Altcoins Talks - Cryptocurrency Forum

Cryptocurrency Ecosystem => Bitcoin Forum => Topic started by: bitmover on January 15, 2024, 01:06:55 AM

Title: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 15, 2024, 01:06:55 AM
Just like in bitcointalk, I created this thread so we can observe the mempool.

This images always show the mempool in realtime:

Recommended fees:

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)
Code: [Select]
[img height=150]https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php[/img]
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/chart.php) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)

Code: [Select]
[img]https://bitcoindata.science/api/chart.php[/img]
Anyone can use those images, just use the codes above. Data  is always updated.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: tranthidung on January 15, 2024, 04:00:48 AM
Anyone can use those images, just use the codes above. Data  is always updated.
Great tool and I like the chart as it summaries what's going on with Bitcoin transaction fee.

Welcome to [Huge List] Bitcoin Helpful Links/ Tools (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=315152.0)

I'd like to know did you use data from mempool.space to make this chart, as I recalled you did it with your previous tools.

Or you actually run your Bitcoin full node 24/7 and use it for your tools nowadays?

Do you want to host something like https://mempool.jhoenicke.de/#BTC,24h,weigh
It's open source code. (https://github.com/jhoenicke/mempool)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on January 15, 2024, 07:01:13 AM
(https://bitcoindata.science/bot/chart.php) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)
I was wondering about the line below, isn't it supposed to be 0 sat/vB, as this almost always happens when two blocks are mined with a relatively short time interval, so the block is broadcast without transaction fees?

Your charts are helpful and I will use them in the future. The code is simple, thank you.

Welcome to [Huge List] Bitcoin Helpful Links/ Tools (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=315152.0)
with such lists we will have a new Ratimov
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: tranthidung on January 15, 2024, 12:02:25 PM
I was wondering about the line below, isn't it supposed to be 0 sat/vB, as this almost always happens when two blocks are mined with a relatively short time interval, so the block is broadcast without transaction fees?
Only Mining pools can add their own transactions without any fee, 0 sat/vbyte is possible but as normal Bitcoin users, you can not use that fee rate and get confirmations nowadays.

Quote
with such lists we will have a new Ratimov
Ratimov/ Symmetrick is not here and in Bitcointalk, already RIP.

Don't bring the saga back and it even does not belong here. Also I am not him.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 15, 2024, 01:07:57 PM
I'd like to know did you use data from mempool.space to make this chart, as I recalled you did it with your previous tools.

Or you actually run your Bitcoin full node 24/7 and use it for your tools nowadays?

I still use data from mempool.space, they have an amazing API
https://mempool.space/docs/api/rest

I was wondering about the line below, isn't it supposed to be 0 sat/vB, as this almost always happens when two blocks are mined with a relatively short time interval, so the block is broadcast without transaction fees?

I think you are correct. I will fix that! Coinbase have 0 sat/vbyte fees
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on January 15, 2024, 02:40:39 PM
That is a tool, nice work again  ;)

I don't know if you may have overlooked it, but it would also be handy to display the time on a horizontal line on this chart. It would make reading the chart much easier.

also, not sure why don't you add a source (bitcoindata.science/API for example) to your graphics, maybe even a link if possible.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 15, 2024, 02:48:16 PM
That is a tool, nice work again  ;)

I don't know if you may have overlooked it, but it would also be handy to display the time on a horizontal line on this chart. It would make reading the chart much easier.
Yeah, this is needed.

I will add you axis labels,  probably the date for each day. This is still a work in progress.

Quote
also, not sure why don't you add a source (bitcoindata.science/API for example) to your graphics, maybe even a link if possible.

Good idea! I will do that!
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Don Pedro Dinero on January 15, 2024, 03:52:53 PM
It's crazy about the mempool and fees these days. They had finally come down to about 30 sats/vByte and between Saturday and Sunday 100,000 transactions were dumped on the mempool, raising the fees above 200 sats/vByte. Since then it seems that nobody is spaming the mempool and both pending transactions and fees are gradually dropping, but it has seemed like a roller coaster over the last few days.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 16, 2024, 10:21:10 AM
Can we adjust the size of image and make it smaller?
Maybe forum administration can add your mempool observer tool in top right corner or somewhere in the page bottom.
This can be optional settings selected from profile page settings, and fees for other altcoins can also be included.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitterguy28 on January 16, 2024, 12:23:59 PM
It's crazy about the mempool and fees these days. They had finally come down to about 30 sats/vByte and between Saturday and Sunday 100,000 transactions were dumped on the mempool, raising the fees above 200 sats/vByte. Since then it seems that nobody is spaming the mempool and both pending transactions and fees are gradually dropping, but it has seemed like a roller coaster over the last few days.
Its not just for few days but since last year december that the mempool is roller coaster I manage to customized my fee once  and confirmed faster and the next time i tried it stocked up to 5 days same sats/vByte that i used , We don't know till when this will run because we have had this in the past but not as long as we are experiencing now , even the free acceleration from viaBtc is been abused by Bot that we cannot use their free service as its always slots full
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on January 16, 2024, 04:51:59 PM
I think you are correct. I will fix that! Coinbase have 0 sat/vbyte fees
Did you make any changes? It doesn't appear for me.

(https://bitcoindata.science/bot/chart.php)

Code: [Select]
[img]https://bitcoindata.science/bot/chart.php[/img]
I did not imagine that we would see a minimum fee of 23 satoshi, so the situation began to improve from mid-November.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on January 16, 2024, 05:18:02 PM
Did you make any changes? It doesn't appear for me.

The tool is designed so that the image always shows the current fee. The moment you reloaded the page or post where it was shared, regardless of when it was posted. Also, you don't need to use the "code" tag.
So for example, this (posted without a code tag)

Code: [Select]
[img height=150]https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php[/img]
will show like this (you will see that the same values are here and in the first bitmover's post)

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php)

I suggest you visit https://bitcoindata.science for more info
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 16, 2024, 07:14:09 PM
Did you make any changes? It doesn't appear for me.

The tool is designed so that the image always shows the current fee. The moment you reloaded the page or post where it was shared, regardless of when it was posted. Also, you don't need to use the "code" tag.
So for example, this (posted without a code tag)

Code: [Select]
[img height=150]https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php[/img]
will show like this (you will see that the same values are here and in the first bitmover's post)

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php)

I suggest you visit https://bitcoindata.science for more info

I made some changes in the chart, as you suggested @examplens. Now I added my domain name, I will also add the dates in the x axis soon.

You can check in the OP
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on January 16, 2024, 11:01:35 PM
I made some changes in the chart, as you suggested @examplens. Now I added my domain name, I will also add the dates in the x axis soon.

You can check in the OP

I saw the changes, it's a good direction.
It might be useful to have one horizontal line that will mark the entire length of the chart, for example, 40 sat/vb. Somehow we all agreed that the 40 sat/vb fee is acceptable as usable. It would be easier to follow because a little while ago there was a short jump to 360, which significantly affects the appearance of the chart.

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Litzki1990 on January 17, 2024, 06:08:11 AM
The sat/vB was limited to 30 to 40 for a while but today when I monitor Mempool the sat/vB minimum is showing above 60.  For some time now it has been well observed that Mempool is fluctuating between 30 and 40 but Mempool is above 60 and may increase further in next few hours from now. Minimum sat/vB if bitcoin transfer now still costs 5 to 6 dollars in transaction fee.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 17, 2024, 10:27:50 AM
Somehow we all agreed that the 40 sat/vb fee is acceptable as usable. It would be easier to follow because a little while ago there was a short jump to 360, which significantly affects the appearance of the chart.

2 months ago I would  never send a transaction for 40 sat/vB. I would pay at most 10.

Things changed... I hope fees will go back to normal...
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: God Of Thunder on January 17, 2024, 03:20:50 PM
Oh, Thanks bitmover. I thought you didn't create such a thread here and I was saying this on another thread where stompix informed me that you have created this thread already. I guess the idea of Feebuddy won't work there. What do you think about it? We have been expecting a telegram bot like TryNinja's super notifier bot, but we haven't seen anything like that yet.

I guess I have seen a discussion somewhere and someone was trying to create a bot. Was it you or examplens? I don't remember exactly. But, It would be great if someone can manage create a teegram bot.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 17, 2024, 04:12:08 PM
Oh, Thanks bitmover. I thought you didn't create such a thread here and I was saying this on another thread where stompix informed me that you have created this thread already. I guess the idea of Feebuddy won't work there. What do you think about it? We have been expecting a telegram bot like TryNinja's super notifier bot, but we haven't seen anything like that yet.

I guess I have seen a discussion somewhere and someone was trying to create a bot. Was it you or examplens? I don't remember exactly. But, It would be great if someone can manage create a teegram bot.

I was trying to create it, however I was not able to login into this forum using a bot (it is much easier in bitcointalk)

I will try again later on.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: CryptoLaila on January 17, 2024, 05:50:26 PM


2 months ago I would  never send a transaction for 40 sat/vB. I would pay at most 10.

Things changed... I hope fees will go back to normal...

So you trading  it now  ??? because  it even more,  the mempool keeps getting more congested day by day and the fee kept rising because  they just want it done :P. Currently, what's  Average fee you're  paying/vB
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Don Pedro Dinero on January 17, 2024, 07:15:09 PM
So you trading  it now  ??? because  it even more,  the mempool keeps getting more congested day by day and the fee kept rising because  they just want it done :P. Currently, what's  Average fee you're  paying/vB

I can tell you didn't follow the mempool before saying that. The mempool is in constant ups and downs lately, and just as three days ago there was a spike and fees went up to 200 sats/vByte they are now at more reasonable rates of around 50 sats/vByte. In fact, it has been having these ups and downs for some time now. I illustrate this with an image of unconfirmed transactions from mempool.observer:


(https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/01/17/34snP.png)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 17, 2024, 07:56:33 PM
So you trading  it now  ??? because  it even more,  the mempool keeps getting more congested day by day and the fee kept rising because  they just want it done :P. Currently, what's  Average fee you're  paying/vB

I can tell you didn't follow the mempool before saying that. The mempool is in constant ups and downs lately, and just as three days ago there was a spike and fees went up to 200 sats/vByte they are now at more reasonable rates of around 50 sats/vByte. In fact, it has been having these ups and downs for some time now. I illustrate this with an image of unconfirmed transactions from mempool.observer:

You are right Don Pedro Dinero.

