providing good answers and interesting questions.
Active members have the ability to thank and punish users *don't abuse it!

Update:
  • Positive Karma will grant bonus from time to time
  • Negative Karma will remove an amount of points from the user's score.
  • The negative karma score goes up by a factor of4:
    • 1 negative karma: - 100 points
    • 2 negative karma: - 400 points
    • 3 negative karma: - 1600 points

If you have negative Karma, you can appeal it:
http://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=2705.0
but first show that you are a valuable member of this community!!

The Paid group: Immortals is not influenced by negative Karma.



When you will get Negative Karma:

1. Posting in wrong section.
2. Being aggressive, or impolite without any reason.
3. Trying to spam your referral link or your website.
Are there rules other than those 3 negative karma rules above?
are there any restrictions on activity on the forum.?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: akhjob on April 29, 2018, 09:38:13 AM
Only moderator can give karma it depend moderator if our post are good  or not other comment not all  moderator  always online i hope i can get 1 karma  here but thank for info it help me alot about but little confusing about system

Hi jakeshadows27,

you aren't right. Not only moderator can give karma. Karma can give user with rank Full Member and higher.

Mnixxo, I think you got this wrong here. I am a full member and I cant see a way to give karma. I think its senior member and above.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on April 29, 2018, 10:35:35 AM

Mnixxo, I think you got this wrong here. I am a full member and I cant see a way to give karma. I think its senior member and above.

So you don't see below Karma, Thanks and Punish button? If it is so, maybe admin has changed it to Sr. Member. But here are his words:


for now only full members and above can grant karma, maybe later we can restrict it to senior and above
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on April 29, 2018, 04:37:03 PM

Mnixxo, I think you got this wrong here. I am a full member and I cant see a way to give karma. I think its senior member and above.

So you don't see below Karma, Thanks and Punish button? If it is so, maybe admin has changed it to Sr. Member. But here are his words:


for now only full members and above can grant karma, maybe later we can restrict it to senior and above


Karma is restricted only for senior members and higher, I think.


UPDATE

Just found this answer from Admin:
"members with 120 posts and above""
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on April 29, 2018, 05:28:56 PM

Mnixxo, I think you got this wrong here. I am a full member and I cant see a way to give karma. I think its senior member and above.

So you don't see below Karma, Thanks and Punish button? If it is so, maybe admin has changed it to Sr. Member. But here are his words:


for now only full members and above can grant karma, maybe later we can restrict it to senior and above


Karma is restricted only for senior members and higher, I think.


UPDATE

Just found this answer from Admin:
"members with 120 posts and above""

That's Sr Member rank if I'm not mistaken, I remember I only saw the options once I reached this rank.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on April 29, 2018, 05:33:14 PM
...I am a full member and I cant see a way to give karma. I think its senior member and above.
.. admin has changed it to Sr. Member. But here are his words:
...
Karma is restricted only for senior members and higher...


UPDATE

Just found this answer from Admin:
"members with 120 posts and above""
That's Sr Member rank if I'm not mistaken, I remember I only saw the options once I reached this rank.


Yes, this is SENIOR MEMBER for sure.


20 - Jr. Member
60 - Full Member
120 - Sr. Member
500 - Hero Member
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: ALT Legendary on May 01, 2018, 08:09:12 AM
So karma will be awarded by the forum members? If they like then they will give positive karma and if they dont then they will give negative karma?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on May 01, 2018, 04:00:22 PM
So karma will be awarded by the forum members? If they like then they will give positive karma and if they dont then they will give negative karma?

Not quite, it's not about liking/disling. Positive karma is thanking something for providing value to forum with quality content, negative karma is punishing someone for spamming the forum with low-quality comments. Think of it more as quality control.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: ALT Legendary on May 02, 2018, 08:48:03 PM
Not quite, it's not about liking/disling. Positive karma is thanking something for providing value to forum with quality content, negative karma is punishing someone for spamming the forum with low-quality comments. Think of it more as quality control.

I already had my answer however thank you for your response. I can't wait to see these features once I become a Jr. Member
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on May 02, 2018, 09:08:23 PM
Not quite, it's not about liking/disling. Positive karma is thanking something for providing value to forum with quality content, negative karma is punishing someone for spamming the forum with low-quality comments. Think of it more as quality control.

I already had my answer however thank you for your response. I can't wait to see these features once I become a Jr. Member


You need to be a Senior Member to be able to use karma feature. You see karma now but you would be able to issue negative and positive karma when you will be a Senior Member.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: ALT Legendary on May 03, 2018, 04:48:14 PM
Not quite, it's not about liking/disling. Positive karma is thanking something for providing value to forum with quality content, negative karma is punishing someone for spamming the forum with low-quality comments. Think of it more as quality control.

I already had my answer however thank you for your response. I can't wait to see these features once I become a Jr. Member


You need to be a Senior Member to be able to use karma feature. You see karma now but you would be able to issue negative and positive karma when you will be a Senior Member.
Oh snap! My mistake. Just realized that it was a typo. I meant to type Sr. by ended up typing Jr. Sorry about that. Thanks for the correction @EmoneyABC


Update: Can I see who sent me positive or negative karma?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Master107 on May 05, 2018, 09:06:23 AM
Thank you admin for such an informative topic regarding karma.

I wonder about the given karma in my profile. I always think about it everyday. May I suggest please let us know the particular massage that was given a positive or negative karma. I know Sr. Member and above have the ability to give karma points and maybe to access the link of given karma in the profile. As below sr. member may we click the button on the karma that was given to us?  Please correct me if there's something to improve, I humbly appreciates your guidance.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on May 05, 2018, 09:10:06 AM
... As below sr. member may we click the button on the karma that was given to us? ...


I don't understand what you mean. Can you please ask your question one more time?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: akhjob on May 05, 2018, 10:17:42 AM
... As below sr. member may we click the button on the karma that was given to us? ...


I don't understand what you mean. Can you please ask your question one more time?

I think he is asking to add a feature so that we could know which post of ours lead to the +/- karma. Just like the merit system in BTT where you can see the merits granted at the top of the post.


@Master107, Not knowing which post got you a positive karma is a good thing. Because the forum doesn't want its members to spend their time trying to repeat the same thing in order to gain more karma. Just post good stuff around the forum and you'll earn karma.

I hope when you are given a negative karma, you'll be warned for it. Not sure though. But if there isn't a feature to warn the members about negative karma, then I think the admin should add the feature. Because we all want to know what we did wrong.  But hey, you can always appeal before the Forum Court.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on May 05, 2018, 10:22:35 AM
... As below sr. member may we click the button on the karma that was given to us? ...


I don't understand what you mean. Can you please ask your question one more time?

