No gamblers in trading becomes profitable. If we think what we are doing is gambling, we should take a break in trading.
Profitable or not, it will depend on the strategy. If someone gambles in trading, it will be too risky because he doesn't have any idea about the strategy in trading. Sure, it is better to stop and focus learning about the basic thing in trading first.
However, even if we have a good strategy because we joined mentorships, it doesn't mean it works for you. You are not the same as your mentor because you are a newbie, we should follow what he teach step by step because that is the only we need to become him in the future.
I don't really understand about mentorships, I think we can learn trading ourselves.
I never have a mentor, I learn trading myself and I practice trading myself, but I focus learning everything about trading first before doing it. However, if you have a trusted mentor, it is also good.
If you ignore his advice, this is the problem you need to fix to be profitable in trading.
What advice? Mentor advice?
I think it depends what advice it is. If the advice looks realistic, just follow the advice.