I even made this chart which is always updated, showing the average 50% cheapest fees in each block for the past 3 days. You can see that there are some spikes, and a very strong resistance in 30 sat/vB

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/chart.php)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: CryptoLaila on January 17, 2024, 08:19:12 PM
Quote

I can tell you didn't follow the mempool before saying that. The mempool is in constant ups and downs lately, and just as three days ago there was a spike and fees went up to 200 sats/vByte they are now at more reasonable rates of around 50 sats/vByte. In fact, it has been having these ups and downs for some time now. I illustrate this with an image of unconfirmed transactions from mempool.observer:

Yeah I didn't  lol :D
All I know is the fee is in an high state even if not stable but I get your point...
I did checked last 4  days and it was around 163> and thanks for the graph
I am just curious about what he/she glued with as fee (@bitmover) .
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: God Of Thunder on January 18, 2024, 03:26:42 PM
---

Do you remember that our beloved LoyceV has a thread named Mempool is empty, consolidate your tx or something like that. I guess that thread has no purpose at this moment. LOL. I hope I will get a notification one day that LoyceV posted again, and it's time to consolidate our TXs again! Ahhhhh

Good old days! I hope we will get back to these days again. Bitcoin developers should look for a solution now. Either do something to exclude the ordinals things, or increase the blocksize. I don't know which one is better, but we can't survive like that.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Don Pedro Dinero on January 18, 2024, 03:58:04 PM
Do you remember that our beloved LoyceV has a thread named Mempool is empty, consolidate your tx or something like that. I guess that thread has no purpose at this moment. LOL. I hope I will get a notification one day that LoyceV posted again, and it's time to consolidate our TXs again! Ahhhhh

In general, no, it is not a good time to consolidate, especially compared to a year ago when you could do it for the minimum rate with fast confirmations. I remember doing a trade at the weekend at 1 sat/vByte and it was confirmed in the next block. It will be a long time before we see that again.

But if next weekend, for example, the rates drop to around 30 sats or less, depending on the inputs you have and how big they are, you might want to consolidate. It's kind of a gamble too because if you expect the fees to stay fairly high you can't wait for them to go down to the minimum rate, because it may take months, years or even never go back down to that level.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Uruhara on January 18, 2024, 05:03:17 PM
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php)

I used to think 20 sats/vB was expensive. But now I see 40 sats/vB is cheap. Because now we've kept seeing costs keep circling between 40 to 200.

I hope things return to normal and I miss transactions with fees of 6 to 10sats/vB. Now I'm even starting to doubt that we'll ever see such cheap costs again. :'(
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Gurujebs on January 18, 2024, 05:15:46 PM
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php)

I used to think 20 sats/vB was expensive. But now I see 40 sats/vB is cheap. Because now we've kept seeing costs keep circling between 40 to 200.

I get discouraged about transaction when I see high sats needed to get transactions included in the next block because to me, it's like we are spoiling miners. ;D I get it that they need to be compensated for the security level of bitcoin they are maintaining but if they continue like this, they will be the one having all the bitcoin.

Quote
I hope things return to normal and I miss transactions with fees of 6 to 10sats/vB. Now I'm even starting to doubt that we'll ever see such cheap costs again. :'(

I don't think such will return soon. We have halving coming up and not like Ordinals are cooling off or disappearing from the protocol now. I'm very sure that if the halving is approaching, we will have more of them influence by some miners to increase their profits, that I'm very sure of and what they are going to do to increased their revenues.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: yhiaali3 on January 18, 2024, 06:00:43 PM
Thanks bitmover, great job again, I used to use your wonderful tool in the Bitcoin Talk forum and added it to my favorites so I can use it when needed.

A really useful tool since Bitcoin fees are constantly changing and everyone is looking for the right opportunity to send with the cheapest fees.

How happy I am to see fees reduced again, even though they are still high compared to fees a few months ago, but it would be very good if they remained constant at this rate. I expect that this would be satisfactory for both users and miners.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 18, 2024, 06:43:30 PM
How happy I am to see fees reduced again, even though they are still high compared to fees a few months ago, but it would be very good if they remained constant at this rate. I expect that this would be satisfactory for both users and miners.

THe current fee rate is too high! It will cost about 3-4 USD to send each input (not the overall transaction).

So if you received 30 usd per week in a campaign, to send 100 you would need to spend about 9 usd which is quite high
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Uruhara on January 19, 2024, 03:09:16 AM
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php)

I used to think 20 sats/vB was expensive. But now I see 40 sats/vB is cheap. Because now we've kept seeing costs keep circling between 40 to 200.

I get discouraged about transaction when I see high sats needed to get transactions included in the next block because to me, it's like we are spoiling miners. ;D I get it that they need to be compensated for the security level of bitcoin they are maintaining but if they continue like this, they will be the one having all the bitcoin.
Last year, I actually still had no problem with the fee increases that continued to occur. Because last year there was a free Accelerator of 100 tx every hour from ViaBTC. But now I can no longer use the accelerator because the free slots have been reduced to 20 tx per hour and even then they always run out in a few seconds. Maybe by bots or maybe because many people use it.
I hope things return to normal and I miss transactions with fees of 6 to 10sats/vB. Now I'm even starting to doubt that we'll ever see such cheap costs again. :'(

I don't think such will return soon. We have halving coming up and not like Ordinals are cooling off or disappearing from the protocol now. I'm very sure that if the halving is approaching, we will have more of them influence by some miners to increase their profits, that I'm very sure of and what they are going to do to increased their revenues.
yeah I think you are right. Because up to now, the number of people using Brc-20 doesn't seem to have decreased much. But instead it continues to grow. Moreover, many Cex have registered trading in coins from the BRC20 network.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dwyane36 on January 19, 2024, 08:02:11 AM
Last year, I actually still had no problem with the fee increases that continued to occur. Because last year there was a free Accelerator of 100 tx every hour from ViaBTC. But now I can no longer use the accelerator because the free slots have been reduced to 20 tx per hour and even then they always run out in a few seconds. Maybe by bots or maybe because many people use it.

Yes, the ViaBTC accelerator is a useful site, especially when transaction fees on the BTC network become insanely expensive. As far as I know, this site reduced the hourly limit because of the influx of bots, and the problem is that it only made the situation worse because now it is completely unrealistic for regular users to use this service. Now, bots literally empty the current limit in a fraction of a second, and it is clear that an ordinary user won't be able to press the button and pass the captcha in such a short time.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 19, 2024, 01:17:27 PM
THe current fee rate is too high! It will cost about 3-4 USD to send each input (not the overall transaction).

So if you received 30 usd per week in a campaign, to send 100 you would need to spend about 9 usd which is quite high
My solution for this issue is for campaign managers to adopt Liquid Network wallets (Aqua, Jade, Green wallet, ledger) and pay participants with L-BTC.
Each of them can swap L-BTC to BTC when on-chain fees are lower or when they need them, and they can easily swap it for L-USDT if they want.
In this way there won't be the need for consolidation, and transaction fees will be much lower for everyone.


Maybe you can include additional fees in your bitcoindata mempool observer for Liquid network and L-BTC:
https://liquid.network/ (https://liquid.network/)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: ABCbits on January 19, 2024, 01:30:53 PM
Maybe you can include additional fees in your bitcoindata mempool observer for Liquid network and L-BTC:
https://liquid.network/ (https://liquid.network/)

If the goal is to promote Liquid, that's fine. But otherwise i don't think it's very useful since that website shows most blocks is almost empty. It means people could just set 0.1 sat/vB (which is minimum fee rate[1]). Although as reminder Liquid use Confidential Transaction which leads to bigger transaction size[2].

[1] https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001386846 (https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001386846)
[2] https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001390903-What-is-the-transaction-capacity-of-Liquid- (https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001390903-What-is-the-transaction-capacity-of-Liquid-)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 19, 2024, 02:20:03 PM
If the goal is to promote Liquid, that's fine. But otherwise i don't think it's very useful since that website shows most blocks is almost empty. It means people could just set 0.1 sat/vB (which is minimum fee rate[1]). Although as reminder Liquid use Confidential Transaction which leads to bigger transaction size[2].
Goal is to show difference compared to main chain Bitcoin, and why it could be a good idea to use Liquid L-BTC for frequent campaign campaign payments.
Number of transactions is slowly increasing on Liquid so fees will change in future and it would be nice to follow USD value estimates.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: yhiaali3 on January 20, 2024, 02:43:59 AM
THe current fee rate is too high! It will cost about 3-4 USD to send each input (not the overall transaction).

So if you received 30 usd per week in a campaign, to send 100 you would need to spend about 9 usd which is quite high
You are right, for small amounts, the fees are still high, such as for campaigns in the forum. If you want to send the payment every week, it will cost you a fee of about $9 per month, as you mentioned, so I will not send it every week, but rather I will send it once a month to reduce the fees.

But I said that it is good due to the high rate of fees that we have seen over the past months, as fees sometimes reached $15-20, so compared to these high fees, the current fees are considered good, but of course we hope that they will continue to decline until they return to their previous level of 10-15 sat.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Uruhara on January 20, 2024, 10:33:31 AM
Last year, I actually still had no problem with the fee increases that continued to occur. Because last year there was a free Accelerator of 100 tx every hour from ViaBTC. But now I can no longer use the accelerator because the free slots have been reduced to 20 tx per hour and even then they always run out in a few seconds. Maybe by bots or maybe because many people use it.

Yes, the ViaBTC accelerator is a useful site, especially when transaction fees on the BTC network become insanely expensive. As far as I know, this site reduced the hourly limit because of the influx of bots, and the problem is that it only made the situation worse because now it is completely unrealistic for regular users to use this service. Now, bots literally empty the current limit in a fraction of a second, and it is clear that an ordinary user won't be able to press the button and pass the captcha in such a short time.
yeah, that's right, friend. Now I've even given up on using the free acceleration from ViaBTC. Because it is no longer possible to compete with bots which are always faster than us who only input manually.