I think he is asking to add a feature so that we could know which post of ours lead to the +/- karma. Just like the merit system in BTT where you can see the merits granted at the top of the post.


@Master107, Not knowing which post got you a positive karma is a good thing. Because the forum doesn't want its members to spend their time trying to repeat the same thing in order to gain more karma. Just post good stuff around the forum and you'll earn karma.

I hope when you are given a negative karma, you'll be warned for it. Not sure though. But if there isn't a feature to warn the members about negative karma, then I think the admin should add the feature. Because we all want to know what we did wrong.  But hey, you can always appeal before the Forum Court.


The main reason and question of this post I understand. I don't understand what he is talking about only in the text I quoted.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: ALT Legendary on May 05, 2018, 11:29:34 AM
Are there rules other than those 3 negative karma rules above?
are there any restrictions on activity on the forum.?
There are no activity count on this forum. Just post count. I am also interested to know what happen if you have more then 3 negative karma?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on May 06, 2018, 12:53:12 AM
Are there rules other than those 3 negative karma rules above?
are there any restrictions on activity on the forum.?
There are no activity count on this forum. Just post count. I am also interested to know what happen if you have more then 3 negative karma?


I don't know exactly what happen if you have -3 karma but I think that this will influence your tokens share for sure. I don't think there are other penalties This is also a good indicator for ban.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: ALT Legendary on May 06, 2018, 03:43:08 PM
I don't know exactly what happen if you have -3 karma but I think that this will influence your tokens share for sure. I don't think there are other penalties This is also a good indicator for ban.
I hope someday the admin will enlighten us with this incomplete information knowing there are so many different things the admin has in his priority list. The forum is fairly new and we need to be patience.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: jakeshadows27 on May 15, 2018, 12:48:03 AM
What rank can give karma? Or only the moderators and admin can give karma to active member here?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on May 15, 2018, 01:50:09 PM
What rank can give karma? Or only the moderators and admin can give karma to active member here?
Sr Members and above, so you're nearly there  ;)
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: rhegs27 on May 20, 2018, 01:27:34 AM
whos give the positive karma ?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on May 20, 2018, 02:15:14 PM
whos give the positive karma ?

Please read the discussion before posting next time, my answer to your question is just above you!

What rank can give karma? Or only the moderators and admin can give karma to active member here?
Sr Members and above, so you're nearly there  ;)
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on May 21, 2018, 01:17:41 AM
whos give the positive karma ?
Please read the discussion before posting next time, my answer to your question is just above you!
What rank can give karma? Or only the moderators and admin can give karma to active member here?
Sr Members and above, so you're nearly there  ;)


This is just annoying and that is why I repeat my suggestion to delete and report spam.  If this members only read few posts in this thread, they would never ask this questions. This is obvious that they are not interested in this topic and don't want to find answers to their questions only to spam and push post count higher. That is why spam should be deleted.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on May 21, 2018, 01:49:25 AM
whos give the positive karma ?
Please read the discussion before posting next time, my answer to your question is just above you!
What rank can give karma? Or only the moderators and admin can give karma to active member here?
Sr Members and above, so you're nearly there  ;)


This is just annoying and that is why I repeat my suggestion to delete and report spam.  If this members only read few posts in this thread, they would never ask this questions. This is obvious that they are not interested in this topic and don't want to find answers to their questions only to spam and push post count higher. That is why spam should be deleted.

But they also have -1 karma from someone, probably for that post, so isn't this enough?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on May 22, 2018, 10:48:36 AM
snip
Please read the discussion before posting next time, my answer to your question is just above you!
snip
nip
This is just annoying and that is why I repeat my suggestion to delete and report spam.  If this members only read few posts in this thread, they would never ask this questions. This is obvious that they are not interested in this topic and don't want to find answers to their questions only to spam and push post count higher. That is why spam should be deleted.
But they also have -1 karma from someone, probably for that post, so isn't this enough?

Yes you are right such a member should get -1 as a punishment for spamming. I agree with you fully.

Spam should be deleted because adds nothing new to discussion, is annoying, hard to read and time consuming if there is more spam in the thread (for moderators to clean up and readers to report and go thru if they are interested in topic).

Like me, sometimes Ilike to know more about some project and read thread from begin to end, to catch up and not ask stupid questions. We are still young and small forum but on BTT I found threads with 13 pages and literally 11 of them was pure spam with 2 words answers or even one "ok". Few times after I finished reporting from 13 - 20 pages left 2 - 5 when moderator finished cleaning. To report such a garbage thread took me about 2 hours. Next we have to add the moderator time spending on deleting.

If we will not fight with spam from start one day we will be very sorry. The first and most important rule on each forum is "don't spam". If I would tell, how much is my reported post count on BTT nobody would believe and my accuracy is 100%. I really know how spam looks like and how bad and damaging could be for our forum.

Finally, post count shouldn't be higher if post is pure spam or even off topic. Such a member can be in signature campaign and is obvious that he shouldn't get paid for this post. That is why I think all spam should be deleted.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Pandu Kelana on May 22, 2018, 08:47:47 PM
~snip~


Spam should be deleted because adds nothing new to discussion, is annoying, hard to read and time consuming if there is more spam in the thread (for moderators to clean up and readers to report and go thru if they are interested in topic).
~
100 % agree with you.
We're in the forum, not in a chatroom to talk about garbage.
Quote
Like me, sometimes Ilike to know more about some project and read thread from begin to end, to catch up and not ask stupid questions. We are still young and small forum but on BTT I found threads with 13 pages and literally 11 of them was pure spam with 2 words answers or even one "ok". Few times after I finished reporting from 13 - 20 pages left 2 - 5 when moderator finished cleaning. To report such a garbage thread took me about 2 hours. Next we have to add the moderator time spending on deleting.
It is too hard to fight spam with "spam reports". If better use self moderated thread, but I can't found that tools in here. Maybe admin can take considerations to activated self moderation tools.

Quote
If we will not fight with spam from start one day we will be very sorry. The first and most important rule on each forum is "don't spam". If I would tell, how much is my reported post count on BTT nobody would believe and my accuracy is 100%. I really know how spam looks like and how bad and damaging could be for our forum.
Its better using "NO SPAM".
Agree with you, we must start now to fight spamming actions before too late.
1. To make more dev team come here, they will look our forum have quality members to support their project.
2. To make our member more respect why admin founding this forum and make them do smart actions.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: SnowDawn on May 27, 2018, 02:17:33 AM
It does not work for me to thank, because there is still a small rank on the forum ... Please enter this function to earlier ranks. Thank you
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Converter on June 13, 2018, 07:47:46 AM
Because of this, it can minimize the spammer in this forum. It's just like in the Bitcointalk— in this forum is karma and in the Bitcointalk is trust.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on June 13, 2018, 11:17:35 AM
Because of this, it can minimize the spammer in this forum. It's just like in the Bitcointalk— in this forum is karma and in the Bitcointalk is trust.


