OFFICIAL ANNOUNCEMENTIt's time, friends.
eXch will officially shutdown its operations effective May 1st, 2025.
Almost all of you know that eXch started as a project aimed at demonstrating to the community that alternatives can exist during times when there were none. We have never had any financial goals with this project and rather, we conducted an experiment that was unexpectedly successful.
Recently, we received confirmation of information we had previously, thanks to some friends we have even in the state intelligence sector, that our project is the subject of an active transatlantic operation aimed at forcibly shutting our project down and prosecuting us for "money laundering and terrorism."
Even though we have been able to operate despite some failed attempts to shutdown our infrastructure (attempts that have also been confirmed to be part of this operation), we don't see any point in operating in a hostile environment where we are the target of SIGINT simply because some people misinterpret our goals. Starting from the date of the merger with a new management team this month, and as a result of some urgent meetings, the majority of us voted to cease and retreat instead of going against strong winds, because none of us want to cause any harm to innocent people or this forum.
The goals we certainly never had in mind were to enable illicit activities such as money laundering or terrorism, as we are being accused of now. We also have absolutely no motivation to operate a project where we are viewed as criminals. This doesn't make any sense to us.
Originally, we were just a team of privacy enthusiasts with main areas of interest quite distant from cryptocurrency, where we saw the absolutely unfair happenings. This project was an attempt to restore balance in this industry.
Our project has demonstrated that an instant exchange done properly can be more effective than any centralized mixer in terms of privacy, which is why it has been referred to as "a mixer" many times by third parties, even though we have continuously rejected this label.
Our project has shown that it's possible to operate without abusing customers with nonsensical policies, unlike projects that will accept this announcement as a "weight lifted off their shoulders" that pretend to believe the false idea that confiscating crypto from customers somehow prevents "money laundering", who rely on random and unreliable scoring systems created and operated by companies that are parasites aiming to extract money from their governments by providing consulting based on the segregation of the crypto space and blockchain data. If we were to look at these projects from the perspective of "preventing money laundering and terrorism financing", any instant exchangers that screen their customer deposits using third-party APIs and appeal to nonsensical AML/KYC terms are far from preventing money laundering and terrorism. If they were serious about this, they would need to stop hiding behind shelf offshore companies and start conducting strict due diligence on every customer, which none of them do in reality. The absurdity is compounded by the absolute uselessness of the address score reporting APIs they use, as any of these screening mechanisms can be easily bypassed.
Our project will also demonstrate that even without it, this space will continue to have ways and instruments for those engaging in illicit activities to effectively "launder" their funds. Thus, the goal of stopping eXch under the belief that it may stop all money laundering in the world is ridiculous.
Meanwhile, our project effectively provided privacy to all our customers and even anonymity to most. However, there are still far more effective ways to achieve it, thanks to these flagship projects that exist nowadays:
- Monero, with its total privacy, although not without some recently discovered issues that are serious and should be fixed with the Full-Chain Membership Proofs implementation
- Litecoin, with its optional privacy (MWEB)
- Dash, with its optional privacy
- Tornado Cash
- Bitcoin CoinJoin protocols
Another distinctive project that does not betray its mission is Thorchain. Even under the immense pressure that the whole industry had to deal with due to the irresponsible actions of those at ByBit, Thorchain was the only decentralized protocol that resisted the pressure to implement screening mechanisms at the protocol level, proving itself to be absolutely reliable. Even though all Thorchain trades are transparent on-chain, privacy and even total untraceability can be easily achieved when combined with some of the privacy-enabling projects mentioned above, when used correctly. However, the Thorchain network currently has a very limited choice of good interfaces, aside from Asgardex and MMGen wallets, and none of them are privacy-preserving, but we hope this can change.
Bitcoin privacy remains, however, in the midst of a notable crisis given the collapse of all important projects and protocols that had significant liquid CoinJoin-like pools. The most interesting and convenient of them in terms of usability remains WabiSabi; however, it needs some lightweight client implementations to achieve greater popularity in order to effectively prevent serious risks associated with Sybil attacks. We certainly know that most people in this space prefer lightweight solutions to heavy software solutions, and this factor can significantly affect the popularity and usage of any good project.