Luckily now the fees are starting to get lower again within a few days. But I'm not sure it will last long.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/01/20/3xT41.png)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: famososMuertos on January 20, 2024, 11:59:06 PM
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php)

I used to think 20 sats/vB was expensive. But now I see 40 sats/vB is cheap. Because now we've kept seeing costs keep circling between 40 to 200.

I hope things return to normal and I miss transactions with fees of 6 to 10sats/vB. Now I'm even starting to doubt that we'll ever see such cheap costs again. :'(

While it is true, we all want 1sat/vB even if we do not use it, but you cannot always expect the rates to adapt to your possible TXs, adapt your amounts to the real situation.

Consequently! Send in time and avoid emergencies.

If you send $300 a fee of $3 is quite acceptable, within the limits of 1%-5%, which could be considered acceptable.

On the other hand, awareness is using the correct fee, which corresponds, if the highest priority is $10, understanding that putting $20 is not correct.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Baofeng on January 21, 2024, 09:29:10 AM
Last year, I actually still had no problem with the fee increases that continued to occur. Because last year there was a free Accelerator of 100 tx every hour from ViaBTC. But now I can no longer use the accelerator because the free slots have been reduced to 20 tx per hour and even then they always run out in a few seconds. Maybe by bots or maybe because many people use it.

Yes, the ViaBTC accelerator is a useful site, especially when transaction fees on the BTC network become insanely expensive. As far as I know, this site reduced the hourly limit because of the influx of bots, and the problem is that it only made the situation worse because now it is completely unrealistic for regular users to use this service. Now, bots literally empty the current limit in a fraction of a second, and it is clear that an ordinary user won't be able to press the button and pass the captcha in such a short time.
yeah, that's right, friend. Now I've even given up on using the free acceleration from ViaBTC. Because it is no longer possible to compete with bots which are always faster than us who only input manually.

Luckily now the fees are starting to get lower again within a few days. But I'm not sure it will last long.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/01/20/3xT41.png)

It started to go up at least 47 sat/vB currently from the 30's that we have seen in the last 12 hours or so. And just like the price, it a continuous up and down. Maybe there are time frame that there are no activity whatsoever that's why the transaction fee is down.

And then active hours means fees are bumping up. I do hope that we can see 1 sat/vB, but I doubt it though. The ordinals are going to continue and so mempool will be clogged from time to time.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 22, 2024, 04:55:12 AM
If you send $300 a fee of $3 is quite acceptable, within the limits of 1%-5%, which could be considered acceptable.
The problem is that right now each UTXO will cost about 3$ to send, which is quite high.

For example, we receive less than $50 in signature campaigns. We would need at least 6-10 inputs to make a transaction of 300 now, which would cost about 12-30 usd
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Uruhara on January 22, 2024, 05:12:30 AM
yeah, that's right, friend. Now I've even given up on using the free acceleration from ViaBTC. Because it is no longer possible to compete with bots which are always faster than us who only input manually.

Luckily now the fees are starting to get lower again within a few days. But I'm not sure it will last long.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/01/20/3xT41.png)

It started to go up at least 47 sat/vB currently from the 30's that we have seen in the last 12 hours or so. And just like the price, it a continuous up and down. Maybe there are time frame that there are no activity whatsoever that's why the transaction fee is down.

And then active hours means fees are bumping up. I do hope that we can see 1 sat/vB, but I doubt it though. The ordinals are going to continue and so mempool will be clogged from time to time.
Well transaction fees keep fluctuating. And yes, it all depends on transaction density at certain hours. So now we have to start to understand at what times transaction density decreases accompanied by a decrease in transaction costs. So checking the mempool in real time can also help. And yes, topics like this can also help by notifying each other when fees start to fall.

For now the fee will at least not increase to 100sats again. But it continues to rotate in the 70 to 32 area.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/01/22/kAlrI.png)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 22, 2024, 12:30:59 PM
The problem is that right now each UTXO will cost about 3$ to send, which is quite high.

For example, we receive less than $50 in signature campaigns. We would need at least 6-10 inputs to make a transaction of 300 now, which would cost about 12-30 usd
Did you read what I wrote before about L-BTC as alternative?
This would easily fix that issue and it would be even better for smaller transactions like tips/donations and it would give better privacy.
I would like to see this added to bitcoindata.science if possible :)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 22, 2024, 02:04:13 PM
The problem is that right now each UTXO will cost about 3$ to send, which is quite high.

For example, we receive less than $50 in signature campaigns. We would need at least 6-10 inputs to make a transaction of 300 now, which would cost about 12-30 usd
Did you read what I wrote before about L-BTC as alternative?
This would easily fix that issue and it would be even better for smaller transactions like tips/donations and it would give better privacy.

This is interesting.

But how to convert L-BTC to BTC? AFAIK, only Aqua wallet do that.

I have been using Monero and LTC when possible for now, but those coins usually have a worst performance compared to BTC price. I am using exch.cx to convert them.

L-BTC could be an alternative.

Quote
I would like to see this added to bitcoindata.science if possible :)

In the donation page or in the API?

Fees are basically 0 sat/vbyte in all blocks lol
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: ABCbits on January 23, 2024, 10:30:06 AM
But how to convert L-BTC to BTC? AFAIK, only Aqua wallet do that.

You also can use exchange, although it's not practical if you deal with small amount of L-BTC due to BTC withdraw fees.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: MVL~$ on January 23, 2024, 10:37:17 AM
Just like in bitcointalk, I created this thread so we can observe the mempool.

This images always show the mempool in realtime:

Recommended fees:

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)
Code: [Select]
[img height=150]https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php[/img]
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/chart.php) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)

Code: [Select]
[img]https://bitcoindata.science/api/chart.php[/img]
Anyone can use those images, just use the codes above. Data  is always updated.
I personally really like this tool a lot. Through this you can easily understand about the gas fee of Bitcoin. For which you don't have to spend much. You can see the data nicely with horizontal lines there if you want.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 24, 2024, 12:17:11 PM
But how to convert L-BTC to BTC? AFAIK, only Aqua wallet do that.

You also can use exchange, although it's not practical if you deal with small amount of L-BTC due to BTC withdraw fees.

And which exchange is that?

I just looked at coinmarketcap.com  and found d nothing

https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/liquid-network/

I discovered a list of exchanges here
Only small ones
https://liquid.net/

Best to do is to swap to usdt using aqua
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 24, 2024, 12:56:26 PM
But how to convert L-BTC to BTC? AFAIK, only Aqua wallet do that.[/size]
[/size]
Aqua wallet already have integrated SideSwap for that, but you can also use it separately.
Another decentralized p2p exchange you can use is TDEX app, and I heard that other exchanges will come soon.
https://sideswap.io
https://tdex.network

Fees are basically 0 sat/vbyte in all blocks lol
[/size]
Yeah, that is the point  8)  but it will increase in future.


And which exchange is that?

I just looked at coinmarketcap.com  and found d nothing

https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/liquid-network/ (https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/liquid-network/)

I discovered a list of exchanges here
Only small ones
https://liquid.net/ (https://liquid.net/)

Best to do is to swap to usdt using aqua
[/size]
Bitfinex is part of the Liquid Network so I am sure they will add full support soon, others will follow.
But I much more prefer to use decentralized exchanges.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Litzki1990 on January 25, 2024, 04:04:43 AM
Today mempool is showing normal, minimum 28, medium 29 and maximum 33. At the time I'm writing this post, if someone wants to transfer bitcoins, they may have to pay a transaction fee of $3 to a maximum of $5 per transfer. To catch it is normal compared to other times, other times normally we used to use 70 to 80 mempool to transfer bitcoins now it is between 28 to 30.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on January 25, 2024, 05:33:53 AM
Just like in bitcointalk, I created this thread so we can observe the mempool.

This images always show the mempool in realtime:

Recommended fees:

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)
Code: [Select]
[img height=150]https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php[/img]
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/chart.php) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)

Code: [Select]
[img]https://bitcoindata.science/api/chart.php[/img]
Anyone can use those images, just use the codes above. Data  is always updated.
Nice work like it here and there.

I am thinking price of fees backed off for four reasons.

ETF sell off.
Ordinals reduced.
Btc price dropped
Large Texas mines got back on line. Power was diverted from mines when it was cold in Texas.

This has lifted the difficulty rate and blocks are mined faster right now than last week.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: ABCbits on January 25, 2024, 10:15:39 AM
But how to convert L-BTC to BTC? AFAIK, only Aqua wallet do that.

You also can use exchange, although it's not practical if you deal with small amount of L-BTC due to BTC withdraw fees.

And which exchange is that?

I just looked at coinmarketcap.com  and found d nothing

https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/liquid-network/

I discovered a list of exchanges here
Only small ones
https://liquid.net/

Best to do is to swap to usdt using aqua

Check this Blockstream help guide, https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001387106 (https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001387106). But that guide is outdated since few website i checked doesn't show L-BTC as trade/exchange option.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on January 25, 2024, 01:37:47 PM
I am thinking price of fees backed off for four reasons.

ETF sell off.
Ordinals reduced.
Btc price dropped
Large Texas mines got back on line. Power was diverted from mines when it was cold in Texas.

This has lifted the difficulty rate and blocks are mined faster right now than last week.

I don't think the ETF affects the fee, at least not directly. Because they mostly hold Bitcoin, they do not make transactions on the blockchain.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on January 25, 2024, 04:44:10 PM
But how to convert L-BTC to BTC? AFAIK, only Aqua wallet do that.

You also can use exchange, although it's not practical if you deal with small amount of L-BTC due to BTC withdraw fees.



And which exchange is that?

I just looked at coinmarketcap.com  and found d nothing

https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/liquid-network/

I discovered a list of exchanges here
Only small ones
https://liquid.net/

Best to do is to swap to usdt using aqua

Check this Blockstream help guide, https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001387106 (https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001387106). But that guide is outdated since few website i checked doesn't show L-BTC as trade/exchange option.
okay reading it now.  I will add to this post in a few minutes

After checking it a bit I would not do L-BTC

If I want to do small btc moves I would do kyc with kraken because kraken will allow me access to its LN wallet.