Not exactly, karma is like trust and points are like merits but you get points automatic so there is no problem, like with merits and there is no points requirement to rank up. So this is a lot different as on BTT and much better of course  ;)
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: akhjob on June 13, 2018, 06:25:16 PM
It is too hard to fight spam with "spam reports". If better use self moderated thread, but I can't found that tools in here. Maybe admin can take considerations to activated self moderation tools.

Earlier, I started a thread with a suggestion for self moderation features. It seems that the feature already exists for royalty members. It will be very helpful if the feature was extended to everyone. This can be used to avoid lots of spam.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on June 17, 2018, 08:47:05 AM
It is too hard to fight spam with "spam reports". If better use self moderated thread, but I can't found that tools in here. Maybe admin can take considerations to activated self moderation tools.
Earlier, I started a thread with a suggestion for self moderation features. It seems that the feature already exists for royalty members. It will be very helpful if the feature was extended to everyone. This can be used to avoid lots of spam.

From what I know self moderated feature is only for Royalty and Patrons (maybe moderators not sure). The only way to start self moderated thread is to ask one of this persons for help. I understand why Admin choose such a option. Maybe we can change this in the future if there will be more need for that.

We have to accept Admin policy against spam. If this is on me I will delete all spam, period. Admin has different approach and I understand, accept this. We have other tools like points, karma, report button to fight with spam.

I trust our Admin blindly, he has his reasons to act with spam in this way.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: bxbxy on June 23, 2018, 03:54:24 PM
Well said and Well done admin, but can I suggest? I am thinking that, it is good to know who gave you a positive or negative karma, Because if someone gave you positive karma then you can thank him/her personally or via private chat and if someone gave you negative, you can message him/her and ask question why you receive negative karma from him/her.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mrbitcoin on June 27, 2018, 05:05:55 PM
this is helpful and recommend for new users
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Omega on June 29, 2018, 09:06:59 AM
Dear everyone and admin


I would like to raise my issue here. Please correct me if I did offensive post that gives me negative karma. It wasn't enjoyable to see -1 karma. Honestly I am wondering what post that not appropriated to the discussion that I made. Maybe I am just a victim.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on July 10, 2018, 11:42:35 AM
Dear everyone and admin

I would like to raise my issue here. Please correct me if I did offensive post that gives me negative karma. It wasn't enjoyable to see -1 karma. Honestly I am wondering what post that not appropriated to the discussion that I made. Maybe I am just a victim.

This is exactly how Karma works and why is created. You can get -1 for almost every abusive behavior. Offensive post or even language is a good reason to issue -1 karma to somebody. If you offend me I'll punish you with negative karma too.

One of the main rule on this forum is to be friendly. This is why everybody loves this forum so much. You don't see people using F...S like confetti here on AltcoinsTalks.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Official_BlockFolks on July 12, 2018, 05:13:32 AM
Dear everyone and admin

I would like to raise my issue here. Please correct me if I did offensive post that gives me negative karma. It wasn't enjoyable to see -1 karma. Honestly I am wondering what post that not appropriated to the discussion that I made. Maybe I am just a victim.

This is exactly how Karma works and why is created. You can get -1 for almost every abusive behavior. Offensive post or even language is a good reason to issue -1 karma to somebody. If you offend me I'll punish you with negative karma too.

One of the main rule on this forum is to be friendly. This is why everybody loves this forum so much. You don't see people using F...S like confetti here on AltcoinsTalks.

I agree that karma can bring positive influence to the community. But at the same time, the karma can also be used as a threat or even create negative vibes. FOr example, you will start to see a growing strength of ranked accounts coming together secretly and then they will mass - karma or + karma. This will cause a lot of biasness.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on July 13, 2018, 10:02:43 AM
Dear everyone and admin

I would like to raise my issue here. Please correct me if I did offensive post that gives me negative karma. It wasn't enjoyable to see -1 karma. Honestly I am wondering what post that not appropriated to the discussion that I made. Maybe I am just a victim.

This is exactly how Karma works and why is created. You can get -1 for almost every abusive behavior. Offensive post or even language is a good reason to issue -1 karma to somebody. If you offend me I'll punish you with negative karma too.
One of the main rule on this forum is to be friendly. This is why everybody loves this forum so much. You don't see people using F...S like confetti here on AltcoinsTalks.
I agree that karma can bring positive influence to the community. But at the same time, the karma can also be used as a threat or even create negative vibes. FOr example, you will start to see a growing strength of ranked accounts coming together secretly and then they will mass - karma or + karma. This will cause a lot of biasness.

There are logs for karma and if there is a suspicion that somebody abuse the system , Admin can check everything and take proper action. There is always court section where you can resolve all karma related cases.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: ZetsAmam on August 23, 2018, 09:40:51 PM
Negative karma? I think this is embarrassing. We must follow the rules and not over aggressive. Usually over aggressive can make someone forgot the rules. So keep calm and patiently, make our opinion useful for others.a
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: neHcuoHep on August 29, 2018, 06:50:14 AM
how can I know who gave me punish? and why?
for the last day of more than -10 karma >:(
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Graceland on September 01, 2018, 03:50:36 AM
I think admin knows all the policy in terms of spam so they dont need our suggestions, cos they had the control for all of this cos they are one of the main man on top so i think lets just follow all their rules..
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: akhjob on September 02, 2018, 05:27:04 AM
how can I know who gave me punish? and why?
for the last day of more than -10 karma >:(

I agree with his stance. If the poster did not know which post got them negative karma, how are they going to rectify their mistakes? The level of offensive language varies from person to person. Some might think his post is offensive but the poster himself and few others might not think its offensive. And some are giving negative karma for bad usage of English as well. If that is the case, I am not a native English speaker, I cannot converse in English fluently, so I might search for words to express my thoughts right and might even fail sometimes. It's about allowing the members of the forum to rectify their mistakes, improve themselves and to allow them to contribute to the forum in a healthy manner.

So there should be a way to know what gained you a negative karma.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Unknown on September 16, 2018, 01:58:47 PM
Do you plan admin to join the number of karma in the rank requirements in the future? If yes it would be great, to reduce high rank spammers because they can be punish and their rank will goes down.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: alltalk on September 16, 2018, 04:40:32 PM
I have a slightly different thought. Since you posted this thread about "Karma - thank /punish", I see not all members actively participate in giving "thank /punish". I guess some members only focus to increase the number of comments, and don't really care about the quality of the threads. How do you think about this?     
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: LogiC on September 18, 2018, 05:45:12 PM
I have a slightly different thought. Since you posted this thread about "Karma - thank /punish", I see not all members actively participate in giving "thank /punish". I guess some members only focus to increase the number of comments, and don't really care about the quality of the threads. How do you think about this?     