Given this, we are announcing a 50 BTC open-source fund to support any FOSS projects aiming to enhance the availability of privacy solutions. We hope we can still make a difference. Here are examples of the projects we will support:
- Bitcoin wallets and protocols aiming to preserve user privacy
- Lightweight clients for WabiSabi
- Thorchain wallets aiming to preserve user privacy
- Bisq Light Client
- Ethereum wallets and smart contracts aiming to preserve user privacy (an example of such might be a "non-rigged" fork of Railgun smart contracts and wallets allowing users to operate in Tor)
Unfortunately, we will not support projects that are written in Java, NodeJS, Go, or C#, especially developers who don't take module chain supply attacks seriously and believe they're some kind of "conspiracy theory".
There will be other projects that will hopefully take our place as the industry leader in privacy-oriented centralized exchanges, and we wish them success.
Our partners will still have access to our API for a limited time, but what happens after May 1st will depend on our new management team, who will be in possession of all access to our infrastructure. Thus, we recommend launching their own liquidity pools to guarantee seamless operation. We will provide consulting and recommendations to them.
Privacy is not a crime.
[thread locked for a few days for propagation]
While it is very frustrating to see a proejct of this calibre shut down, it looks like it was inevitable after the Bybit hack occured a few months ago. So you will need to search for alternatives.
Well, I don't know what I can say that I haven't said countless times already... The rulers do not want freedom for citizens, they only want control and oppression to a greater or lesser extent. While they continue to make laws that suit their interests and those of their powerful friends, the rest of us are branded as terrorists simply for wanting privacy in our lives, that is very unfair.they obviously used the hack on bybit to finally do what they all wanted to do back then which is shut down many platforms as much as they could and now they were given a reason to do that the community knew this would happen and we are right that they are being more strict and there could be unjustifiably shutting down of many platforms
Thanks to all members of the eXch team for showing the way forward.
The fight never ends.
According to what I read, they wanted the transaction fee used by Lazarus group. I do not think it can be of any significant amount if compared to the hack.While it is very frustrating to see a proejct of this calibre shut down, it looks like it was inevitable after the Bybit hack occured a few months ago. So you will need to search for alternatives.
In addition, let's not forget Bybit used to discriminate coin from eXch (which affect eXch customer) before they ask for eXch help. As for alternative that have optional/no KYC, people could try aggregated list on https://kycnot.me/ (https://kycnot.me/) and https://orangefren.com/ (https://orangefren.com/).
The complications of the Bybit hack are getting pretty big, even now affecting the closure of a major service that was not to blame for anythingI think that unfortunately it must be a vary bad news for all cryptocurrency world. So i believe that in this reason cryptocurrency market maybe fall off bad effect. Because we know that before occurred in incidents to bybit hacked, which could done many platform shutdown. I think that unfortunately it must be bad news for all crypto lover person. So eXch exchange also be hunt same level of bybit, which can be finish many important activists in this reason. Because we know that privacy security is one of the important issue for any exchange. I think that within a shot time this problem will solve.
It's bad news for the crypto world and for those who want and need privacy
But there is still hope that they can continue the service with a new management team. What do you think?
The complications of the Bybit hack are getting pretty big, even now affecting the closure of a major service that was not to blame for anything
It's bad news for the crypto world and for those who want and need privacy
But there is still hope that they can continue the service with a new management team. What do you think?
But there is still hope that they can continue the service with a new management team. What do you think?With a new name and if that includes a new management, possible. But I think they will lie low for a while because they could be monitored.
Yeah, i read it on bitcointalk. What more can i say, it is so sad, eXch is a wonderful service, what they stand for is exactly what we need in the community. However, i am a sure a lot of us knew the authorities will be serious in going after them and prosecuting those behind the service, they had no choice but to take this hard decision, and there we go, we lose another great privacy-oriented service.Really unfortunate to be honest, I've never used the services of eXch before but I do have a friend who was constantly using the platform, I feel bad to come to the knowledge that the platform is shutting down under this type of circumstances, it's not new actually, atleast, many other wonderful services in the past have shutdown due to this same reasons, but then, I like the management behind eXch for their boldness in knowing what is right to do and taking the bold step to do it, many other services in the past waited until the authorities came after them and they ended up shutting down abruptly in a way that even some of their customers lost money, but the team behind eXch choose to be different, I commend them for this step they took and wish them good success in their next project.