I would put in $500 usd to kraken
I would buy $100 usd in BTC monthly on kraken
If I need to do small payments of btc I would use kraken LN wallet.

This is a chump change solution with under $500 usd at risk at all times.

I would still have a wallet with my major amount of coin offline

I am well aware that the $500 on kraken is at risk
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 25, 2024, 10:34:53 PM
I would put in $500 usd to kraken
I would buy $100 usd in BTC monthly on kraken
If I need to do small payments of btc I would use kraken LN wallet.

This is a chump change solution with under $500 usd at risk at all times.

I would still have a wallet with my major amount of coin offline

I am well aware that the $500 on kraken is at risk

You can do that in binance as well.

However,  I think l-btc might be a better solution

You can swap L-BTC to bitcoin or USDT using aqua wallet. I think it is safer to hold L-BTC in aqua than to hold btc in binance
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: ABCbits on January 26, 2024, 09:43:30 AM
Check this Blockstream help guide, https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001387106 (https://help.blockstream.com/hc/en-us/articles/900001387106). But that guide is outdated since few website i checked doesn't show L-BTC as trade/exchange option.
okay reading it now.  I will add to this post in a few minutes

After checking it a bit I would not do L-BTC

If I want to do small btc moves I would do kyc with kraken because kraken will allow me access to its LN wallet.

I would put in $500 usd to kraken
I would buy $100 usd in BTC monthly on kraken
If I need to do small payments of btc I would use kraken LN wallet.

This is a chump change solution with under $500 usd at risk at all times.

I would still have a wallet with my major amount of coin offline

I am well aware that the $500 on kraken is at risk

Yeah, L-BTC lost it's advantage when you don't mind take some risk and pay on-chain TX fee to open new LN channel. But it wouldnt hurt to know more options.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: 0t3p0t on January 26, 2024, 04:45:12 PM
Today mempool is showing normal, minimum 28, medium 29 and maximum 33. At the time I'm writing this post, if someone wants to transfer bitcoins, they may have to pay a transaction fee of $3 to a maximum of $5 per transfer. To catch it is normal compared to other times, other times normally we used to use 70 to 80 mempool to transfer bitcoins now it is between 28 to 30.
It is now at 23 sats/vB for 66 minutes and I missed this lowest priority for my 35 sats/vB transaction that has been cancelled. Patience really is a virtue and I am not having it as all I thought was that fees will keep on going up. 😅
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 26, 2024, 05:10:00 PM
However,  I think l-btc might be a better solution

You can swap L-BTC to bitcoin or USDT using aqua wallet. I think it is safer to hold L-BTC in aqua than to hold btc in binance
It is better in some cases, but better check out rates in TDEX app, they could be offering lower fees sometimes than directly in Aqua wallet, for larger amounts when swapping from BTC to L-BTC.

I am not supporting centralized exchanges in any way, but some of them support Liquid network now, like Bitfinex (no withraw fee for L-BTC), BTSE, BTCTurk, etc.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 27, 2024, 01:24:24 PM

It is better in some cases, but better check out rates in TDEX app, they could be offering lower fees sometimes than directly in Aqua wallet, for larger amounts when swapping from BTC to L-BTC.

I am not supporting centralized exchanges in any way, but some of them support Liquid network now, like Bitfinex (no withraw fee for L-BTC), BTSE, BTCTurk, etc.

Tdex and exch.cx are also centralized. They are just able to bypass regulations for now. Like shapeshif, changelly and other services in the past..

I like those swap services and I have always used them. They come and go, if they Stay for too long in the market they end up demanding kyc...

I will try tdex for sure. I have to exchange some XMR I have to L-BTC
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 30, 2024, 12:09:03 AM
Tdex and exch.cx are also centralized. They are just able to bypass regulations for now. Like shapeshif, changelly and other services in the past..
I think that TDEX aka TrueDEX is p2p decentralized exchange, unlike other exchanges you mentioned ;)
There are some limitations and it's not one solution for everything, but this could be used as one of the tools with Liquid network.
https://tdex.network/
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 03, 2024, 08:33:10 PM
Common guys, wake up!!!!
We hit again 500sat/b!
You see , this happens when you don't have a fee buddy to keep things up to date! ;D

We're back at 10$ for next block, although , that is as always misleading because if you happen to nee two inputs, well, you're going to pay with something else.

(https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/03/vAOXP.png)

Now, imagine you're face to face with the guy that paid 5000sat/vb...what are you going to say? Or do?



Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Don Pedro Dinero on February 04, 2024, 10:37:15 AM
Common guys, wake up!!!!
We hit again 500sat/b!
You see , this happens when you don't have a fee buddy to keep things up to date! ;D

We're back at 10$ for next block, although , that is as always misleading because if you happen to nee two inputs, well, you're going to pay with something else.

Well, yesterday's storm was short-lived and the sun has come out again: currently 24 sats/vB are enough for a quick confirmation. There seems to be a downward trend in unconfirmed mempool transactions, with exceptions such as yesterday. In the last 7 days there has been a clear decline. Let's hope it continues.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: famososMuertos on February 04, 2024, 02:54:18 PM
The days to Txs by gross less than $2, etc. It ended a long time ago and not to mention the "famous" 1sat/vB, the fee is a percentage, placed in the range 1-3%, low priority, and HP: 4%,5% of the amount. If it doesn't work for you, there are other options, waiting is one, and/or Atls.

Saying that $10-$20 is a lot doesn't make sense if you send $1000 and it's stupid to pay a $10-$20 fee when the mempool tells you that the priority is 1sat/vB.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 04, 2024, 03:45:21 PM
Saying that $10-$20 is a lot doesn't make sense if you send $1000 is 1sat/vB.

It's still a lot if you compare it to 5 cents or for free as some others methods are able to do it.
Besides most of the people wouldn't want to send $1000 every time as the majority of crypto wonder don't even have that amount ready.
Common let's not turn Bitcoin into some elitist payment gateway where it's cheap for millionaire to transfer a billion for 0.0..1 of the sum while a guy can't get his signature campaign payment without a 20% cut.

Let's hope it continues.

No chance!
First it was the weekend, then we had a 7% adjustment so 10 extra blocks per day for 13 days, and since Saturday we're looking at 20 extra blocks per day, so in the last weeks we had around 200vMB of extra space available for confirmation, now way this is going to repeat itself!

It will go down a bit but not with the same pace, plus once it hits under 20sat/vb expect a ton of incoming tx as there are thousands that start sending them again after being purged from most mempools. Plus a ton of consolidations from large exchnges, OKex has 7000 unconfirmed inputs in one wallet for example.

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: rdluffy on February 04, 2024, 11:19:06 PM
Several times I've had the opportunity to consolidate my wallet for less than 5sat/b and I didn't do it
I waited too long thinking it would take too long for the rates to increase that much
Today I need to consolidate and I don't want to spend more than 20 dollars hehehe
The good thing about this is that we're in forced HODL hehehe
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Papusha20 on February 05, 2024, 03:10:22 AM
Several times I've had the opportunity to consolidate my wallet for less than 5sat/b and I didn't do it
I waited too long thinking it would take too long for the rates to increase that much
Today I need to consolidate and I don't want to spend more than 20 dollars hehehe
The good thing about this is that we're in forced HODL hehehe

(https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/05/vGDCH.jpeg)

High Transfer Fee
By the end of December 2023, Bitcoin's transaction fees had increased so much that I could never have imagined.  I was surprised to see this huge transaction fee and canceled the transaction.
372sat/B --- 443sat/B
  21.54$ Fee - 25.65$ Transfer Fee..




Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bayu7adi on February 05, 2024, 05:12:35 AM
(https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/05/vGDCH.jpeg)

High Transfer Fee
By the end of December 2023, Bitcoin's transaction fees had increased so much that I could never have imagined.  I was surprised to see this huge transaction fee and canceled the transaction.
372sat/B --- 443sat/B
  21.54$ Fee - 25.65$ Transfer Fee..
Yeah... but now it's February, and the fees aren't as high anymore. The times when fees were sky-high are over, and we're no longer forced to HODL. The congestion has eased, and this is good news for all of us because we can transfer Bitcoin to other wallets quickly and more affordably.

In the last few days, a transaction fee of 24 sat/vB seems reasonable to use. I'm confident that a fee of 10 sat/vB will soon be achievable in the coming months.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Don Pedro Dinero on February 05, 2024, 05:35:11 AM
It will go down a bit but not with the same pace, plus once it hits under 20sat/vb expect a ton of incoming tx as there are thousands that start sending them again after being purged from most mempools.

I have a transaction that I sent about a week ago, just at 19 sats/vB and it hasn't been purged, do you have any idea why? I thought there had been a purge of transactions below 20.

Several times I've had the opportunity to consolidate my wallet for less than 5sat/b and I didn't do it
I waited too long thinking it would take too long for the rates to increase that much
Today I need to consolidate and I don't want to spend more than 20 dollars hehehe
The good thing about this is that we're in forced HODL hehehe

When the mempool was empty I took the opportunity to consolidate with the minimum fee several times. Txs were confirmed quite quickly, but it seems that we will either not see that again or it will take a long time.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 05, 2024, 09:46:02 AM
I have a transaction that I sent about a week ago, just at 19 sats/vB and it hasn't been purged, do you have any idea why? I thought there had been a purge of transactions below 20.

Non standard node.
Most nodes are indeed limited to 300MB, even some miners keep a low node because it has no practical purpose for them, but others have a higher limit, mine (home) is pushed to 2000 and for sure the node that relayed your tx first was a non-default mempool node.

If you use a wallet like electrum you can test them by trying to broadcast a tx via a certain server with 1sat/vb.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 05, 2024, 04:26:11 PM
Common guys, wake up!!!!
We hit again 500sat/b!
You see , this happens when you don't have a fee buddy to keep things up to date! ;D

We're back at 10$ for next block, although , that is as always misleading because if you happen to nee two inputs, well, you're going to pay with something else.


This was just a spike. In a few minutes fees were normal again.