Hello, I think this option only applicable to senior member and up. I'd love to analyze posting of other and see potential post of other people and scrutinize some abusive poster with punish but I'll be patience when the option to do so enable me to do so.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: cryptothief on September 22, 2018, 06:32:12 PM
Thanks.

Just hit double figures on Karma, nice to know that other members have appreciated some of my posts. Aiming for the big 50 next, so it might take a while  ;D I need to be more proactive in dishing out Karma to other members too, I tend to comment instead.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: EmoneyABC on September 22, 2018, 11:56:13 PM
I have a slightly different thought. Since you posted this thread about "Karma - thank /punish", I see not all members actively participate in giving "thank /punish". I guess some members only focus to increase the number of comments, and don't really care about the quality of the threads. How do you think about this?     

I advise to use this karma buttons if you are able to.

Especially, positive karma for quality and helpful content, useful content, good behavior, something which is valuable for you. Negative karma I use only in extreme cases and punished only a few times so far mostly because I am a moderator and Judge on the forum.

If you can then do it award members for special actions this will encourage them and others to be even more creative and active on the forum.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: alltalk on September 23, 2018, 06:18:19 AM
I have a slightly different thought. Since you posted this thread about "Karma - thank /punish", I see not all members actively participate in giving "thank /punish". I guess some members only focus to increase the number of comments, and don't really care about the quality of the threads. How do you think about this?     

I advise to use this karma buttons if you are able to.

Especially, positive karma for quality and helpful content, useful content, good behavior, something which is valuable for you. Negative karma I use only in extreme cases and punished only a few times so far mostly because I am a moderator and Judge on the forum.

If you can then do it award members for special actions this will encourage them and others to be even more creative and active on the forum.

Yeah, for now, I have understood well how to use it. I learn from many discussion about karma and see the the answer from Admin and moderators like you. It is really helpful, and I noted every important information related to karma. So, then I hope I will help with my best to improve our forum especially in applying karma. Thank you EmoneyABC for your explanation.   
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: fallenangel1789 on September 30, 2018, 05:59:29 AM
I have read all answers and one thing is obvious to me. Karma is a great tool and the only issue is with abuse of negative karma which could be used as a weapon against somebody. Despite that Admin has a log and we have a court abuse can and will happen especially when there will be more members.

That is why I will propose if this is technically possible to leave only one button for every member only with positive karma (this could not be abused) and negative karma should be only visible for high-rank members (legendary), moderators, and trusted members with very high karma or chosen by admin.

If there will be any sort of abuse then we have court and everybody has right to start a case.

What do you think fellow Talkers?

Agree with @EmoneyABC
To give negative karma should be right and duty of admins, moderators and trusted members. So, in the future, no one can abuse the system. But admin says,


I have read all answers and one thing is obvious to me. Karma is a great tool and the only issue is with abuse of negative karma which could be used as a weapon against somebody. Despite that Admin has a log and we have a court abuse can and will happen especially when there will be more members.

That is why I will propose if this is technically possible to leave only one button for every member only with positive karma (this could not be abused) and negative karma should be only visible for high-rank members (legendary), moderators, and trusted members with very high karma or chosen by admin.

If there will be any sort of abuse then we have court and everybody has right to start a case.

What do you think fellow Talkers?

i can't do that, they are linked
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: kemalramdanu on October 01, 2018, 04:13:10 AM
please eliminate my negative karma
thank you
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Virtuoso on October 13, 2018, 11:44:30 PM
On every forum there must be something to prevent spamming. I think this is very good.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: bubblebubble on October 24, 2018, 10:45:24 PM
Good night.
I received a positive karma but I don't know when and for what post I wrote.
I'd like to know also who give me positive karma.
I think is important know these aspects to learn how increase own karma.

Thanks.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on October 25, 2018, 01:16:45 PM
Good night.
I received a positive karma but I don't know when and for what post I wrote.
I'd like to know also who give me positive karma.
I think is important know these aspects to learn how increase own karma.

Thanks.
Good morning.
You received positive karma from an unknown member for posting something useful. Congratulations by the way.
You don't know who, therefore you don't know why, therefore you can continue to try and post useful content regardless  ;)
This saves member attempting to repeating "karma receiving posts" in order to gain karma, or karma begging to certain members who regularly grant karma, this would be annoying. This forum isn't about earning karma, it's about being part of a community and helping each other out. Giving and receiving karma is just a part of that.
Take care.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: bubblebubble on October 25, 2018, 05:57:42 PM
Good night.
I received a positive karma but I don't know when and for what post I wrote.
I'd like to know also who give me positive karma.
I think is important know these aspects to learn how increase own karma.

Thanks.
Good morning.
You received positive karma from an unknown member for posting something useful. Congratulations by the way.
You don't know who, therefore you don't know why, therefore you can continue to try and post useful content regardless  ;)
This saves member attempting to repeating "karma receiving posts" in order to gain karma, or karma begging to certain members who regularly grant karma, this would be annoying. This forum isn't about earning karma, it's about being part of a community and helping each other out. Giving and receiving karma is just a part of that.
Take care.

Thanks for your help.
I'm posting here from a pair of days, after subscribed long time ago, because I decided to move on this forum after bored by merit system on bitcointalk.

Best regards and thanks again!
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mightwalker on October 26, 2018, 04:17:33 AM
I wonder what is the purpose of karma, Can I use it to do tasks on this forum or only increase my reputation?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on October 27, 2018, 12:36:19 PM
I wonder what is the purpose of karma, Can I use it to do tasks on this forum or only increase my reputation?

From the pinned post re: karma - thank/punish: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=657.0

  • Positive Karma will grant bonus from time to time
  • Negative Karma will remove an amount of points from the user's score.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Zed0X on October 27, 2018, 04:47:15 PM
I wonder what is the purpose of karma, Can I use it to do tasks on this forum or only increase my reputation?

LOL you were able to comment without reading the content of this topic?
Anyway, Dragon already gave you an idea but if you want to know more, I suggest you read the content.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Ahmad Arwanj on December 06, 2018, 04:25:25 PM
Hello admin how do I want to give negative / positive karma to someone, while my account every time I want to give karma can't !! then what is the cause ... thank you
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Prem Thakur on February 01, 2019, 01:14:08 PM
Thank you for the information we will take care about it before posting or commenting
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: crypto101 on April 23, 2019, 08:34:24 AM
thanks for the info.
why i can't see who sending me a karma in my notification/alert messages?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Zed0X on April 23, 2019, 09:36:24 AM
thanks for the info.
why i can't see who sending me a karma in my notification/alert messages?
At the moment, karma (+/-) senders are only known to the admin and the person sending. This is probably done to avoid a "karma war" since them giving out is less regulated here. I read that admin is working out on a new policy re: karma, let's wait for that one. 
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: gunhell16 on June 05, 2020, 03:46:31 PM
what about positive karma?

