This is an excellent proposal, I don't know how technically feasible it is, but it is definitely worth considering.

I don't think so because it breaks the core value of Bitcoin Protocol. It's your private key, it's your bitcoin.

It will never happen!
Even if you increase the age, even if you decrease the amount taken by 50 or 90% no such proposal will ever be accepted.

The main problem is not what it does itself but the fact that everyone will see it as opening Pandora's box, if this happens then what's next? And people's imagination will run wild, what if next it's a mandatory annual tax of 0.1% on all coins?
Furthermore, you have Satoshi's own opinion, lost coins are a donation, he had no plan to recycle them.

I agree with you.

Bitcoin is our own banks, with private keys, or mnemonic seeds. If there is a term like this in the Protocol, and a code to refund our bitcoins after 50 inactive years, people will lose their faith in Bitcoin.

The threshold is hard to define too. 50 years, people have longer lifespan that it and even threshold is 100 years, there are people can live longer than that. More important, Bitcoin can be used as inherited asset for our children and family members, from generation to generation.

This idea breaks all of good core value of Bitcoin Protocol.

It is a Pandora box we never want to open similarly to increase Bitcoin total supply.

I have been doing that for a year, and I am glad I decided not to spend all my signature earnings. If someone can save their entire signature earnings, that is good. But, if they cannot, they should save at least half of it. Some locals asked when I had invested and how much my buying price was. The simple answer is that I never bought BTC for holding purposes. All the BTC and altcoins I have now are Signature earnings from the other forum.

Congratulations for your good savings in bitcoins.

As for classic DCA and SDCA, I guess the classic one is better. Just increase the amount during the dip market and decrease when it's pumped. That is what I think.

By bringing this topic, I only wanted to bring something I discovered, new to everyone but as I noted, Classic (Traditional) DCA is better for most of us. For people who can use Smart DCA better, go ahead with it.

According to my personal observations, this strategy is not always profitable on the distance. Therefore, it is necessary to be extremely careful. Not everything works the way we would like it to. Especially, this strategy cannot work properly, when the price of bitcoin (the whole cryptocurrency) has already given hundreds of % returns, over the last year.

By applying Smart DCA, you might miss lower prices, better entries but with Smart DCA, you buy dips and can get profit quickly.

It is good strategy in a bull market but in bear market, if you don't have enough experience, you can buy dips and hold, so end with loss with time before the market starts its recovery from bottom.

Agree with your opinion, we cannot determine the accuracy of purchasing bitcoins, because it is very difficult. DCA only tries to buy bitcoin with a method that is consistent with the amount of money we can determine. As you said, we can set the time to shop, and of course for small investors like me we can buy a little but consistently.

DCA is more about spending money on accumulation of bitcoin for your portfolio. You don't have to spend a fixed amount of money like $100 or $1,000 for each of your DCA entry. The point is you can assign a minimum fixed capital for each entry but if you have more, you can increase the DCA capital for any DCA round.

You can DCA like a clock, with fixed time, fixed capital but you can be flexible with it too because life is not like a clock and your financial status can change too.

DCA method is definitely a good way for small investors to invest their small funds.

It is one of biggest wrong thinking about DCA. DCA is for everyone, from small to big investors.

MicroStrategy is DCA and they are not a small investor. Whales apply DCA too and surely we can not say whales are small investors.
https://saylortracker.com/
MicroStrategy is winning big

Usually, after the halving occurs, the price of bitcoin will have the potential to collapse temporarily because there will definitely be miners and whales who will try to sell their assets and have an influence on bitcoin price movements in the market, but when I look at the history of bitcoin price movements in the past four years then there is a possibility that after the price collapses it will rise again at a very high price.

It is your speculation and price can fluctuate with not big up or down changes around halving or it will have a surge or a massive weak down. We all can not know what will happen in future but if you have bitcoin, hold it tightly as months after a halving, we will have a massive bull market.

If you have spare money, let's be ready for accumulate more bitcoins. Don't miss the party!

Satoshi Nakamoto was last seen active on the forum December 13, 2010

Satoshi Nakamoto never used Altcoinstalks and he disappeared years before Altcoinstalks forum was created.

In my opinion, it will be very dangerous when Satoshi Nakamoto's identity is known. There is a possibility that if Satoshi Nakamoto's identity was known then the price would not be as expensive as it is now.

I agree and disagree.

I agree that if Satoshi Nakamoto identity is known, still alive, the market will have some price shocks with fud and fear that Satoshi Nakamoto will dump his bitcoins on the market and drag the price down.

I disagree that price shock won't last long, and price will recover after all. Because even Satoshi Nakamoto (if alive), can not shut down Bitcoin network, can not roll back the blockchain. His existence can not help government to shut down Bitcoin blockchain and its network.

Yeah most futures traders will benefit more on these up and down trends.

Futures Trading is risky and I am very doubtful that if a trader lives to trade Futures, he will end up with Positive Net Profit. Probability to end up with Massive Loss is more realistic.

There are many ways to find out the right position to enter cryptocurrency, but the need for better analysis is really needed, therefore if you are more comfortable using the DCA method then continue to consistently use that method because so far the movements using this method have had quite accurate results. .

DCA is to avoid finding right positions to enter the market because the bottom line is, You can not find it accurately in price and time.

By finding right positions, you will be affected by emotion, psychology and if you miss a right position, you will start to make bad decisions.

DCA is a powerful strategy to help you avoid (1) Timing the market (2) Finding right positions (3) Eliminate effects from emotion and psychology.

but it's unfortunate I didn't notice that the minimum deposit of the exchange is 0.0005BTC. So, I didn't receive last week pay, which means the scam CEX got it instead.

That exchange did not scam you if they wrote it in their website like their exchange fee (withdrawal, deposit ...) or at the Deposit page in your account.

If they have it, they did not scam you and you were irresponsible with your money by did not read it. Afaik, exchanges have min deposit for each cryptocurrency.

I was aware of the smart DCA method before but did not come up with some term to call it, so it's a small DCA. Well, both have their own use cases in separate situations and in my view, there are no restrictions in using one strategy in place of another. For example, we can do smart DCA even in the bearish run and can do DCA in a bull run. I don't think there are any restrictions on it.

If people want to do DCA smartly but only base on their thinking and don't have any reliable indicator to use, they might have bad practice than Traditional DCA.

It's the point and use case of this Smart DCA indicator. Perhaps this indicator is useful for people who want to do Smart DCA for their investment. The bottom line is whether this Smart DCA indicator is reliable enough.

I still prefer using the traditional way of DCAing my Bitcoins because it doesn't need for me to learn technical analysis and any other complicated techniques that will keep my eye on the screen for hours. This is what caused stress to me a few years back so I will stick to the traditional one from now onwards.

If you consider this Smart DCA indicator is reliable, you can use it without much own work for technical analysis. Because the author already did the hard work for you and the indicator is public to use.

The graphic chart you have created here can be very helpful for beginners if they understand this chart well.

You can access it directly on CryptoQuant, but you must create a free account, then visit the following link to access that chart.

• https://cryptoquant.com/community/dashboard/650de954ca432c72d6ef82b1
• There are more charts from AxelAdlerJr on that dashboard.
• When you have an account, you can access the chart, zoom in and zoom out.

If newbies do not understand this chart well, they may not find it very helpful.

The chart has good summary and basic information which is not difficult for newbies to get its meaning.