Take a look at the mempool chart. Probably someone trying to artificially increase fees?
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/02/05/vmtMP.gif) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Aanuoluwatofunmi on February 05, 2024, 04:36:17 PM
Several times I've had the opportunity to consolidate my wallet for less than 5sat/b and I didn't do it
I waited too long thinking it would take too long for the rates to increase that much
Today I need to consolidate and I don't want to spend more than 20 dollars hehehe
The good thing about this is that we're in forced HODL hehehe

(https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/05/vGDCH.jpeg)

High Transfer Fee
By the end of December 2023, Bitcoin's transaction fees had increased so much that I could never have imagined.  I was surprised to see this huge transaction fee and canceled the transaction.
372sat/B --- 443sat/B
  21.54$ Fee - 25.65$ Transfer Fee..

Maybe we should try and engage another alternative to paying lesser by using static and then considering the purging fee for making transaction and you pay a little bit more higher than that,then engage the use of the transaction accelerator service like viabtc for easy and speedy transaction, I think that will be more lesser to paying the direct fee rate from the mempool order of priority, what do you think guys concerning this, I way out or make no difference.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: famososMuertos on February 05, 2024, 06:24:08 PM
Several times I've had the opportunity to consolidate my wallet for less than 5sat/b and I didn't do it
I waited too long thinking it would take too long for the rates to increase that much
Today I need to consolidate and I don't want to spend more than 20 dollars hehehe
The good thing about this is that we're in forced HODL hehehe

Last year I mentioned in reference to the classic 1sat/vB in which it is "stipulated" to consolidate, that the new value was 100sat/vB, (sarcasm), which in reality is, but an emergency for those who need it given the values seen in the mempool, It could work. :)

I think that Hodl is ok, but also it helps to maintain privacy.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: NikeFit_7777 on February 06, 2024, 11:06:30 AM
Yeah... but now it's February, and the fees aren't as high anymore. The times when fees were sky-high are over, and we're no longer forced to HODL. The congestion has eased, and this is good news for all of us because we can transfer Bitcoin to other wallets quickly and more affordably.

In the last few days, a transaction fee of 24 sat/vB seems reasonable to use. I'm confident that a fee of 10 sat/vB will soon be achievable in the coming months.
It seems to me, on the contrary, that transfer prices are going to go up. Although, if you look at the ETH network - and what was the fee for 1 transfer (from 15$ to 45$) it was really expensive. Maybe if the btc rate drops a bit (+ there will be less demand) from users = we will see a decrease in the transfer price.

Below, in the photo, you can see the stats: Transaction volume on BTC network, hits highest since September 2022 - The Block

(https://i.ibb.co/0hZkxZc/photo-2024-02-05-14-13-55.jpg)

+ Extras if you use a translator, you can read my article about "how much American miners consume" : https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=316886.msg1489190#msg1489190
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitterguy28 on February 06, 2024, 01:12:49 PM
Several times I've had the opportunity to consolidate my wallet for less than 5sat/b and I didn't do it
I waited too long thinking it would take too long for the rates to increase that much
Today I need to consolidate and I don't want to spend more than 20 dollars hehehe
The good thing about this is that we're in forced HODL hehehe
Well we have so a little decrease in fees as I have send 200 dollars earlier ? having 5 dollars fee so for me this is considerable amount to pay.
Hodling must not be forced mate , we are here in our own desire and dedication so try not to become greed and stupid.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 07, 2024, 05:34:50 PM
It seems to me, on the contrary, that transfer prices are going to go up.
Below, in the photo, you can see the stats: Transaction volume on BTC network, hits highest since September 2022 - The Block

(https://i.ibb.co/0hZkxZc/photo-2024-02-05-14-13-55.jpg)

Volume has no real connection to the average fee.
In fact volume can be really misleading in certain days because of what big players can do, for example: Binance can chose to move a part of it's hot wallet to the cold wallet and here you go, one small 170vbyte tx is worth 4 000 BTC.
Same for consolidations and mixing, if somebody decided to mix 10 BTC, then you have 10 from user to mixer, 10 btc from mixer to tumbler, 10 btc in coinjoin, 10 btc from coinjoin to mixer controlled addresses, 10 btc from mixer to user. And voila somebody cleaning 10 BTC has made an on chain volume of 50 BTC by effectively doing...not so much economic activity.

This is a better indicator for the fees:
https://mempool.space/graphs/mining/block-fee-rates#3d
And only click on min excluding the others, but when you use longer periods it becomes messy and it stops showing the gaps, it's good for 24 and 3 days still.
[img heigth=200]https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/07/vsSAJ.png[/img]
or use this:
https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-median_transaction_fee.html#3m


Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Hamza2424 on February 07, 2024, 05:48:28 PM
High Transfer Fee
By the end of December 2023, Bitcoin's transaction fees had increased so much that I could never have imagined.  I was surprised to see this huge transaction fee and canceled the transaction.
372sat/B --- 443sat/B
  21.54$ Fee - 25.65$ Transfer Fee..

Ahhh, for a moment you took my breath away, on the image my reaction was ohhh shit it's rising against these shity ordinals and you can imagine what else I can think on the same time after exploring such high fees again.

After a few moments, my breath was back hehe, as it was an old case discussion with the current transaction fees I feel safe for now and it's going to rise over time, and I'm ok with it because with the concept of if you need to class security, you need to pay and for my assets security and networks transparency and decentralization.

Hehe, take a snapshot of the current transection cost.... if you want to move around on the network make sure to do it now... a good time...
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: pacar_tiri on February 08, 2024, 09:33:23 AM
Ahhh, for a moment you took my breath away, on the image my reaction was ohhh shit it's rising against these shity ordinals and you can imagine what else I can think on the same time after exploring such high fees again.

After a few moments, my breath was back hehe, as it was an old case discussion with the current transaction fees I feel safe for now and it's going to rise over time, and I'm ok with it because with the concept of if you need to class security, you need to pay and for my assets security and networks transparency and decentralization.

Hehe, take a snapshot of the current transection cost.... if you want to move around on the network make sure to do it now... a good time...
When transaction costs are very expensive, you can use other alternative coins, such as altcoins that have a BSC network or Sol Network, but when you only have Bitcoin in your electrum wallet, there is no other choice but to wait for transaction costs to decrease because the electrum wallet only provides a few options. The network method used to send Bitcoins, whereas if you choose the lowest fee, the transaction can be canceled or wait more than 24 hours.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: rdluffy on February 08, 2024, 01:21:30 PM
Well we have so a little decrease in fees as I have send 200 dollars earlier ? having 5 dollars fee so for me this is considerable amount to pay.
Hodling must not be forced mate , we are here in our own desire and dedication so try not to become greed and stupid.

Hehe, don't worry, the forced HODL part is just a joke  ;)
This is a wallet I've had for several years and I need to consolidate, so it ended up being quite expensive to do now, I'll have to wait, that's why I made the joke

I miss the 2sat/B days  ;D
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 08, 2024, 02:38:54 PM
Well we have so a little decrease in fees as I have send 200 dollars earlier ? having 5 dollars fee so for me this is considerable amount to pay.
Hodling must not be forced mate , we are here in our own desire and dedication so try not to become greed and stupid.

Hehe, don't worry, the forced HODL part is just a joke  ;)
This is a wallet I've had for several years and I need to consolidate, so it ended up being quite expensive to do now, I'll have to wait, that's why I made the joke

I miss the 2sat/B days  ;D

Transactions are  not expensive anymore. You can get a 23 sat vB confirmed within some hours, which is about 2 usd.

Not as cheap as 0.2 usd from 2 sat vB times ... but fees are getting lower.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: pacar_tiri on February 09, 2024, 02:45:08 PM
Transactions are  not expensive anymore. You can get a 23 sat vB confirmed within some hours, which is about 2 usd.

Not as cheap as 0.2 usd from 2 sat vB times ... but fees are getting lower.
Actually, when you want to make a transaction using Bitcoin, you have to look at your needs first. When you need Bitcoin to make a transaction quickly, it can increase transaction costs, but if you are willing to wait for the Bitcoin to be sent in a few minutes, maybe you can use vB 30. The sending cost is a little different, but it provides a fairly efficient delivery effect.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Hamza2424 on February 09, 2024, 09:16:22 PM
Ahhh, for a moment you took my breath away, on the image my reaction was ohhh shit it's rising against these shity ordinals and you can imagine what else I can think on the same time after exploring such high fees again.

After a few moments, my breath was back hehe, as it was an old case discussion with the current transaction fees I feel safe for now and it's going to rise over time, and I'm ok with it because with the concept of if you need to class security, you need to pay and for my assets security and networks transparency and decentralization.

Hehe, take a snapshot of the current transection cost.... if you want to move around on the network make sure to do it now... a good time...
When transaction costs are very expensive, you can use other alternative coins, such as altcoins that have a BSC network or Sol Network, but when you only have Bitcoin in your electrum wallet, there is no other choice but to wait for transaction costs to decrease because the electrum wallet only provides a few options. The network method used to send Bitcoins, whereas if you choose the lowest fee, the transaction can be canceled or wait more than 24 hours.

Hmm, got it I think you are trying to help me with the alternative payment mode but I was specific for the Bitcoin network because if a person owns Bitcoin only in whatever wallet he's using he needs to go with the Bitcoins network only, traders can use this strategy when they are making cross exchange trades to save network fees.

But for a Bitcoin holder, it doesn't matter whether other network costs are lower or higher. There's another option that we can use the pegged Bitcoins to save on the transfer but as I said for a Bitcoiner he might not choose the pegged Bitcoin due to the high risks involved. This is a proven fact that with the evolution of Bitcoin the network fees will go higher until we propose any other solution and belive me L2's are non acceptable.

 
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 09, 2024, 10:01:04 PM
~

This was just a spike. In a few minutes fees were normal again.

It took a bit more than just minutes, I remember quite a few blocks around that time!
But it was finally an event, another movement even if it was temporarily.

And the thing is, and the reason why comping back to the topic that a few orc-20 or src-20 I don't know what those things were managed to at least trigger a jump in fees while even a 10% increase in fee made absolutely nothing, not even the smallest dent, from February the 3rd we're on a gentle stop that probably will go down to 1sat/b, if a price action isn't pumping the mempool at this point no fomo will. Besides, it's the weekend so I think me might touch the 10.x-11sat/b floor.