Well, positive Karma will depend on how post good you have here in the forum.
Because as far as I know the only member who is capable to give Karma whether positive or
negative is that at least Sr. member and up if I am not mistaken.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dkbit98 on June 14, 2020, 03:29:44 PM
I don't see any option for me to like or dislike any posts or anything related to karma.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on June 14, 2020, 09:04:00 PM
I don't see any option for me to like or dislike any posts or anything related to karma.

Hi,

you need to be at least Sr. Member. After that you will be able to give positive or negaitve karma. So just be active and try to rank up for the possibility to do it.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dkbit98 on June 15, 2020, 09:25:16 PM
Hi,

you need to be at least Sr. Member. After that you will be able to give positive or negaitve karma. So just be active and try to rank up for the possibility to do it.
Is there some link where I can see comparison for profiles where I can see how much activity I need for ranking up?

I saw your other post with all members rank but I can't see how much activity is needed for each of them.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: mnixxo.crypto on June 16, 2020, 08:35:44 AM
Is there some link where I can see comparison for profiles where I can see how much activity I need for ranking up?

I saw your other post with all members rank but I can't see how much activity is needed for each of them.

Newbie = 0 activity
1st step = 1-4 activity
Baby Steps = 5-40 activity
Jr. Member = 46-130 activity
Member = ? <- added few weeks ago, so we don't know the numbers
Full Member = 136-300 activity
Sr. Member = 312 activity
Hero Member = 700 activity
Legend = 1200 activity
Mythical = 5000-6000 activity
Padawan = 10000 activity


Baby Steps - after 40 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 7 days had passed.
Jr Member - after 130 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 30 days had passed.
Member - ?
Full Member - after 300 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 60 days had passed.
Sr. Member - ?
Hero Member - ?
Legend - ?
Mythical - after 6000 messages posted, the amount of activity stopped until 186 days had passed.
Padawan - ?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dkbit98 on June 16, 2020, 08:09:21 PM
Newbie = 0 activity
1st step = 1-4 activity
Baby Steps = 5-40 activity
Jr. Member = 46-130 activity
Member = ? <- added few weeks ago, so we don't know the numbers
Full Member = 136-300 activity
Sr. Member = 312 activity
Hero Member = 700 activity
Legend = 1200 activity
Mythical = 5000-6000 activity
Padawan = 10000 activity


Baby Steps - after 40 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 7 days had passed.
Jr Member - after 130 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 30 days had passed.
Member - ?
Full Member - after 300 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 60 days had passed.
Sr. Member - ?
Hero Member - ?
Legend - ?
Mythical - after 6000 messages posted, the amount of activity stopped until 186 days had passed.
Padawan - ?

Thank you!
I was looking for this everywhere.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Churphans on November 08, 2020, 08:32:26 AM
Is there some link where I can see comparison for profiles where I can see how much activity I need for ranking up?

I saw your other post with all members rank but I can't see how much activity is needed for each of them.

Newbie = 0 activity
1st step = 1-4 activity
Baby Steps = 5-40 activity
Jr. Member = 46-130 activity
Member = ? <- added few weeks ago, so we don't know the numbers
Full Member = 136-300 activity
Sr. Member = 312 activity
Hero Member = 700 activity
Legend = 1200 activity
Mythical = 5000-6000 activity
Padawan = 10000 activity


Baby Steps - after 40 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 7 days had passed.
Jr Member - after 130 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 30 days had passed.
Member - ?
Full Member - after 300 published messages, the amount of activity stopped until 60 days had passed.
Sr. Member - ?
Hero Member - ?
Legend - ?
Mythical - after 6000 messages posted, the amount of activity stopped until 186 days had passed.
Padawan - ?
Thanks sir provide very good information.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: oasis on November 11, 2020, 07:24:43 AM

Positive Karma can be exchanged into ALTS :
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=31069.0

[edited by dragononcrypto with authorization from admin]

No offense but can I know why I should exchange my Karma if I have some? ALTS token have any value right now and what is its use case?
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Master107 on November 11, 2020, 05:58:50 PM

Positive Karma can be exchanged into ALTS :
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=31069.0

[edited by dragononcrypto with authorization from admin]

No offense but can I know why I should exchange my Karma if I have some? ALTS token have any value right now and what is its use case?


I would like to recommend you in the following links. I hope you will enjoy it and answer your questions.

Our Tokens : ALTS & ALTT : full information (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=124991.msg734940#msg734940)
ALTS token - a brief overview (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=82193.msg506549#msg506549)
Active users will get ALTS token (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=832.0)
Why be active on AltcoinsTalks ?
 (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=1076.msg6235#msg6235)
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on December 06, 2020, 12:16:32 PM
Updated:

When you will get Positive Karma:
  • Providing good answers, interesting questions, useful topics and helpful comments for other members
  • Making translations of forum (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=45867.0) guides (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=23431.0), news or crypto projects for your local language section
  • Accurately reporting posts (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=31311.0), users (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?board=323.0) and bugs (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?board=276.0) as well as proposing good suggestions (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?board=358.0)
  • Writing an article about the forum see: How to get a positive Karma point fast (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=64540.0)
  • Being friendly, welcoming, respectful and helpful towards others

When you will get Negative Karma:
  • Breaking the forum rules > read the rules here (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=3171.0)
  • Spamming (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=84157.0) your referral link or website
  • Plagiarism (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=50701.0), shilling (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=111857.0) and shitposting (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=13796.0)
  • Being aggressive or rude to others
  • Ignoring advise given to you by mods
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: Gostudio on December 06, 2020, 03:32:35 PM
We have to carefull guys😅

Nothing to worry about, as long that we know the rules and regulations and we're obeying them.
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: dragonvslinux on December 08, 2020, 06:35:37 AM
We have to carefull guys😅

Nothing to worry about, as long that we know the rules and regulations and we're obeying them.

