Altcoins Talks - Cryptocurrency Forum

Learning & News => For Beginners => Basic questions about this forum => Topic started by: Charles-Tim on April 04, 2025, 10:07:51 AM

Title: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Charles-Tim on April 04, 2025, 10:07:51 AM
I wanted to give negative feedback to a scammer but I was unable to send the feedback. The forum does not allow me.

(https://talkimg.com/images/2025/04/04/lKRyv.jpeg)

Why am I not allowed?
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: DYING_S0UL on April 04, 2025, 12:21:12 PM
I wanted to give negative feedback to a scammer but I was unable to send the feedback. The forum does not allow me.

Why am I not allowed?

Same here! I tried it with your account but also getting the same error. I'm guessing it was intentionally disabled by the admin for some reason!  :)
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Charles-Tim on April 04, 2025, 12:32:12 PM
Same here! I tried it with your account but also getting the same error. I'm guessing it was intentionally disabled by the admin for some reason!  :)
If it is disabled, I do not know the reason admin makes it to be appearing on users profile. They can as well remove it from there so that we can know we don't have to send anyone feedback.

Check this profile: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?action=profile;u=100934
His post history: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?action=profile;area=showposts;u=100934

It is full of scam. I reported some but I did not know the reason moderators did not delete everything the guy is posting. All his posts are about nothing more than means to scam people on this forum. He is also a spammer.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: hugeblack on April 04, 2025, 01:42:13 PM
AFAIK, only a few members can do this. (admin +Ex/President)
Create a topic about that scam and report it. scam is moderated here, but there isn't enough time to review all posts.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: snowpega on April 04, 2025, 02:34:15 PM
If it is disabled, I do not know the reason admin makes it to be appearing on users profile. They can as well remove it from there so that we can know we don't have to send anyone feedback.

Check this profile: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?action=profile;u=100934
His post history: https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?action=profile;area=showposts;u=100934

It is full of scam. I reported some but I did not know the reason moderators did not delete everything the guy is posting. All his posts are about nothing more than means to scam people on this forum. He is also a spammer.

Hmm, it's strange, mate. I can also see the same here. I am also not allowed to leave feedback on that profile you mentioned. Other than that, your intention of creating this thread started to fulfil a kind of, as I can see, warning level 20% on his/her profile and negative 3 karma and zero activity, but the user is still active and doing posts, and he/she has also made some posts by today as well.

But as Hugeblack mentioned, create a separate thread for the scam and mention everything with details, and hopefully you will see results shortly if moderators act upon this.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Cantsay on April 04, 2025, 04:53:23 PM

Why am I not allowed?

I don’t know if I’m accurate but I kinda remember reading a post made by the admin about not wanting the forum to develop some kind of dramas which usually occurs as a result of feedbacks being left by forum members same thing that happens in Bitcointalk that why it’s limited to just the admin and a few other accounts. But now it’s looking like it’s limiting people from giving warning to other forum members concerning accounts that might be out there scamming.

P.S. Even trades feedbacks still require permission from the admin.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Charles-Tim on April 04, 2025, 05:13:11 PM
I don’t know if I’m accurate but I kinda remember reading a post made by the admin about not wanting the forum to develop some kind of dramas which usually occurs as a result of feedbacks being left by forum members same thing that happens in Bitcointalk that why it’s limited to just the admin and a few other accounts. But now it’s looking like it’s limiting people from giving warning to other forum members concerning accounts that might be out there scamming.
Trust feedback and the whole trust system on Bitcointalk is far better than what is on this forum with what I am seeing. They are not comparable at all.

P.S. Even trades feedbacks still require permission from the admin.
What I am asking of is also the same feedback. Or is trading feedback different?
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Cantsay on April 04, 2025, 05:26:32 PM

P.S. Even trades feedbacks still require permission from the admin.
What I am asking of is also the same feedback. Or is trading feedback different?

I don’t think they are the same; the positive feedback you mentioned is as a result of the users post (but can also be given after a successful deal with the user).  However, the 'trade count' refers to the number of successful trades the user has completed, regardless of whether they went well or not.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Charles-Tim on April 04, 2025, 05:52:42 PM
I don’t think they are the same; the positive feedback you mentioned is as a result of the users post (but can also be given after a successful deal with the user).  However, the 'trade count' refers to the number of successful trades the user has completed, regardless of whether they went well or not.
I have seen it on my profile. You are right. I am just getting use to this forum.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Jokers on April 04, 2025, 06:12:38 PM
but the user is still active and doing posts, and he/she has also made some posts by today as well.

This user is not active anymore, I banned this account several hours earlier, all posts are trashed as obvious spam.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: DYING_S0UL on April 04, 2025, 06:46:44 PM

Why am I not allowed?

I don’t know if I’m accurate but I kinda remember reading a post made by the admin about not wanting the forum to develop some kind of dramas which usually occurs as a result of feedbacks being left by forum members same thing that happens in Bitcointalk that why it’s limited to just the admin and a few other accounts. But now it’s looking like it’s limiting people from giving warning to other forum members concerning accounts that might be out there scamming.

P.S. Even trades feedbacks still require permission from the admin.

It's the same with karma! There was this discussion where everyone was talking about why wasn't the karma log made public! Several arguments were made, why it should be made public and why it shouldn't be! And if I remember correctly, the admin simply responded that it would create unnecessary dramas, that's why he made the karma log hidden! I guess it could be the same reason with feedbacks!