Well we have so a little decrease in fees as I have send 200 dollars earlier ? having 5 dollars fee so for me this is considerable amount to pay.
Hodling must not be forced mate , we are here in our own desire and dedication so try not to become greed and stupid.

Hehe, don't worry, the forced HODL part is just a joke  ;)
This is a wallet I've had for several years and I need to consolidate, so it ended up being quite expensive to do now, I'll have to wait, that's why I made the joke
I miss the 2sat/B days  ;D

Transactions are  not expensive anymore. You can get a 23 sat vB confirmed within some hours, which is about 2 usd.
Not as cheap as 0.2 usd from 2 sat vB times ... but fees are getting lower.

Well, we don't know how many inputs he had in those 200$, if it's just one it would be manageable but what if he has more?
That's why I don't really like when people say you pay x$ for something and refer only to the bare minimum, like 1 input and 1 output into a deposit address with no change while somebody else talks about the same sum be he has only 10000 satoshi inputs, carrying his wheelbarrow full coins to the store.

Anyhow, I have a feeling fees are going to drop, like really drop! Also, I'm most of the time wrong with my predictions!
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: EthereumDev_ on February 10, 2024, 10:21:35 AM
Hmm, got it I think you are trying to help me with the alternative payment mode but I was specific for the Bitcoin network because if a person owns Bitcoin only in whatever wallet he's using he needs to go with the Bitcoins network only, traders can use this strategy when they are making cross exchange trades to save network fees.

But for a Bitcoin holder, it doesn't matter whether other network costs are lower or higher. There's another option that we can use the pegged Bitcoins to save on the transfer but as I said for a Bitcoiner he might not choose the pegged Bitcoin due to the high risks involved. This is a proven fact that with the evolution of Bitcoin the network fees will go higher until we propose any other solution and belive me L2's are non acceptable.
In my opinion, some Bitcoin wallets provide very expensive transaction fees, and when that happens, there is no other choice but to wait until transactions on the blockchain network are not too busy anymore, or maybe you can use a computer and connect the wallet you are using using Electrum and try looking for the cheapest cost with Electrum installed on the PC.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Hamza2424 on February 10, 2024, 02:51:44 PM
Hmm, got it I think you are trying to help me with the alternative payment mode but I was specific for the Bitcoin network because if a person owns Bitcoin only in whatever wallet he's using he needs to go with the Bitcoins network only, traders can use this strategy when they are making cross exchange trades to save network fees.

But for a Bitcoin holder, it doesn't matter whether other network costs are lower or higher. There's another option that we can use the pegged Bitcoins to save on the transfer but as I said for a Bitcoiner he might not choose the pegged Bitcoin due to the high risks involved. This is a proven fact that with the evolution of Bitcoin the network fees will go higher until we propose any other solution and belive me L2's are non acceptable.
In my opinion, some Bitcoin wallets provide very expensive transaction fees, and when that happens, there is no other choice but to wait until transactions on the blockchain network are not too busy anymore, or maybe you can use a computer and connect the wallet you are using using Electrum and try looking for the cheapest cost with Electrum installed on the PC.

I really cant oppose this fact, some wallets really offer higher transaction fees and no customization feature for boosting or sitting up custom fees. In my views, they usually set auto higher fees to enhance their customer's experience with the transaction processing.

Mostly newbies use the renowned Hot wallets like Trust wallet, so they really miss the important information related to the memepool and unit sat/b, but those who are aware of it mostly prefer the Electrum like solutions for their transection.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: rdluffy on February 10, 2024, 04:59:59 PM
Transactions are  not expensive anymore. You can get a 23 sat vB confirmed within some hours, which is about 2 usd.

Not as cheap as 0.2 usd from 2 sat vB times ... but fees are getting lower.

The problem is, I need to consolidate my wallet, take a look here:

(https://i.ibb.co/VHVrV0g/mem.png) (https://imgbb.com/)

40 USD if I use 20 sat vB

I don't have much to do now, the good thing is that I won't need to trade, but it would be good if I already consolidated it for a possible transaction in the future
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on February 10, 2024, 05:20:24 PM
The problem is, I need to consolidate my wallet, take a look here:

(https://i.ibb.co/VHVrV0g/mem.png) (https://imgbb.com/)

40 USD if I use 20 sat vB

Better don't look at USD value so much, this can get much higher when bitcoin get's to 100k, 200k or 500k. ;)
You can also wait or try using lower value with around 10 sat/vB but there is no guarantee when this transaction will be confirmed.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 10, 2024, 05:46:44 PM
Transactions are  not expensive anymore. You can get a 23 sat vB confirmed within some hours, which is about 2 usd.

Not as cheap as 0.2 usd from 2 sat vB times ... but fees are getting lower.

The problem is, I need to consolidate my wallet, take a look here:

(https://i.ibb.co/VHVrV0g/mem.png) (https://imgbb.com/)

40 USD if I use 20 sat vB

I don't have much to do now, the good thing is that I won't need to trade, but it would be good if I already consolidated it for a possible transaction in the future

How many inputs do you have there?  :o
A ballpark figure gets me at least 50 if we assume segwit inputs and consolidation.
Anyhow most likely by early Monday morning you could do that with half of a the sum, I'm pretty confident that the weekend will make us touch 10sat/b.



Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: rdluffy on February 10, 2024, 09:48:02 PM
Better don't look at USD value so much, this can get much higher when bitcoin get's to 100k, 200k or 500k. ;)
You can also wait or try using lower value with around 10 sat/vB but there is no guarantee when this transaction will be confirmed.

I'm thinking about whether to try a 10 sat/vB transaction or leave it for the future and maybe we can go back to 5 sat in a few weeks/months
If I try 10 sat I can save 20 USD, it's a good amount to save

How many inputs do you have there?  :o
A ballpark figure gets me at least 50 if we assume segwit inputs and consolidation.
Anyhow most likely by early Monday morning you could do that with half of a the sum, I'm pretty confident that the weekend will make us touch 10sat/b.

More than 80 inputs  ;D
It's a good amount to save, I'll keep looking the Mempool to see if I can save more
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 10, 2024, 11:31:09 PM
~

More than 80 inputs  ;D
It's a good amount to save, I'll keep looking the Mempool to see if I can save more

You could do a reverse DCA fee saving plan  ;D ;D
Basically split your inputs in two or three batches depending on their value and you consolidate them like:
- the first most valued one at 10sat/vb
- second batch not so important you broadcast them at 5sat
and the last one just dump it at 1 sat/vb and leave it in the mempool

This way you would be at no risk at waiting for 5 and some other stupid hype to pump the the fees back to 100sat/vb but of course you will also feel bad if it does indeed drop to 1sat/vb.
But that being said, I'm almost sure we could touch under 10 if not even 8 by next Thursday(when the difficulty adjusts again)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 11, 2024, 05:32:07 PM
In my opinion, some Bitcoin wallets provide very expensive transaction fees, and when that happens, there is no other choice but to wait until transactions on the blockchain network are not too busy anymore, or maybe you can use a computer and connect the wallet you are using using Electrum and try looking for the cheapest cost with Electrum installed on the PC.
This is just bad software. Not bitcoin protocol problem.

Anyway  you can most of the time customize the transaction fee, and use the ones recommended by mempool.space,  which is the most accurate fee rate prediction for transactions
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on February 11, 2024, 05:49:22 PM
Better don't look at USD value so much, this can get much higher when bitcoin get's to 100k, 200k or 500k. ;)
You can also wait or try using lower value with around 10 sat/vB but there is no guarantee when this transaction will be confirmed.

I'm thinking about whether to try a 10 sat/vB transaction or leave it for the future and maybe we can go back to 5 sat in a few weeks/months
If I try 10 sat I can save 20 USD, it's a good amount to save

How many inputs do you have there?  :o
A ballpark figure gets me at least 50 if we assume segwit inputs and consolidation.
Anyhow most likely by early Monday morning you could do that with half of a the sum, I'm pretty confident that the weekend will make us touch 10sat/b.

More than 80 inputs  ;D
It's a good amount to save, I'll keep looking the Mempool to see if I can save more

13 or 14 sats looks good at the moment. you would save around 14 dollars if you use 14 sats.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: masudginanjar on February 12, 2024, 09:37:16 AM
Better don't look at USD value so much, this can get much higher when bitcoin get's to 100k, 200k or 500k. ;)
You can also wait or try using lower value with around 10 sat/vB but there is no guarantee when this transaction will be confirmed.
I'm thinking about whether to try a 10 sat/vB transaction or leave it for the future and maybe we can go back to 5 sat in a few weeks/months
If I try 10 sat I can save 20 USD, it's a good amount to save
How many inputs do you have there?  :o
A ballpark figure gets me at least 50 if we assume segwit inputs and consolidation.
Anyhow most likely by early Monday morning you could do that with half of a the sum, I'm pretty confident that the weekend will make us touch 10sat/b.
More than 80 inputs  ;D
It's a good amount to save, I'll keep looking the Mempool to see if I can save more
13 or 14 sats looks good at the moment. you would save around 14 dollars if you use 14 sats.
(https://i.imgur.com/Pi6DuVb.png)
Sorry, I only convey the latest information at this time when I looked at the website https://blockchair.com/
There I saw around 12 Satoshi for Bitcoin transaction fees, that means it's cheaper as you said around 13 or 14 satoshi.

But if I ask all markets, miners and various components in Bitcoin, I want the Bitcoin transaction fee to be below 4 Satsohi.
As far i know , y're miners of Bitcoin . Can this happen if the Bitcoin transaction fee is below 4 satoshi?
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on February 12, 2024, 04:56:26 PM
(https://i.ibb.co/k0YDVNz/pic565.jpg) (https://imgbb.com/)

And here we go again  :P
Just when I thought we are going to get back below 10 sat/vB, new wave of transactions came in and mempool is full again.
I hope everyone consolidated on time and enjoyed low fees while they lasted.

Bitmover how is that L-BTC observer development doing?
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 12, 2024, 10:48:33 PM
Just when I thought we are going to get back below 10 sat/vB, new wave of transactions came in and mempool is full again.
I hope everyone consolidated on time and enjoyed low fees while they lasted.