Best air on the side of caution though if you're not sure  :P
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on December 09, 2020, 10:46:13 AM
Updated with new info: Remove strikes, penalties and negative karma, the easiest way (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=182908.0)

Appealing negative karma in court (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?board=154.0): (with points)
  • If you have negative karma, you can appeal it in the Forum Court (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?board=154.0). Reserved for valued members who have points
  • When appealing in the court, the negative karma removal cost goes up by a factor of 4 as follows:
    • 1 negative karma: - 100 to 400 points ~ equivalent to 1-4 ALTS
    • 2 negative karma: - 400 to 1,000 points ~ equivalent to 4-10 ALTS
    • 3 negative karma: - 1,600 to 4,000 points ~ equivalent to 16-40 ALTS
    • 4 negative karma - 6,400 to 16,000 points ~ equivalent to 64-160 ALTS
    • 5 negative karma - 25,600 to 64,000 points ~ equivalent to 256-640 ALTS
  • Read the rules of the court (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=57183.0) before appealing. Otherwise you will receive negative karma

Removing negative karma with ALTS (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=182908.0) (and points):
  • To remove negative karma the easiest way send 3 ALTS/per negative karma, read the announcement here (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=182908.0).
  • Send the following number of ALTS tokens to this address: 0x2143F7146F0AadC0F9d85ea98F23273Da0e002Ab
    • 1 negative karma: - 3 ALTS ~ equivalent to 300 points  ~ upto 25% discount
    • 2 negative karma: - 6 ALTS ~ equivalent to 600 points   ~ upto 40% discount
    • 3 negative karma: - 9 ALTS ~ equivalent to 900 points  ~  40-75% discount
    • 4 negative karma - 12 ALTS ~ equivalent to 1,200 points  ~ 80-90% discount
    • 5 negative karma - 15 ALTS  ~ equivalent to 1,500 points  ~ 90-95% discount
  • Note: You will also lose some of your points. Once transaction sent, pm admin (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?action=profile;u=1).

Note the discounts removing negative karma with ALTS  8)
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Dinid on March 03, 2021, 09:31:47 AM
Hello Admin, I am back. Already stopped for ±2 years on crypto.

Ok then, a little question,
Can "thank / punish" be abused?
For example, someone gives punish just because they hate the member, not because of the member's fault
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: dragononcrypto on March 03, 2021, 09:48:41 AM
Hello Admin, I am back. Already stopped for ±2 years on crypto.

Ok then, a little question,
Can "thank / punish" be abused?
For example, someone gives punish just because they hate the member, not because of the member's fault

Hello Dini, welcome back!

A lot of development have happened here since you joined over 2 years ago. I will answer your question so admin can focus on administrative duties (hint hint (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=182103.0)!)

Yes karma can be abused, and has been in the past, hence since 2018 there is a Karma Abuser membership group (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0) for those who are caught and end up with their karma issuance revoked. This first happened to a group of plagiarists in 2019 (who were targeting a d team member (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?board=323.0)), as well as more recently (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=184350.msg1026738#msg1026738) in the Bangladeshi section.

In fact the 1st reason listed for opening a case in the Forum Court (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?board=154.0) is:

Quote
If you suspect someone is giving you negative karma repetitively

Source: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=57183.0

I hope that answers your question.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Rehan Zakir on March 05, 2021, 07:33:18 PM
I think Positive Karma is for those who are doing great work. And it is for appreciation for their work.
And negative Karma for those who are not following the forum rules. Make spam posts. Due to these illegal things those peoples have got negative Karma.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Abubakar56 on June 25, 2021, 08:31:04 PM
Seriously I really love this write up now I believe the rules are clear must people will just post anyhow just to rank up but seriously this forum is not just about posting anyhow to rank up you should be able to write about what will benefit the forum and what will benefit the people using the forum.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: KenshIn on August 01, 2021, 03:54:40 PM
Seriously I really love this write up now I believe the rules are clear must people will just post anyhow just to rank up but seriously this forum is not just about posting anyhow to rank up you should be able to write about what will benefit the forum and what will benefit the people using the forum.
Yes, I totally agree with you, in addition to pursuing a rank increase, you also have to think about how the posts you make can be useful for this forum.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Master107 on August 01, 2021, 06:58:53 PM
Yes, I totally agree with you, in addition to pursuing a rank increase, you also have to think about how the posts you make can be useful for this forum.

There are a lot of good posts that someone could plagiarize. We should refrain from that. Good post is relevant to the topic discussion. As long as it is relevant and unique for me it is good. Everyone should enjoy ranking up while building chemistry.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: KenshIn on August 02, 2021, 05:15:21 PM
.

There are a lot of good posts that someone could plagiarize. We should refrain from that. Good post is relevant to the topic discussion. As long as it is relevant and unique for me it is good. Everyone should enjoy ranking up while building chemistry.
Yes, because chemistry is very important, wherever or in real life, chemistry is very important, because we can do things wholeheartedly.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Master107 on August 02, 2021, 05:26:32 PM
.

There are a lot of good posts that someone could plagiarize. We should refrain from that. Good post is relevant to the topic discussion. As long as it is relevant and unique for me it is good. Everyone should enjoy ranking up while building chemistry.
Yes, because chemistry is very important, wherever or in real life, chemistry is very important, because we can do things wholeheartedly.

Yeah, nobody's perfect. But good chemistry will help us to make friends and be understable to one another regardless of different races.

Along the journey the forum chemistry would change. So, let us enjoy and calm to do things at this stage.  ;)

Nice to know you mate  :D
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: sadia batool on November 03, 2021, 07:20:04 AM
Thank you so much about giving this information. I am a new member and I was also confused about Karma but now after reading your post I get all the information and I will follow all the rules because I want to work here and for this I will try my best.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: M@dMax on December 07, 2021, 01:00:08 AM
Greetings! I do not speak English, but I would like to express my opinion. I think that the user should see who gave him karma. This will save you from harassment and help you evaluate your thoughts.
Karma that appears incomprehensibly for what makes you think, but these thoughts may not be correct. The user should know for what he received karma. It will be even better if he knows from whom he received.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: chongjasmine on February 24, 2023, 12:26:51 AM
I think members with multi accounts who add to their own karma ought to be banned. That is cheating, and it is wrong!
Title: Re: Karma - thank /punish
Post by: farzad1278 on August 20, 2023, 03:50:14 PM
I like KARMA, but maybe if someone give positive or negative karma to someone else should write few words why. Because now it is just THE CLICK. Nothing else.

It will be good if we can click on user's KARMA and see reason for positive or negative karma, including username who rated this user.
Because I am afraid of misuse of this power.

Or maybe mods have to confirm in some way postive / negative karma. Or something like that.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Uruhara on December 01, 2023, 11:48:31 PM
 :)
I'm just scrolling from top to bottom and trying to understand this forum. And I seem to be wrong by asking at another topic (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=64540.0).(my reply (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=64540.msg1452117#msg1452117)).

now by reading this topic. I have found the answer to my question in another topic (my reply (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=64540.msg1452117#msg1452117)).