Such a sad end for eXch because the reality of their involvement in the hack coins dragged them into this whole mess and they were not prepared for this, since if they were, they could have not allowed such large inflows of funds from an already dented addresses since of allowed eventually will bring them into trouble.Yeah, i read it on bitcointalk. What more can i say, it is so sad, eXch is a wonderful service, what they stand for is exactly what we need in the community. However, i am a sure a lot of us knew the authorities will be serious in going after them and prosecuting those behind the service, they had no choice but to take this hard decision, and there we go, we lose another great privacy-oriented service.Really unfortunate to be honest, I've never used the services of eXch before but I do have a friend who was constantly using the platform, I feel bad to come to the knowledge that the platform is shutting down under this type of circumstances, it's not new actually, atleast, many other wonderful services in the past have shutdown due to this same reasons, but then, I like the management behind eXch for their boldness in knowing what is right to do and taking the bold step to do it, many other services in the past waited until the authorities came after them and they ended up shutting down abruptly in a way that even some of their customers lost money, but the team behind eXch choose to be different, I commend them for this step they took and wish them good success in their next project.
Such a sad end for eXch because the reality of their involvement in the hack coins dragged them into this whole mess and they were not prepared for this, since if they were, they could have not allowed such large inflows of funds from an already dented addresses since of allowed eventually will bring them into trouble.Yeah, i read it on bitcointalk. What more can i say, it is so sad, eXch is a wonderful service, what they stand for is exactly what we need in the community. However, i am a sure a lot of us knew the authorities will be serious in going after them and prosecuting those behind the service, they had no choice but to take this hard decision, and there we go, we lose another great privacy-oriented service.Really unfortunate to be honest, I've never used the services of eXch before but I do have a friend who was constantly using the platform, I feel bad to come to the knowledge that the platform is shutting down under this type of circumstances, it's not new actually, atleast, many other wonderful services in the past have shutdown due to this same reasons, but then, I like the management behind eXch for their boldness in knowing what is right to do and taking the bold step to do it, many other services in the past waited until the authorities came after them and they ended up shutting down abruptly in a way that even some of their customers lost money, but the team behind eXch choose to be different, I commend them for this step they took and wish them good success in their next project.
According to what I read, they wanted the transaction fee used by Lazarus group. I do not think it can be of any significant amount if compared to the hack.While it is very frustrating to see a proejct of this calibre shut down, it looks like it was inevitable after the Bybit hack occured a few months ago. So you will need to search for alternatives.
In addition, let's not forget Bybit used to discriminate coin from eXch (which affect eXch customer) before they ask for eXch help. As for alternative that have optional/no KYC, people could try aggregated list on https://kycnot.me/ (https://kycnot.me/) and https://orangefren.com/ (https://orangefren.com/).
Also eXch said only small amount did Lazarus group transact on the exchange and not the $35 million dollar that investigators claimed.
In my opinion, any direct dealing with hackers by a non KYC exchange is risky, and they should have known the implications of exchanging stolen funds which they knew it could be traced by investigators and the Bybit exchange team itself.I agree with you about this. I do not know how good the tracking system of these exchanges is. Coins coming from Lazarus group in relation to Bybit hack is too loud and such money should have been seized instead. This would have given eXch a good reputation.
Lazarus hackers are on the news about their Bybit hacks, and it was very obvious that the stolen funds were being monitored. I think that eXch exchange took unnecessary risk by doing business with hackers if it is actually this information was true.
they obviously used the hack on bybit to finally do what they all wanted to do back then which is shut down many platforms as much as they could and now they were given a reason to do that the community knew this would happen and we are right that they are being more strict and there could be unjustifiably shutting down of many platformsIts really shocking because the exchange was smooth and the team was perfect, and as of now, when I read their last post, I mean 50 BTC, that's insane, they have big hearts. I wonder if Satoshi has to do something with this project, haha BTW, I don't think the authorities forced them, as you sound. They made it clear they don't want to harm the innocent people of forum, which is really amazing.
It is very unfortunate that eXch will close its service, even though I already know this announcement from Bitcointalk but still can't forget this service.There will definitely be a solution in the future, it is really unfortunate that this exchange has closed, even though many users feel comfortable using it, without KYC they can already make transactions, is this KYC problem what made them close?
Because now every time I pay from my usual mixer I immediately exchange at eXch and now they will be closed in early May this is really sad.
Maybe I will look for other alternatives instead of eXch.
There will definitely be a solution in the future, it is really unfortunate that this exchange has closed, even though many users feel comfortable using it, without KYC they can already make transactions, is this KYC problem what made them close?
