Altcoins Talks - Cryptocurrency Forum
Crypto Discussion Forum => Forum related => Suggestion Box => Topic started by: examplens on March 20, 2024, 11:00:58 AM
-
Here we discussed The dots below username, what kind of badge is it? (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=319263)
We received partial explanations, perhaps not complete. Later, one user added a link to a similar discussion. Now we have additional new reputation dots with some users, I believe that there will be more over time.
I would suggest, if feasible, implementing some kind of info hints when the user hovers mouse pointers on the specific badge. We see many badges under the username, but to understand how a certain credit was obtained, it is necessary to search the forum for more information.
-
I suppose the admin could make those quality bar points have a link (in the side profile of the users who have those points) to the post (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=319457.0) explaining what each point means, or simply showing the quality of each point. This way we wouldn't have to consult the same thread every time we need information or remember what each color is, although the latter is not complicated either.
It seems to me a logical and positive proposal.
+1
-
the quality bar will have some features and limitations
more on this soon
for example red dots > will no longer be able to have signatures
-
the quality bar will have some features and limitations
more on this soon
I was more interested in the feasibility of the proposal presented in the opening of the topic. It would be very useful to have this kind of info, I've been here for a few months and I still don't understand all the badges here.
for example red dots > will no longer be able to have signatures
This is not implemented yet, right?
For example, I saw this user still has a signature in his profile https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=319757.msg1528246#msg1528246
-
the quality bar will have some features and limitations
more on this soon
I was more interested in the feasibility of the proposal presented in the opening of the topic. It would be very useful to have this kind of info, I've been here for a few months and I still don't understand all the badges here.
for example red dots > will no longer be able to have signatures
This is not implemented yet, right?
For example, I saw this user still has a signature in his profile https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=319757.msg1528246#msg1528246
not yet, very soon
-
the quality bar will have some features and limitations
more on this soon
So that means green and blue bars will have some additional benefits in forum compared to normal members without any bar?
I like the idea but I would suggest creating open discussion about changes like this, so we can hear what community thinks about that.
-
I think you have to keep in mind that this forum just became active again in the last few months. Prior to the new year, lots of accounts went inactive and hadn't visited in months so the admin probably didn't have a lot of changes in his mind that would be worth implementing.
Now, it's an active and thriving forum and there's a billion things to do. The admin has new ideas he wants to add, but it takes time. Anything added will probably have an explanation somewhere, but i agree I wouldn't mind being able to hover over what I have a question about and be able to get an explanation or a hyperlink.
-
the quality bar will have some features and limitations
more on this soon
I was more interested in the feasibility of the proposal presented in the opening of the topic. It would be very useful to have this kind of info, I've been here for a few months and I still don't understand all the badges here.
for example red dots > will no longer be able to have signatures
This is not implemented yet, right?
For example, I saw this user still has a signature in his profile https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=319757.msg1528246#msg1528246
not yet, very soon
Okay I have a quick question about this too, is there any way possible for the red dot to be removed or changed after been tagged with it? And am suprised to see the user thats wearing the coinomize signature been placed with the red dot and it would be also nice to actually know the panel responsible for given the verdict on users to placed under this new dot ranks.
-
Okay I have a quick question about this too, is there any way possible for the red dot to be removed or changed after been tagged with it? And am suprised to see the user thats wearing the coinomize signature been placed with the red dot and it would be also nice to actually know the panel responsible for given the verdict on users to placed under this new dot ranks.
Yes, a consideration or an appeal should be a thing because the admin (or maybe some global mods) only have the power to add those dots and its looks like a permanent one. An open/close thread for proofs why the users got such a negative badge would be better.
-
So that means green and blue bars will have some additional benefits in forum compared to normal members without any bar?
I like the idea but I would suggest creating open discussion about changes like this, so we can hear what community thinks about that.
admin started the idea that members would be rewarded with quality dots for writing useful and quality content. He even gave 100 topics as suggestions.
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=315376
-
And I've also been wondering if the reputation dot; will somehow or some day replace the normal trust rating system, for as for now, it seems nobody is interested in using the normal trust rating system.
In the thread where the admin introduced the reputation dot and what the different colors stand for, he likened a red dot to a nagative trust, is this to say that, a user with a red dot shoulf not be trusted in a trade? Remember, the user earned the red dot not by means of scamming in a trade, but by means of poor quality post.
I think this are some of the things we need clear explanation or clarification on @admin.
-
Okay I have a quick question about this too, is there any way possible for the red dot to be removed or changed after been tagged with it? And am suprised to see the user thats wearing the coinomize signature been placed with the red dot and it would be also nice to actually know the panel responsible for given the verdict on users to placed under this new dot ranks.
Everything can be changed, nothing is eternal, but the intruder should have a will to improve his behavior for that. First they should contact admin, admit their violations and make positive contributions to show that they are ready to not to break rules again. Most of intruders don't want to be honest users from the very beginning, so their red marks can hardly be removed.
-
And I've also been wondering if the reputation dot; will somehow or some day replace the normal trust rating system, for as for now, it seems nobody is interested in using the normal trust rating system.
In the thread where the admin introduced the reputation dot and what the different colors stand for, he likened a red dot to a nagative trust, is this to say that, a user with a red dot shoulf not be trusted in a trade? Remember, the user earned the red dot not by means of scamming in a trade, but by means of poor quality post.
I think this are some of the things we need clear explanation or clarification on @admin.
The red dot has another meaning, And while it may have something to do with the quality of the posts, the most important part of the red dot is as follows:
Bad Quality
(https://www.altcoinstalks.com/Themes/default/images/quality11.png) :
This user have a major issue that needs to be resolved. (this is like negative trust) . We advise the user to contact the admin to see if there is a solution to this issue.