The point is every user who behaves well. (obeying forum rules, contributing to the forum, being useful to fellow forum members, etc.) then Karma will come to the forum members.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Anita805 on December 08, 2023, 11:59:11 PM
Thanks to the forum admin/s for enlightening me about the karma stuff, indeed this post was helpful, and very useful to every new members like me, who just registered newly.
Once again kudos to the forum admin
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Blurr2.0 on December 09, 2023, 04:30:17 AM
The +karma/-karma links under each profile avatar are responsible for karma, to thank (+) as well as punish (-) users
Senior members and above (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=191961.0) have the ability to issue karma. Don't abuse it, otherwise you will have your issuance revoked (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0)
The rules are quite easy to understand. However, in a situation where a senior member or others give negative karma to a post that appears okay and satisfies others, is there a mechanism in place that allows other senior members to remove the karma?
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: hair on December 09, 2023, 05:08:50 AM
is there a mechanism in place that allows other senior members to remove the karma?
to remove negative karma, you need to get positive karma.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Tribalchief on December 10, 2023, 11:53:29 PM
The +karma/-karma links under each profile avatar are responsible for karma, to thank (+) as well as punish (-) users
Senior members and above (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=191961.0) have the ability to issue karma. Don't abuse it, otherwise you will have your issuance revoked (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0)

  • Positive karma is granted to users providing good answers, interesting questions, useful topics and helpful contributions to the forum
  • Negative karma is given to users who are misbehaving, breaking the rules, being aggressive or disruptive to the forum

Thanks for your proper guide.
Regarding the Karma rules: "In regards to positive Karma especially, does the karma of those giving it out get reduced after giving one out?".
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: admin on December 10, 2023, 11:56:08 PM
The +karma/-karma links under each profile avatar are responsible for karma, to thank (+) as well as punish (-) users
Senior members and above (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=191961.0) have the ability to issue karma. Don't abuse it, otherwise you will have your issuance revoked (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0)

  • Positive karma is granted to users providing good answers, interesting questions, useful topics and helpful contributions to the forum
  • Negative karma is given to users who are misbehaving, breaking the rules, being aggressive or disruptive to the forum

Thanks for your proper guide.
Regarding the Karma rules: "In regards to positive Karma especially, does the karma of those giving it out get reduced after giving one out?".
No
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Tribalchief on December 13, 2023, 09:10:49 PM
The +karma/-karma links under each profile avatar are responsible for karma, to thank (+) as well as punish (-) users
Senior members and above (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=191961.0) have the ability to issue karma. Don't abuse it, otherwise you will have your issuance revoked (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=11700.0)
I have two further questions...
1. How can I identify the post that resulted to me earning Karma?
2. Assuming someone gets to a senior member rank and above, and he/she have just one karma, can he/she issue out more than one karma to others ?.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Freemind on December 13, 2023, 09:17:10 PM
I have two further questions...
1. How can I identify the post that resulted to me earning Karma?
2. Assuming someone gets to a senior member rank and above, and he/she have just one karma, can he/she issue out more than one karma to others ?.

Hi and welcome @Tribalchief.

1. You cannot know (no one does) which of your posts is the one in which you have been granted positive karma.
2. Yes, you can give more than 1 karma, but it is not good to abuse it.

You should also keep in mind (in case you didn't know) that you can only give or take away karma from the same user every 24 hours.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Tribalchief on December 13, 2023, 10:04:19 PM

Hi and welcome @Tribalchief.

1. You cannot know (no one does) which of your posts is the one in which you have been granted positive karma.
2. Yes, you can give more than 1 karma, but it is not good to abuse it.

You should also keep in mind (in case you didn't know) that you can only give or take away karma from the same user every 24 hours.
Thanks for the swift answers. Looking forward to abiding by the rules.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Wiseman on December 16, 2023, 03:33:42 PM
I have two further questions...
1. How can I identify the post that resulted to me earning Karma?
2. Assuming someone gets to a senior member rank and above, and he/she have just one karma, can he/she issue out more than one karma to others ?.

Hi and welcome @Tribalchief.

1. You cannot know (no one does) which of your posts is the one in which you have been granted positive karma.
2. Yes, you can give more than 1 karma, but it is not good to abuse it.

You should also keep in mind (in case you didn't know) that you can only give or take away karma from the same user every 24 hours.
I would add that when karma was first introduced, many thought that it would be important in getting some privileges or tokens, but then everyone quickly realized that it’s just like liking someone you like or liking what they write, it’s a really nice topic and its implementation was the right decision.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: KingsDen on December 18, 2023, 11:35:15 PM
Pardon me if one or all these questions have been asked before;

Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Jokers on December 19, 2023, 09:45:06 AM
Pardon me if one or all these questions have been asked before;

  • Is Karma reversible? Like if I mistakenly click negative karma on someone's profile. Is there anyway to remove it? Or will the solution be to give a counter positive karma to balance it 
  • Is there anywhere to see who gave me positive or negative karma? 
  • Does the karma of the admin and a random user have the same strength?
  • If a post is too good for more than 1 karma, can I decide to give the user 20  karmas

1. You need to give an opposite karma to solve the problem.
2. No, to prevent karma wars. Only admin can see karma logs.
3. Karma is karma.
4. No more than 1 karma per some period of time per one user. You'll see a page saying your limit on a user is over until some time will pass.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: KingsDen on December 19, 2023, 10:07:44 AM
Pardon me if one or all these questions have been asked before;

  • Is Karma reversible? Like if I mistakenly click negative karma on someone's profile. Is there anyway to remove it? Or will the solution be to give a counter positive karma to balance it 
  • Is there anywhere to see who gave me positive or negative karma? 
  • Does the karma of the admin and a random user have the same strength?
  • If a post is too good for more than 1 karma, can I decide to give the user 20  karmas

1. You need to give an opposite karma to solve the problem.
2. No, to prevent karma wars. Only admin can see karma logs.
3. Karma is karma.
4. No more than 1 karma per some period of time per one user. You'll see a page saying your limit on a user is over until some time will pass.
Thank you boss jokers. You are goated, you have been providing answers to my questions. I do really appreciate.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: yahoo62278 on January 12, 2024, 04:17:48 PM
If a user is a scammer(proven or unproven) and got -karma, can they just send ALTS and lose the neg karma? Are scammers able to buy themselves outta the sin bin is the question? If so, will this policy change? I know it's a friendly forum, but I feel like we should consider protecting members a little.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: admin on January 12, 2024, 04:29:24 PM
If a user is a scammer(proven or unproven) and got -karma, can they just send ALTS and lose the neg karma? Are scammers able to buy themselves outta the sin bin is the question? If so, will this policy change? I know it's a friendly forum, but I feel like we should consider protecting members a little.
scammers get the scammer tag > not possible to remove > unless proven innocent in forum court
cheater gets cheater tag > so far no way out > in the future might be a reduced punishment with another tag that replaces the cheater tag
karma mostly for everyday interaction about quality, and help us detect some red flags > in the future will play a role in shitpost tag
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: admin on January 12, 2024, 04:32:19 PM
If a user is a scammer(proven or unproven) and got -karma, can they just send ALTS and lose the neg karma? Are scammers able to buy themselves outta the sin bin is the question? If so, will this policy change? I know it's a friendly forum, but I feel like we should consider protecting members a little.

i might implement a trust meter also, this way it would be a bit more in harmony with btt
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: examplens on January 12, 2024, 04:46:33 PM
If a user is a scammer(proven or unproven) and got -karma, can they just send ALTS and lose the neg karma?