Recently, we received confirmation of information we had previously, thanks to some friends we have even in the state intelligence sector, that our project is the subject of an active transatlantic operation aimed at forcibly shutting our project down and prosecuting us for "money laundering and terrorism."
Suspect that Bybit may continue to report this exchange for closure, but we don't know what kind of pressure eXch is receiving.There will definitely be a solution in the future, it is really unfortunate that this exchange has closed, even though many users feel comfortable using it, without KYC they can already make transactions, is this KYC problem what made them close?
In a nutshell, and according to themselves:QuoteRecently, we received confirmation of information we had previously, thanks to some friends we have even in the state intelligence sector, that our project is the subject of an active transatlantic operation aimed at forcibly shutting our project down and prosecuting us for "money laundering and terrorism."
And this was greatly aggravated by the Bybit hack a few weeks ago
I was not happy when i heard of this and it makes me remember that of mixers when it was announced that they should no longer be allowed to operate on the other forum before they got peace to stay here, am not that comfortable with anything that has to do with allegation and because the way government are taking down on these sites are somewhat suspicious and at the same time threatening to us in cryptocurrency, because the victimization is not getting too much, that an exchange like this gets nuked by the same government for unreasonable reason they cant establish the fact.I only knew about eXch when they refused to process the hacker's funds during the Bybit event. It's quite something how straightforward their response was, and they certainly don't forget old grudges! I'm not sure if that's why they had to suddenly cease operations though, haha.
Its really shocking because the exchange was smooth and the team was perfect, and as of now, when I read their last post, I mean 50 BTC, that's insane, they have big hearts. I wonder if Satoshi has to do something with this project, haha BTW, I don't think the authorities forced them, as you sound. They made it clear they don't want to harm the innocent people of forum, which is really amazing.
I mean, many platforms have been seized before, and people got their money stuck forever, only this time, people won't lose money, I guess. I wonder what the next management will bring. Best of luck to them, and I hope these illicit actors will stop someday using a brilliant technology for bad purposes.
they obviously used the hack on bybit to finally do what they all wanted to do back then which is shut down many platforms as much as they could and now they were given a reason to do that the community knew this would happen and we are right that they are being more strict and there could be unjustifiably shutting down of many platformsIts really shocking because the exchange was smooth and the team was perfect, and as of now, when I read their last post, I mean 50 BTC, that's insane, they have big hearts. I wonder if Satoshi has to do something with this project, haha BTW, I don't think the authorities forced them, as you sound. They made it clear they don't want to harm the innocent people of forum, which is really amazing.
I mean, many platforms have been seized before, and people got their money stuck forever, only this time, people won't lose money, I guess. I wonder what the next management will bring. Best of luck to them, and I hope these illicit actors will stop someday using a brilliant technology for bad purposes.
There will definitely come a time when a business will suddenly close down unexpectedly, maybe because of the intensity of the competitions or maybe they have not reached the target volume that the platform should have received, so it has ended up like that. What do you think?
I am seeing this service, which has been providing its signature service since the beginning days when I used to post on Bitcointalk, and now, in my point of view, saying goodbye to that last good service is hard for its members who are earning the best pay rewards from this campaign.You are right, it was the only non-gabbing campaign after mixers that lasted this long and was really long term project and you know this just by seeing the team's words. Although there is another non gamlbing campaign by icp named as peach bitcoin, but they don't pay everyone, don't know the details as never applied or heard about it like in terms of Open for applicants, so don't know the acceptance procedure of it.
Well, I think it is the last non-gambling campaign after mixers that is providing its signature on the BitcoinTalk till May 1st. And, after that day, only gambling campaigns will be left on BTT, according to my knowledge. Am I right?
Peach bitcoin is a voluntary campaign so you can sign up and be accepted immediately, but if I'm not mistaken in this campaign whoever is the best poster will get a bonus.I am seeing this service, which has been providing its signature service since the beginning days when I used to post on Bitcointalk, and now, in my point of view, saying goodbye to that last good service is hard for its members who are earning the best pay rewards from this campaign.You are right, it was the only non-gabbing campaign after mixers that lasted this long and was really long term project and you know this just by seeing the team's words. Although there is another non gamlbing campaign by icp named as peach bitcoin, but they don't pay everyone, don't know the details as never applied or heard about it like in terms of Open for applicants, so don't know the acceptance procedure of it.