Neah, cheap fees will still be around, this was just a dump that triggered a small clog.
Overall the mempool i still smaller 2015vMB despite that compared to than Saturday 220vMb or Friday 270vMb.
And it's again almost midnight in Europe so we will go pretty soon back to 12sat/vb 9there (are just 6 blocks till that).
The real test will be in 3 days once the difficulty adjusts.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 12, 2024, 11:39:15 PM

Bitmover how is that L-BTC observer development doing?

I will first add L-BTC to my balance Checker tool


I didn’t think about fee observer. As fees are very low  it would be monotonous.  Don't you think?

I am preparing also a browser extension to help plot the price image api in the forums
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on February 13, 2024, 02:53:38 AM
I didn't think we were >10 sat/vB but it might be a good opportunity to Consolidate your small inputs
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/02/13/v86KZ.png)
With a Bitcoin price around $50,000, the fees are very low.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Papusha20 on February 13, 2024, 08:11:46 AM
I didn't think we were >10 sat/vB but it might be a good opportunity to Consolidate your small inputs
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/02/13/v86KZ.png)
With a Bitcoin price around $50,000, the fees are very low.

Bitcoin transaction satoshis are very low, but in the past when bitcoin prices were very low, bitcoin transaction satoshis were high. Currently a little higher because the volume of transactions has increased.
(https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/13/v8qSZ.jpeg)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: joniboini on February 13, 2024, 10:43:27 AM
Bitcoin transaction satoshis are very low, but in the past when bitcoin prices were very low, bitcoin transaction satoshis were high. Currently a little higher because the volume of transactions has increased.
I don't get what you're trying to say here. Are you saying that the sats/vb fees are still higher compared to the past? I think that's just inevitable though, the network will never be free because more people are using it. It is not ideal to compare it to the fiat value since you still pay in sats anyway unless you're buying and trading Bitcoin regularly so you need to keep the margin to get some profits.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on February 13, 2024, 10:55:55 PM
Neah, cheap fees will still be around, this was just a dump that triggered a small clog.
Overall the mempool i still smaller 2015vMB despite that compared to than Saturday 220vMb or Friday 270vMb.
I am not so sure we are going to have fees bellow 10-15 sat/vB for a while.
Binance have a huge number of unconfirmed transactions and they usually have bad fee management.

I didn’t think about fee observer. As fees are very low  it would be monotonous.  Don't you think?
It can be built inside current fee observer.
For example you can add additional info that you can save on fees with Lighting for $? and on Liquid for $?

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Uruhara on February 13, 2024, 11:12:02 PM

I didn't think we were >10 sat/vB but it might be a good opportunity to Consolidate your small inputs
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/02/13/v86KZ.png)
With a Bitcoin price around $50,000, the fees are very low.
I haven't checked the price of Bitcoin transaction fees for a long time, or several days or a week, so I don't know if there has been a decrease in transaction fees again in the BTC network. is it because the BRC-20 has lost its hype? Yes, it doesn't matter what the reason is, the most important thing is that costs remain low when BTC prices soar to higher levels. With this we no longer need to worry about the costs of sending BTC. As I write this the fee is still the same at around 13 sats/vB.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 13, 2024, 11:34:51 PM

I didn’t think about fee observer. As fees are very low  it would be monotonous.  Don't you think?
It can be built inside current fee observer.
For example you can add additional info that you can save on fees with Lighting for $? and on Liquid for $?

That's a good idea.

I can even implement FeeBuddy here, with some additional alttcoins such Ethereum, LTC, etc
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on February 14, 2024, 02:41:55 PM

I didn’t think about fee observer. As fees are very low  it would be monotonous.  Don't you think?
It can be built inside current fee observer.
For example you can add additional info that you can save on fees with Lighting for $? and on Liquid for $?

That's a good idea.

I can even implement FeeBuddy here, with some additional alttcoins such Ethereum, LTC, etc

dkbit98 - the biggest promoter of L-BTC  :D
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Litzki1990 on February 14, 2024, 03:04:39 PM
The value of Bitcoin has increased considerably but Bitcoin transaction fees are currently at normal levels. Mempool was 13 sat/vB at the time I was making this post. According to 13 sat/vB Mempool if Bitcoin is transferred then the user has to pay one dollar BTC fee from each transfer. Other times it is seen that when the Bitcoin market increases, Mempool increases a lot but now we see something different. 13 sat/vB is definitely the minimum mempool to transfer bitcoins. At present there may be no user complaints about transferring bitcoins because now the transfer fees of bitcoins are limited.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 15, 2024, 03:42:42 PM
I am not so sure we are going to have fees bellow 10-15 sat/vB for a while.
Binance have a huge number of unconfirmed transactions and they usually have bad fee management.

Binance is paying out at 3x all the time and their small inputs consolidations are already in the mempool at 10sat/vb and 5sat/vb:
https://mempool.space/address/bc1qm34lsc65zpw79lxes69zkqmk6ee3ewf0j77s3h
actually blockstream is better at this:
https://blockstream.info/address/bc1qm34lsc65zpw79lxes69zkqmk6ee3ewf0j77s3h
UNCONFIRMED TX COUNT   3565

There won't be any game changer move coming from exchnges, they are either spending 3 times like Binance or OKex or have a ton in waiting already in the mempool, the NFT hype is down for a while , the only thing that will make a sufficient change is the difficulty adjustment that has just hit, we had a ton of extra speed in the last 13 days, that most likely will be gone.

For a bit we still have 13sat/vb last block.

Other times it is seen that when the Bitcoin market increases, Mempool increases a lot but now we see something different.

Because all the action is on CEXs and ETFs, this is all trading and nobody moves coins to actually buy or sale from or to their wallets.
Hodlers hold and sellers had the coins already there.


Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on March 17, 2024, 11:26:03 PM
Fees are low, it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/03/17/JE3lN.png)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on March 18, 2024, 12:20:41 AM
Fees are low, it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/03/17/JE3lN.png)

It's a picture I've been wanting to see for a long time.  :D

btw. @Yamane_Keto, did you know that there is a browser extension made by bitmover that allows you to set information such as the current fee in just one click? You don't have to do a screenshot, upload, etc...

For example:
(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php?&currency=USD&hex=000000) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)

You can find more at [FORUM EXTENSION] Bitcoin data API ready to be inserted in altcointalks posts. (https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=318130.msg1503612#msg1503612)
Or visit his website: https://bitcoindata.science
There is a lot of interesting stuff there.  ;)

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on March 18, 2024, 10:38:00 AM
Fees are low, it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/03/17/JE3lN.png)

I will wait a little more. I believe we will see 1 sat vB soon! Maybe in a few months.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on March 19, 2024, 04:29:00 PM
I will wait a little more. I believe we will see 1 sat vB soon! Maybe in a few months.
You keep saying that same line for weeks, and I keep telling you that is not going to happen any time soon, halving is coming and real bull run has not even started yet.
''Few months'' is not soon and it can easily turn into year.
Dreaming is free, so you can continue doing it ;)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on March 19, 2024, 07:15:22 PM
I will wait a little more. I believe we will see 1 sat vB soon! Maybe in a few months.
You keep saying that same line for weeks, and I keep telling you that is not going to happen any time soon, halving is coming and real bull run has not even started yet.
''Few months'' is not soon and it can easily turn into year.
Dreaming is free, so you can continue doing it ;)

A few weeks ago I saw many people saying we would never see 1 sat again. But it looks like we will see it again at any moment.

I have hundreds of inputs. I will consolidate then only at 1 sat vB. I have no hurry...
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on March 19, 2024, 10:49:05 PM
I will wait a little more. I believe we will see 1 sat vB soon! Maybe in a few months.

Not with stuff like this:
(https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/03/19/JVLKP.png)

I had a topic on Bitcointalk, exactly on this title, when we will see 1sat/b , everyone was pessimistic and then it happened in one month.
But, right now I think that 1sat/b is just too cheap, blocks in the weekend were at around 5k in fees, so if it still goes down it could be less than that, a point at which all this world full of people with a ton of money throwing it at random stuff might find it funny to get their own block inscription.

Let's say it will cost me $2000 to inscribe a block "stompix was here" of course my real name, my glorious results, my achievements, my name to be remembered forever in the blockchain...Now, how many idiots thinking the same thing and having more than $2000 to spare do you think there are in the world? Cause I know a lot that have thrown tens of thousands at jpg cats.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: hugeblack on March 20, 2024, 10:37:36 AM
I will wait a little more. I believe we will see 1 sat vB soon! Maybe in a few months.
If Bitcoin price correction continues between $50,000 and $60,000, we may see 1 sat/vB, assuming that a few will sell and the purchase transactions will be via CEXs that batch the transactions. We also do not expect to see any BRC-20 spam.
If the average Bitcoin mining continues for less than ~9.1 minutes, we may see it for some blocks.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on March 20, 2024, 03:07:41 PM
Let's say it will cost me $2000 to inscribe a block "stompix was here" of course my real name, my glorious results, my achievements, my name to be remembered forever in the blockchain...Now, how many idiots thinking the same thing and having more than $2000 to spare do you think there are in the world? Cause I know a lot that have thrown tens of thousands at jpg cats.

What is somewhat bizarre is that bitcoin is becoming a blockchain for nft. Cheaper than ethereum main net.

And there are many people receiving lots of airdrops. People who made inscriptions with their bitcoins are receiving hundreds/thousands of dollars in airdrops.

I didnt make any bitcoin nft, but people are making money out of it for now.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on March 21, 2024, 09:20:27 PM
What is somewhat bizarre is that bitcoin is becoming a blockchain for nft. Cheaper than ethereum main net.

And there are many people receiving lots of airdrops. People who made inscriptions with their bitcoins are receiving hundreds/thousands of dollars in airdrops.

I didnt make any bitcoin nft, but people are making money out of it for now.