Karma issuance has been restricted from Senior Members and above (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=191961.0). You can only give + karma to the same account every 10 hours at least I have this limitation. It seems that it is a long process and requires Senior member accounts for this endeavour. In essence, it is possible, but quite complicated.

Are scammers able to buy themselves outta the sin bin is the question? If so, will this policy change? I know it's a friendly forum, but I feel like we should consider protecting members a little.

Do you mean about this?
Remove strikes, penalties and negative karma, the easiest way (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=182908)
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: yahoo62278 on January 12, 2024, 06:45:42 PM
If a user is a scammer(proven or unproven) and got -karma, can they just send ALTS and lose the neg karma?

Karma issuance has been restricted from Senior Members and above (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=191961.0). You can only give + karma to the same account every 10 hours at least I have this limitation. It seems that it is a long process and requires Senior member accounts for this endeavour. In essence, it is possible, but quite complicated.

Are scammers able to buy themselves outta the sin bin is the question? If so, will this policy change? I know it's a friendly forum, but I feel like we should consider protecting members a little.

Do you mean about this?
Remove strikes, penalties and negative karma, the easiest way (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=182908)
Yea talking about the buying alts and sending to reove neg, seems admin has answered already though.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: debra on January 13, 2024, 09:40:05 AM
If a user is a scammer(proven or unproven) and got -karma, can they just send ALTS and lose the neg karma? Are scammers able to buy themselves outta the sin bin is the question? If so, will this policy change? I know it's a friendly forum, but I feel like we should consider protecting members a little.
A scammer will get scammer badge if he/she is proven. If he/she is unproven, he is certainly free from any sanction. He won't get negative karma, nor getting a scammer badge.

To appeal negative karma with points or ALTS, I think it should get an agreement from admin or judges. If admin and judges don't agree with the appeal, scammers can't appeal the negative karmas and scammer badges. In this matter, it won't be easy for scammers to remove their sins with ALTS or points.

i might implement a trust meter also, this way it would be a bit more in harmony with btt
We have karma system, I don't think we need to have trust meter. If we apply karma meter, we may apply merit system too someday.
If this happens, what is the difference between altcoinstalks and bitcointalk? I think I agree with @hugeblack, he said altcoinstalks shouldn't be like bitcointalk. We have our own system and our own characteristic. As long as we have no serious problem with karma system, we don't need to apply another system like trust or merit.

The most important thing in my opinion now:
 --snip--
 - Don't try to change the forum to be like Bitcointalk.
 - Respect the former members and their system here. Frankly, I have not yet understood all aspects of the forum, but it seems to me that the decision-making mechanism is more dynamic.
 - Enjoy posting, avoid violating the rules as things will improve over time.

Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Jokers on January 13, 2024, 04:27:24 PM
We have karma system, I don't think we need to have trust meter.

I don't think so either. Trust system doesn't work for 100% even on BTT, but it is very needed in there anyway, because scam is not moderated there at all. So to compensate that BTT needs some community system of scam fighting. And DT system works for that. But the DT system has many disadvantages also, it provokes many conflicts, many users who formally participate in it don't do anything and many don't really understand how it should work. It is too complicated and I don't think we are in need of implementing anything like that at the moment.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: IrynaInna on January 18, 2024, 02:59:49 PM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: examplens on January 18, 2024, 03:26:38 PM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?

Write something useful and constructive, even as a reply, and one or more of the other members will reward you with + karma. The same thing is the other way around, if you spam and write nonsense, there is a high probability that you will get - karma.
Sounds simple, doesn't it?
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Freemind on January 18, 2024, 07:55:12 PM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?

Hi and welcome @IrynaInna.

The best way to receive karma from users is by creating useful and quality content, as @examplens (+1) told you. You can create threads commenting on curious things that interest you or you can talk in existing threads, that way users will be able to contrast your ideas with theirs and the conversation will arise. Remember to read (if you haven't already) the forum rules.

Forum rules (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=3171.0).
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Fancode09 on January 25, 2024, 04:52:32 AM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?

(+) Karma If you have Karma you are very trustworthy, if you are informative and post quality then you will be gifted with Positive Karma.

(--) If you cheat then you will get gift of negative karma, if you in any way deal with someone and present nonsense in this forum, you will get gift of negative karma.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Paragon2 on January 25, 2024, 02:33:07 PM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?

Karma is usually awarded based on informative posts and quality posts. As a gift, +positive karma is usually given to make the posting user happy. Negative karmas are given to bad users so that no one deals with them and they are spam posters.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Power420 on January 26, 2024, 02:36:57 AM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?

(+) Karma If you have Karma you are very trustworthy, if you are informative and post quality then you will be gifted with Positive Karma.

(--) If you cheat then you will get gift of negative karma, if you in any way deal with someone and present nonsense in this forum, you will get gift of negative karma.

It is proven that many people who post bad comments on this forum will see their negative karma increase, so understand that person is a scam poster. Now you will see those who post good and advanced and informative posts have positive karma. So if you are happy with someone's post and you are happy, you are gifted with positive karma.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Papusha20 on January 26, 2024, 11:16:26 AM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?

Members give appropriate rewards to those who deserve +Karma, and -Negative Karma to those whose information is uncharacteristic and to those who make bad posters. It is not the responsibility of the members to blame someone else. So we all will post informative good and quality so that unique members will be happy with the post. Many people are deeply regretted by this nonsense post, you will know them when you see them.
Title: Re: Karma - thank/punish
Post by: Agbe on February 08, 2024, 06:34:21 PM
I am new in altscoinstalks forum. How I get karma?
This are the kind of post that gotten -Karma because from the Op, everything is well spelled and written out the way users can have or get positive and negative karma and someone here is asking how he can get a +Karma. Well I would not blame but what you would have done first before replying to any thread is to read the op to know what is going on first before making comments because what you did now, you just jumped to the discussion without knowing what is going on and I believed other users have told what to do and I will also advise you to read the op for more and a comprehensive understanding of how to get a positive karma and negative karma.