Well, I think it is the last non-gambling campaign after mixers that is providing its signature on the BitcoinTalk till May 1st. And, after that day, only gambling campaigns will be left on BTT, according to my knowledge. Am I right?
I am also waiting for non gambling campaign on BTT and I really hoped in 2026 Theymos will lift the ban but seeing this I don't think things will get to normal anytime soon.
I am seeing this service, which has been providing its signature service since the beginning days when I used to post on Bitcointalk, and now, in my point of view, saying goodbye to that last good service is hard for its members who are earning the best pay rewards from this campaign.
Well, I think it is the last non-gambling campaign after mixers that is providing its signature on the BitcoinTalk till May 1st. And, after that day, only gambling campaigns will be left on BTT, according to my knowledge. Am I right?
You are right, it was the only non-gabbing campaign after mixers that lasted this long and was really long term project and you know this just by seeing the team's words. Although there is another non gamlbing campaign by icp named as peach bitcoin, but they don't pay everyone, don't know the details as never applied or heard about it like in terms of Open for applicants, so don't know the acceptance procedure of it.
I am also waiting for non gambling campaign on BTT and I really hoped in 2026 Theymos will lift the ban but seeing this I don't think things will get to normal anytime soon.
Peach bitcoin is a voluntary campaign so you can sign up and be accepted immediately, but if I'm not mistaken in this campaign whoever is the best poster will get a bonus.Oh that (about good poster) I did not knew, well I never applied for it, as now on BTT I am free as not in any campaign I might give it some try to see if I am good poster in sight of Icopress or not, it is a good thing.
Hopefully this is good news so that theymos will lift the ban again, but this also depends on how friendly the US government is to this service, if it gets more complicated then it is likely that theymos will not lift it.
The room for privacy is getting thinner day by day, it's so unfortunate that they have to shut down after doing very good job in building their reputation, especially on bitcointalk. I guess we still have few of that kind but their future will be uncertain because they are not big as exch and might be the next prey for the regulators in real soon.That's reality! Privacy is dwindling as governments keep trying to dismantle platforms with privacy services making it harder for us to be anonymous.
It is unfortunate that they would have to shut down this way, as it was not their fault that the Lazarus group used their platform to transact stolen assets. They had no idea, and I believe if you ask them too they would say the same but fate just held them ransom this way and they had to give up their position in the industry but I believe they would bounce back and in another form so that the government do not come after them again.I'm not exactly sure what pressures eXch is facing that led them to cease operations, but it seems like everything stems from their actions when they were exploited by hackers in the Bybit incident. eXch chose to remain neutral and didn't intervene, which led to them being seen as accomplices and enablers of the hackers.
I think you are right, all sig campaigns that pay in BTC are now exclusively gambling sites. In my opinion, it's not the best for that forum, because most of those campaigns either ask for a certain number of weekly posts in Gambling boards or suggest it in some way.
~snip~
Well, everyone has their own preference being a part of any project, and in my case, I avoid joining gambling projects as possible as I can avoid them. Just a random question from you mate, have you ever join a gambling signature campaign?
This campaign is voluntary and pays nothing; it is there just to get support, and it's all up to you. Like, if your signature space is free, you can put on peach campaign signature until you are not into any paid signature campaign, and I have been part of two voluntary campaigns, Peach and Bitlst, and both campaigns manager is the same, and I am still putting on a Bitlist signature on my BTT profile.No it do pays If you will check the Bitcoin signature observer thread on bitcointalk, you will see this signature is listed there as in paid list and it pays $4 per post even as the salad dagging said before, the campaign is voluntary, but it do pay.
Well, honestly, let's see how things will be in the next year on BTT, as I am also the one who is waiting for non-gambling projects on BTT, and I am seeing that there are a lot of gambling signature projects that are providing their signature service on BTT, and there is not even one non-gambling project there on BTT. Well, dear, if you remember, there was a wallet campaign on BTT with the name of Wasabi Wallet Signature Campaign on BTT." Do you have any idea why this campaign stopped providing its service?Nah I don't have any idea about it, maybe because they had some similarity with coinjoin or mixer feature, but I don't know for sure, you have to look for yourself, I did read about it but now I can't remember.