(multiple accounts, account farms, ...)
We do not advise bounty managers to work with these users.
As for whether you should trust someone with the red dot to trade, I think it's a personal decision. I wouldn't trust someone who doesn't follow the rules of the forum and harms other users by having multiple accounts.
More news on that soon.
-
Remember, the user earned the red dot not by means of scamming in a trade, but by means of poor quality post.
No one got a red dot just for low quality posts. Low quality is a kind of lesser violations and has its own badge (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/Themes/default/images/lowqp.png) in case of persistent spamming everywhere with pointless posts. But even to get a registered warning for low quality posts someone should make many of them. Red dots are for worser violations. ???
-
And I've also been wondering if the reputation dot; will somehow or some day replace the normal trust rating system, for as for now, it seems nobody is interested in using the normal trust rating system.
In the thread where the admin introduced the reputation dot and what the different colors stand for, he likened a red dot to a nagative trust, is this to say that, a user with a red dot shoulf not be trusted in a trade? Remember, the user earned the red dot not by means of scamming in a trade, but by means of poor quality post.
I think this are some of the things we need clear explanation or clarification on @admin.
The red dot has another meaning, And while it may have something to do with the quality of the posts, the most important part of the red dot is as follows:
Bad Quality
(https://www.altcoinstalks.com/Themes/default/images/quality11.png) :
This user have a major issue that needs to be resolved. (this is like negative trust) . We advise the user to contact the admin to see if there is a solution to this issue.
(multiple accounts, account farms, ...)
We do not advise bounty managers to work with these users.
As for whether you should trust someone with the red dot to trade, I think it's a personal decision. I wouldn't trust someone who doesn't follow the rules of the forum and harms other users by having multiple accounts.
More news on that soon.
Your excellency, thank you very much the explanation, that is very much clear and understandable to me, I've actually read that admin's statement you shared in the quote, but I think I completely missed the part where it mention about multiple accounts, account farms as some of the offences that could earn a user, a red dot.
Remember, the user earned the red dot not by means of scamming in a trade, but by means of poor quality post.
No one got a red dot just for low quality posts. Low quality is a kind of lesser violations and has its own badge (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/Themes/default/images/lowqp.png) in case of persistent spamming everywhere with pointless posts. But even to get a registered warning for low quality posts someone should make many of them. Red dots are for worser violations. ???
Well, let me say that maybe I assumed wrongly, but all the same, I think it's been a while since I last saw a user with such tag, and I do see or come across some kind of nonsense posts or comments from some users from time to time, so, I am wondering if that Low Q.P. tag is still in use, I thought the red dot has actually replaced that :D.
-
so, I am wondering if that Low Q.P. tag is still in use, I thought the red dot has actually replaced that :D.
As far as I remember, admin revoked only KYC badges, so until his announcement all other badges are actual. Low Q.P. is very rarely used, but if there will be a need we can give it to the persistent low quality poster. :)
-
Here we discussed The dots below username, what kind of badge is it? (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=319263)
We received partial explanations, perhaps not complete. Later, one user added a link to a similar discussion. Now we have additional new reputation dots with some users, I believe that there will be more over time.
I would suggest, if feasible, implementing some kind of info hints when the user hovers mouse pointers on the specific badge. We see many badges under the username, but to understand how a certain credit was obtained, it is necessary to search the forum for more information.
I though I would get a badge when I created a topic suggested by admin, but I didn't.
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=315376.msg1522964#msg1522964
Maybe more clear rules about those badge would be nice.
-
I though I would get a badge when I created a topic suggested by admin, but I didn't.
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=315376.msg1522964#msg1522964
Maybe more clear rules about those badge would be nice.
As far as I understand, the admin has not yet fully completed the implementation of the new quality bar. At the same time, it seems that the admin's priority is to formulate things related to low-quality and account farmers' badges, I guess the idea is to remove the rotten apples.
Rewards for a positive effect will probably come at the end, like a strawberry on a cake ;)
-
I though I would get a badge when I created a topic suggested by admin, but I didn't.
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=315376.msg1522964#msg1522964
Maybe more clear rules about those badge would be nice.
As far as I understand, the admin has not yet fully completed the implementation of the new quality bar. At the same time, it seems that the admin's priority is to formulate things related to low-quality and account farmers' badges, I guess the idea is to remove the rotten apples.
Rewards for a positive effect will probably come at the end, like a strawberry on a cake ;)
I think that the best contributors have a good recognition already. The karma system works pretty well imo. It has flaws, just like the merit system...
-
I though I would get a badge when I created a topic suggested by admin, but I didn't.
https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=315376.msg1522964#msg1522964
Maybe more clear rules about those badge would be nice.
As far as I understand, the admin has not yet fully completed the implementation of the new quality bar. At the same time, it seems that the admin's priority is to formulate things related to low-quality and account farmers' badges, I guess the idea is to remove the rotten apples.
Rewards for a positive effect will probably come at the end, like a strawberry on a cake ;)
I think that the best contributors have a good recognition already. The karma system works pretty well imo. It has flaws, just like the merit system...
I agree with @examplens here, regarding the fact that there are still some features that will be released regarding the quality bar, the implementation itself was not complete. Maybe in the next following days, we will see more members who will receive the quality bar or the badge, we just have to wait since it is manually being distributed.
Besides, as per the thread created by the admin,
People participating in this quality content project might be granted quality dots
There's no guarantee of receiving a quality dot after you make a thread. There might be but I think the admin has more important things to do as he can visit the created threads back after what he is trying to be done by now.