What's your own take if everyone would have held their Bitcoin and not sell

[slapper]

If everyone keep their Bitcoin and no one sell, the system would fall apart on its own or worse: freeze in time. People love to talk about Bitcoin as currency, yet socially punish anyone who uses it. Bitcoin was born as a tool for decentralization, but it became a symbol of financial identity. People who say "you shouldn't have sold," are projecting psychological regret, loss aversion, and status anxiety. Being seen as someone who "HODL" is now more important than using Bitcoin to purchase pizza

If no one sells:

There is no liquidity

No price discovery

No functioning market

It's merely a piece from a museum with numbers on it. Holding everything forever is a fantasy economics can't support. Still, you are right to sense a loss in something. Store-of- value maximalism has taken over what was intended to empower regular transactions. We silently changed the narrative somewhere in the transition from p2p currency to "digital gold"

Those that sell their Bitcoin are not traitors then. They’re participants. Every transaction pushes the network ahead. And sometimes growth means spending

[ZAINmalik75]

I mean I am not fan of imaginitive or speculative scenarios (it's impossible to happen that everyone would hoard it) but I suppose the usual supply and demand law would come into play and it should have effect on BTC's price positively.

Regarding whether it's bad thing about selling BTC; if you are in need of money, it's never a wrong idea to sell your asset, that's my opinion anyway.

This scenario created by OP is imaginative because no one want to hold their BTC till death although people used to say if you want to hold BTC hold it till death but they don't really mean never use them for yourselves.

If a person is in need of funds they should sell their BTC or whatever assets they have otherwise they will tend to take loan and in my opinion taking loan should be an option when we have none left.

[Mr. Magkaisa]

I mean I am not fan of imaginitive or speculative scenarios (it's impossible to happen that everyone would hoard it) but I suppose the usual supply and demand law would come into play and it should have effect on BTC's price positively.

Regarding whether it's bad thing about selling BTC; if you are in need of money, it's never a wrong idea to sell your asset, that's my opinion anyway.

This scenario created by OP is imaginative because no one want to hold their BTC till death although people used to say if you want to hold BTC hold it till death but they don't really mean never use them for yourselves.

If a person is in need of funds they should sell their BTC or whatever assets they have otherwise they will tend to take loan and in my opinion taking loan should be an option when we have none left.

            -     You know, I think it's just the op's imagination that everyone who has bitcoin and is buying it now or in the coming days will only hold it after a year before selling. Can this be considered trading if that is the only reason or purpose of an investor?

All over the world, all holders are the same or they will only sell bitcoin on the same date and year? Is that what he means? The op's question is not really realistic. Because not all bitcoin holders have the same time, day, and month when they have a problem that will require money. Therefore, asking such a question is nonsense. Sorry but this is my opinion.

[Gurujebs]

This scenario created by OP is imaginative because no one want to hold their BTC till death although people used to say if you want to hold BTC hold it till death but they don't really mean never use them for yourselves.

If a person is in need of funds they should sell their BTC or whatever assets they have otherwise they will tend to take loan and in my opinion taking loan should be an option when we have none left.

Bitcoin is having adoption and one of the principal ways of it's adoption is daily usage, people buy and sell Bitcoin everyday, it will be impossible to for people to buy Bitcoin and not sell, their money is going to be stock on Bitcoin and no money elsewhere to fund whatever business or things they do, and not everyone will even trust to hold.

The only way people can buy a coin and not be able to sell is if Bitcoin is having a smart contract where it can only buy and not sell, there is a OP function for that but it's not build for something like this and beside, where is the freedom, it will make Bitcoin to be more centralized.

[JoyMarsha]

So long as Bitcoin can be traded at any time of the day, the buying and selling positions of Bitcoin will always be open for anyone to do that at any time of the day they choose.

Bitcoin is a global asset that people are willing to buy and sell. Some investors or a group of investors can decide not to sell for long, but others will they do the same when they keep hodling, not to sell when they have seen some profits from their Bitcoin investment. Everyone selling position of Bitcoin is on different prices.

[sampoerna]

If there is no one trading Bitcoin anymore and it is no longer attractive, only for investment, then trading volume will be even more difficult. because there will definitely be a decline.

Oh yeah, talking about holding Bitcoin, whether it is long term or very short, it will still affect our mental possibilities when we reach the target to sell Bitcoin at a certain price rate.

[KryptoBull]

So just for curiosity sake,

I really want to know what would have been the outcome if actually everyone stopped selling their Bitcoin and instead held on to it and the reason is because it's so tiring whenever you hear people complain about how someone have maybe made mistake by actually using or selling their Bitcoin but and am always suprised at this because Bitcoin itself is a currency that it's initial purpose was to be centered on decentralization and financial fairness but as it grew it's value or ability to be used as store of value have made people think that anyone who sells his Bitcoin is actually doing wrongly.

I also sold 20% of my BTC holdings at 100K USD, and honestly, I don't think I made a mistake or need any advice on asset management. I entered the crypto market to seek profit, and taking profits is a natural action to realize gains in fiat currency.

Many people love BTC to an extreme, and they believe everyone should hold BTC instead of trading in the market. Fortunately, the market doesn't meet their demands, people still continuously buy and sell BTC 24/7 and maintain very good liquidity, which helps everyone invest in BTC with the lowest possible barrier.

[bayu7adi]

So just for curiosity sake,

I really want to know what would have been the outcome if actually everyone stopped selling their Bitcoin and instead held on to it and the reason is because it's so tiring whenever you hear people complain about how someone have maybe made mistake by actually using or selling their Bitcoin but and am always suprised at this because Bitcoin itself is a currency that it's initial purpose was to be centered on decentralization and financial fairness but as it grew it's value or ability to be used as store of value have made people think that anyone who sells his Bitcoin is actually doing wrongly.

By not transacting the Bitcoins you own, it will certainly reduce the supply circulating in the market, and when Bitcoin is difficult to obtain, its price will skyrocket because demand does not decrease.... Bitcoin will skyrocket and holders will benefit from the increasing value of the Bitcoins they own...

However, this makes the market unhealthy... Bitcoin should still be transacted so that its adoption can continue to be wider... in addition, holding by everyone simultaneously makes Bitcoin no longer move freely... at least it takes a balance between supply and demand to get the ideal market price...

Holders will be happy because the value increases, while newcomers will feel tortured because the price is too expensive.

[Gposas]

So just for curiosity sake,

I really want to know what would have been the outcome if actually everyone stopped selling their Bitcoin and instead held on to it and the reason is because it's so tiring whenever you hear people complain about how someone have maybe made mistake by actually using or selling their Bitcoin but and am always suprised at this because Bitcoin itself is a currency that it's initial purpose was to be centered on decentralization and financial fairness but as it grew it's value or ability to be used as store of value have made people think that anyone who sells his Bitcoin is actually doing wrongly.

To my little knowledge, if everyone holds Bitcoin and stops selling...., something will be missing and probably the Bitcoin supply will be bought to the last fragment on a very swift manner.

But taking a look from the bigger picture, the candlestick patterns on the market trend will not be complete, we will be observing only green candles.

Also, there'll be no usefulness of miners...

So, if the price of BTC possibly surge as a result of no sales... Then it'll leave some form of negative impact on other aspects.