Anyway I feel like, instead to giving the user feedback it would be better if we could directly contact the admin and mods! They are able to solve issues like these very quickly. The chatbox is also of great help!
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: dragononcrypto on April 04, 2025, 08:54:54 PM
It is full of scam. I reported some but I did not know the reason moderators did not delete everything the guy is posting. All his posts are about nothing more than means to scam people on this forum. He is also a spammer.

In future, report the user to D team section (if spam) or scam accusations if scam, only report posts using the report to mod function (rather than an entire users list of posts).

You need a D team based global mod or Judge to deal with your request most likely, and generally we don't spend our time looking over the old completed reports.


Why am I not allowed?

I don’t know if I’m accurate but I kinda remember reading a post made by the admin about not wanting the forum to develop some kind of dramas which usually occurs as a result of feedbacks being left by forum members same thing that happens in Bitcointalk that why it’s limited to just the admin and a few other accounts.

This is basically the reason. It's just a different system here for dealing with issues, ranging from mods to judges.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: snowpega on April 05, 2025, 02:53:52 PM
but the user is still active and doing posts, and he/she has also made some posts by today as well.

This user is not active anymore, I banned this account several hours earlier, all posts are trashed as obvious spam.

Many thanks, dear, for cleaning the forum from these kinds of users and making the environment again user-friendly. I am surprised to see your instant action of banning this spammer and scammer out of this space. As you know, I suggested to the user to create another thread and mention there everything in detail about the scam he/she may have faced. But you make it quicker and ban the user.

Here is +1 for you, dear!  :)
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Faisal2202 on April 05, 2025, 06:53:34 PM
I wanted to give negative feedback to a scammer but I was unable to send the feedback. The forum does not allow me.
-cut-
Why am I not allowed?
This has been discussed before on Forum Related section and members also questioned the same thing, we could not because we are not allowed and only some members like admin or maybe some president or whatever the lower rank is after admin allowed.

Although we should have this feature here, and I also heard from some members that the admin has plans to implement a feedback system here which is a good thing.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: hugeblack on April 05, 2025, 08:23:00 PM
Although we should have this feature here, and I also heard from some members that the admin has plans to implement a feedback system here which is a good thing.
I think updating this system would be necessary if there were active trading, a Collectibles section, or a lending section, as in BTT, but I have not seen such transactions in this forum.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: PX-Z on April 06, 2025, 12:31:49 AM
Although we should have this feature here, and I also heard from some members that the admin has plans to implement a feedback system here which is a good thing.
I think updating this system would be necessary if there were active trading, a Collectibles section, or a lending section, as in BTT, but I have not seen such transactions in this forum.
There is, i mean those who traded, making a thread on specific board then admin gave them positive feedback also trade count, IIRC its bitmover and yahoo. But yeah, collectible trades and lending doesn't have here yet.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: bitmover on April 07, 2025, 12:54:07 AM
Although we should have this feature here, and I also heard from some members that the admin has plans to implement a feedback system here which is a good thing.
I think updating this system would be necessary if there were active trading, a Collectibles section, or a lending section, as in BTT, but I have not seen such transactions in this forum.
There is, i mean those who traded, making a thread on specific board then admin gave them positive feedback also trade count, IIRC its bitmover and yahoo. But yeah, collectible trades and lending doesn't have here yet.

Yeah, those trade counts were given by the admin for us. We can't make trust comments like in BTT, all trade counts are made by the admin

You can also teleport tem from bitcointalk, for a fee. So I belive this might be the reason that we cannot just share trade counts between us,
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Joeboy on April 07, 2025, 02:09:26 AM
I wanted to give negative feedback to a scammer but I was unable to send the feedback. The forum does not allow me.

(https://talkimg.com/images/2025/04/04/lKRyv.jpeg)

Why am I not allowed?
The account is presently under review. She is obviously a fraud, what I also noticed is that her post wasn't deleted by the admins it is still active. Anyways am sure the admin are working on that, let's just be very careful out there guys this scammers and spammer are beginning to be a thorn in one's flesh.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Aanuoluwatofunmi on April 07, 2025, 09:15:43 PM
I wanted to give negative feedback to a scammer but I was unable to send the feedback. The forum does not allow me.

(https://talkimg.com/images/2025/04/04/lKRyv.jpeg)

Why am I not allowed?

I don't know the reason for that since the option to do so is made available, but i think maybe it will have something to do with using the karma more than the feedback or maybe the moderators or staffs here have to right to use such, this is just my guess on that anyway, there is more to discover regarding here and we just have to take more time in familiarizing ourself to it.
Title: Re: Why not allow to give feedback?
Post by: Faisal2202 on April 08, 2025, 04:29:33 PM
I think updating this system would be necessary if there were active trading, a Collectibles section, or a lending section, as in BTT, but I have not seen such transactions in this forum.
The forum is not that famous yet, there are not any sellers like there are on BTT, as you indicated, we need collectibles, or a lending section here, which TBH I did not find too, but there is a trading section, and trade count option here. So, we might take it as positive feedback, as if someone has 1 or 10 positive trade counts with good comments from admin, then anyone can trust that dude.

I remember the very first trade happens of like $40 or something like that, and both parties gained +1 trade token from admin. It was totally worth it, but we definitely need a collectible section here.