It is unfortunate that they would have to shut down this way, as it was not their fault that the Lazarus group used their platform to transact stolen assets. They had no idea, and I believe if you ask them too they would say the same but fate just held them ransom this way and they had to give up their position in the industry but I believe they would bounce back and in another form so that the government do not come after them again.
they obviously used the hack on bybit to finally do what they all wanted to do back then which is shut down many platforms as much as they could and now they were given a reason to do that the community knew this would happen and we are right that they are being more strict and there could be unjustifiably shutting down of many platforms
I also think we're likely to see more exchanges shut down. Their excuses (some people call them laws) are almost perfect and likely have widespread support among those unfamiliar with cryptocurrencies, money laundering and terrorist financing. Anyone asked about the exchanges that supposedly fund and approve these activities would respond that those services should be shut down immediately, what they don't know is that it's not true. Taking advantage of one's own failure, whether technological or human, to harm others, in one way or another, doesn't reflect well on the exchange's name or the cryptocurrency industry.
I also think we're likely to see more exchanges shut down. Their excuses (some people call them laws) are almost perfect and likely have widespread support among those unfamiliar with cryptocurrencies, money laundering and terrorist financing. Anyone asked about the exchanges that supposedly fund and approve these activities would respond that those services should be shut down immediately, what they don't know is that it's not true. Taking advantage of one's own failure, whether technological or human, to harm others, in one way or another, doesn't reflect well on the exchange's name or the cryptocurrency industry.I personally think that if we still look at any survey, we will see that most of the cases of money laundering and other crimes are happening through fiat currency. I am not saying that crypto currency or such services are not involved in money laundering or other illegal activities at all, but even though these activities are more visible through fiat currency, we are more likely to express an assumption about crypto currency or these related tools. Which main target is to creates bad image for the crypto space.
This is why i never put funds in an exchange account because most of the time the exchange gets hacked and then shuts down. This is really a shame i have used their services a few times in the past and it all went smoothly. If we want we can use the best exchanges like binance and kucoin because their security is very good. I have seen that top exchanges do not face much hacking problems. eXch has completely shut down, it is sad for everyone. I wish them and their management all the best so everyone will be more careful.This case is more than what you think man, because hard it been that this exchange was never traced with the Bybit jack loots nothing could have happened to the platform and as for bad fact that their are one if the no KYC cryptocurrency exchange that give high priorities to users privacy, so the Lazarus group exploited that privacy features pn eXch.
No it do pays If you will check the Bitcoin signature observer thread on bitcointalk, you will see this signature is listed there as in paid list and it pays $4 per post even as the salad dagging said before, the campaign is voluntary, but it do pay.
Nah I don't have any idea about it, maybe because they had some similarity with coinjoin or mixer feature, but I don't know for sure, you have to look for yourself, I did read about it but now I can't remember.
It is unfortunate that they would have to shut down this way, as it was not their fault that the Lazarus group used their platform to transact stolen assets. They had no idea, and I believe if you ask them too they would say the same but fate just held them ransom this way and they had to give up their position in the industry but I believe they would bounce back and in another form so that the government do not come after them again.I'm not exactly sure what pressures eXch is facing that led them to cease operations, but it seems like everything stems from their actions when they were exploited by hackers in the Bybit incident. eXch chose to remain neutral and didn't intervene, which led to them being seen as accomplices and enablers of the hackers.
I'm not saying eXch's actions were wrong, but it's quite risky for the fate of these CEXs. Governments don't want this to happen again, CEXs that don't implement KYC will be in the crosshairs of regulations. Anonymity is no longer as prioritized as transparency and cooperation!
Ahan, then I don't have any idea, as I have also been a part of both these campaigns, Bitcoin Peach and BitList. Well, I do know that the BitList campaign is paying weekly bonuses to the good posters, but according to what I knew, Bitcoin Peach is paying nothing, and if it is paying $4 per week, then it's great, mate.Okay, I never joined any of these before, but will surely join them sooner or later. I did not know Bitlist was paying because I did not see it on the signature observer list, (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=615953.3740)
I am way too busy these days; if I get spare time, I will surely check about this. I asked you because you are a senior member, and you may have kinda idea about this, but you also don't remember it as well, hehe.I just checked the last post by Icopress on the Wasabi Wallet thread, and it just says they are stopping the campaign, no reason is given. if you want to check, then here is the link, busy boy https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5401963.msg63791790#msg63791790 I just guessed that, so I think there was no specific reason they stopped it like you were expecting.
Okay, I never joined any of these before, but will surely join them sooner or later. I did not know Bitlist was paying because I did not see it on the signature observer list, (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=615953.3740)
<snip>