I think you dont expess your points clearly as it is neded, the negative karma you get is due to the poor English and shallow explanation you give. You should write a lengthy and deep expression. Avoid the short anwsers. This means you should do a thorough reserch before you start doing the real task.

Wow, I never thought about this topic from such positions, it's really cool then by any means, let's continue with such for example later, maybe you do have some other points of view absolutely and possibly out there. So let's move on with such.

Thank you, yeah, let’s be optimistic. They have this requirement that if you do the withdrawal, you don’t get the bonus. So I’ll be able to withdraw the funds only after the bonus time is over (not sure if I’ll get the requires turnover or not). But I will definitely let everyone know when I’m done with that, either successfully or not. 

I understand. You are right in some sense. Many brokerages want traders to lose. But there are others that earn with commissions and spreads. I really hope AAFX is the second case. Was hoping to find some traders here that have tried the brokerage themselves but now I’m gonna be the pioneer myself. It’s been three weeks so far. I didn’t do any withdrawals yet, so have not much to say. On the other hand, they don’t do any of those dirty tricks with slippages and quotes manipulations for sure. At least I haven’t noticed any problems with executions so far. Bonus is putting some pressure on for sure, but the rest of it is ok so far.

Yeap, I know that. But you see, I came in crypto market from regular stock market. I’ve been trading stocks for a few years and  I know for sure that investing in SnP500 index is much safer that investing on one of  the stocks from the list. Moreover, if you choose the wrong stock, you may run into troubles and the probability of such troubles is much higher if you use just one stock. Especially if it deals with some unexplored technologies or pharmaceuticals. Just one mistake of company’s management - and here is the black swan that swallows your deposit. I view Bitcoin as such index that shows the overall tendency in the crypto-world. When BTC grows, alts grow and vice versa. I don’t like alts for enormous 100%  risks that they offer along with high profits probability.

This is actually why I’m asking. I have the same suspicions, but according to the rules, it’s not that bad. They give you 60 days to trade and if the volume is big enough, they transfer the bonus to your main account from where you’ll be able to withdraw it to bank. Unfortunately the bonus is no longer 40% as well. But still 35% for the first deposit. If I won’t find anyone who’s tried the service here, I might need to be the AAFX pioneer and try it myself.

Currently I'm looking for a decent brokerage that would allow trading both traditional assets and bitcoin. To tell the truth, I'm not that much interested in alts so far, but Bitcoin still seems to be interesting in a long-term perspective.
I liked AAFX for they have really attractive spreads for all the assets, no commissions and most importantly currently offer 40% bonus to new account replenishments. The claim is the bonus is withdrawable. Did anyone work with this brokerage? Is it really withdrawable? How difficult is it to complete the requirements for bonus withdrawal?