What is even more bizarre is that it is only a current trend and in a year, most of the NFT on bitcoin will be worthless.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: pacar_tiri on March 21, 2024, 11:58:57 PM
What is even more bizarre is that it is only a current trend and in a year, most of the NFT on bitcoin will be worthless.
It is natural that NFTs on the bitcoin network will soon end because the main purpose of bitcoin is not to create NFTs and it could be said that NFTs are just hype that is trending only for a moment, there are already many like that, including on other networks.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on March 22, 2024, 05:04:26 PM
What is somewhat bizarre is that bitcoin is becoming a blockchain for nft. Cheaper than ethereum main net.
That just shows how bad ethereum is. :P

And there are many people receiving lots of airdrops. People who made inscriptions with their bitcoins are receiving hundreds/thousands of dollars in airdrops.
Nobody is receiving this by doing anything.
You need to participate and be active in this crap, and you will receive a lot more scam, spam and worthless nft crap.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on March 22, 2024, 07:53:17 PM
What is somewhat bizarre is that bitcoin is becoming a blockchain for nft. Cheaper than ethereum main net.
That just shows how bad ethereum is. :P

Yeah, this is really impressive.

I own some ethereum, and I converted some of my funds from Sinbad to Ethereum for privacy purposes. however, I am considering swap them now for BTC or SOL.

maybe a little SOL ( to buy more btc later)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on March 22, 2024, 10:03:07 PM
If Bitcoin price correction continues between $50,000 and $60,000, we may see 1 sat/vB, assuming that a few will sell and the purchase transactions will be via CEXs that batch the transactions. We also do not expect to see any BRC-20 spam.
If the average Bitcoin mining continues for less than ~9.1 minutes, we may see it for some blocks.

If the price rise hasn't made anything significant happen to the fees I doubt the downtrend would do either, this is something normal in my opinion, the price moving up and down, and sideways we're going to see the same number of tx.

I don't know where you got the 9.1 minutes, I assume that's something daily?
Pace this epoch (since 14th march) has been almost always negative, currently 28 blocks behind.

It is natural that NFTs on the bitcoin network will soon end because the main purpose of bitcoin is not to create NFTs and it could be said that NFTs are just hype that is trending only for a moment, there are already many like that, including on other networks.

Natural? No!
Things end when there is no demand for it, no demand for Bitcoin NFT at all will never happen!
People used to inscribe a lot of stuff in the blockchain well before NFTs, so this will never truly end, it might go down in size but it won't disappear!
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on March 25, 2024, 02:17:16 PM
I own some ethereum, and I converted some of my funds from Sinbad to Ethereum for privacy purposes. however, I am considering swap them now for BTC or SOL.

maybe a little SOL ( to buy more btc later)

I remember that some time ago you wanted to leave Litecoin because it was unreliable or even too unstable. I would never choose Ethereum over LTC. Otherwise, Litecoin had a growth of about 30% in the last month.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on March 26, 2024, 12:20:37 PM
I own some ethereum, and I converted some of my funds from Sinbad to Ethereum for privacy purposes. however, I am considering swap them now for BTC or SOL.

maybe a little SOL ( to buy more btc later)

I remember that some time ago you wanted to leave Litecoin because it was unreliable or even too unstable. I would never choose Ethereum over LTC. Otherwise, Litecoin had a growth of about 30% in the last month.

But litecoin performance is even worse in long term
It used to be rank top10 a few years ago  and is now about 30 or something.

It is losing much more value against bitcoin than ethereum is..
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: pacar_tiri on March 29, 2024, 11:12:59 PM
But litecoin performance is even worse in long term
It used to be rank top10 a few years ago  and is now about 30 or something.

It is losing much more value against bitcoin than ethereum is..
A digital currency project like Litecoin must have developments from year to year, always updating technology so that it will increase interest in Litecoin, but if the developer doesn't want to do that then it is certain that Litecoin will always remain silent and no one will be interested anymore.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on March 30, 2024, 04:07:26 PM
But litecoin performance is even worse in long term
It used to be rank top10 a few years ago  and is now about 30 or something.

It is losing much more value against bitcoin than ethereum is..

Doge has overtaken it or overshadowed it, not sure what term to use.
Since merge mining they became entangled, after that faster and cheaper fees have made dogecoin the king of pow if we ignore bitcoin, then the userbase, we add the availability of speeding gateways and litecoiin has absolutely no advantage over so much wow much great coin doge.
Everything that litecoiin was doing better as bitcoin acting like silver to gold, doge does it even better.
So, it has lost it's main selling point, it will be a slow death but it's going after long forgotten names, dash?? for example!

Also, unusual spike on friday but fees are back at 9, seems like there is simply no demand, despite a ton of monkeys still being minted.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Legion on April 02, 2024, 08:51:00 AM
But litecoin performance is even worse in long term
It used to be rank top10 a few years ago  and is now about 30 or something.

It is losing much more value against bitcoin than ethereum is..
A digital currency project like Litecoin must have developments from year to year, always updating technology so that it will increase interest in Litecoin, but if the developer doesn't want to do that then it is certain that Litecoin will always remain silent and no one will be interested anymore.
I am sure that Litecoin will still survive even though the development it has has is not as much as other projects because Litecoin is a digital currency that was created at a very old age, so I am sure that the CEO developer is very afraid of taking risks to carry out new developments.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bhadz on April 02, 2024, 09:19:49 AM
But litecoin performance is even worse in long term
It used to be rank top10 a few years ago  and is now about 30 or something.

It is losing much more value against bitcoin than ethereum is..
The basis for that is the market cap and volume and I agree that if it's. But if it's about the use case of it, I still enjoy it using for transactions. I guess that we'd get to see it drop some more of the ranks as it seems to be dropping and can't soar unlike the other cryptos. If it's about long term, I'd still pick this than any of the memes.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on April 02, 2024, 11:47:19 AM
But litecoin performance is even worse in long term
It used to be rank top10 a few years ago  and is now about 30 or something.

It is losing much more value against bitcoin than ethereum is..
The basis for that is the market cap and volume and I agree that if it's. But if it's about the use case of it, I still enjoy it using for transactions. I guess that we'd get to see it drop some more of the ranks as it seems to be dropping and can't soar unlike the other cryptos. If it's about long term, I'd still pick this than any of the memes.

I use litcoin sometimes too. I don't know why it is performing so badly.. ethereum is alos having a poor performance for the last month
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on April 02, 2024, 02:22:49 PM
The basis for that is the market cap and volume and I agree that if it's. But if it's about the use case of it, I still enjoy it using for transactions. I guess that we'd get to see it drop some more of the ranks as it seems to be dropping and can't soar unlike the other cryptos. If it's about long term, I'd still pick this than any of the memes.
Circulating supply for many cryptocurrencies can be easily manipulated. As for Litecoin, the coin is still in good stead but its use cases are limited which make its value diminish. Low fees are the only advantage of LTC but even Bitcoin (in these days) you can broadcast a transaction for 15 sat/vByte and get confirmation in less than 20 min.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on April 02, 2024, 04:06:53 PM
Low fees are the only advantage of LTC but even Bitcoin (in these days) you can broadcast a transaction for 15 sat/vByte and get confirmation in less than 20 min.

But $1.5 plus $1.5 and multiplied by 50 weeks a year starts pending in anyone's wallet.
I'm saying twice 1.5$ because if you send some coins the guys receiving them has also to pay to use them as it's not a bank deposit, then if you have multiple outputs and so on, if your CEX is a shitty one that charges more for BTC than LTC or Doge (cough , Binance) you look back at a year of expenses and you realize even 2$ for a tx is too much for random weekly usage.

And I think daily or weekly usage is dead on Bitcoin, we have sky-high prices compared to 3 months ago, fees have flattened despite half of the block space being used by ordinals and consolidation, I think that most deals have shifted to stablecoins as not only fees but volatility has also become a pain in the ass

Anyhow, finally, the mempool is not during above 1.30sat/vb for the default 300MB settings, two more weekends and nothing out of the ordinary and we might see 1sat/vb not being rejected by default nodes.



Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: IvugeoEvolutionCoin on April 13, 2024, 10:27:18 AM
The basis for that is the market cap and volume and I agree that if it's. But if it's about the use case of it, I still enjoy it using for transactions. I guess that we'd get to see it drop some more of the ranks as it seems to be dropping and can't soar unlike the other cryptos. If it's about long term, I'd still pick this than any of the memes.
Circulating supply for many cryptocurrencies can be easily manipulated. As for Litecoin, the coin is still in good stead but its use cases are limited which make its value diminish. Low fees are the only advantage of LTC but even Bitcoin (in these days) you can broadcast a transaction for 15 sat/vByte and get confirmation in less than 20 min.
LTC is currently one of the oldest cryptocurrency projects still alive, the project they have this year doesn't seem to be of much use to many people but still remains to this day is a very good value. Litecoin must continue to develop to keep increasing its use.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on June 07, 2024, 07:02:14 PM
Let's dump this a bit since we crossed 500sat per vbyte.
And I already see a few meltdowns on BT but here seems like everyone is either completely chill or hasn't heard the news or wasn't forced to use bitcoin today. Anyhow, it's the weekend and instead of seeing again fees of 1$ during the weekend, we're most likely have to wait this one out.

Dramaaaa!  ::)

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on June 11, 2024, 02:55:12 PM
Let's dump this a bit since we crossed 500sat per vbyte.
And I already see a few meltdowns on BT but here seems like everyone is either completely chill or hasn't heard the news or wasn't forced to use bitcoin today. Anyhow, it's the weekend and instead of seeing again fees of 1$ during the weekend, we're most likely have to wait this one out.

Dramaaaa!  ::)

Your drama queen ambitions did not go over well this time  :D

Honestly, I already bored myself with the drama about the high fee, so I accepted things and decided to reduce my nervousness about it.
I used Mastercard for some payments in those days, so my conclusion is that Bitcoin is good as long as you have a bank card as a backup means of payment. I guess that's how Bitcoin was conceived.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on June 11, 2024, 09:47:27 PM
Meanwhile mempool fees on Liquid network for L-BTC and L-USDT are around ~0 sat/vB or $0.00  8)
https://liquid.network/

I think fees on main chain is acceptable again with around ~30 sat/vB, but I am expecting big changes in next few months.
We could see major crash in all markets including stocks and bitcoin, but this is going to be bigger crash than 2008.
That usually means chaos in mempool and possible bear market, so better prepare for this, but let's wait and see what happens.
Remember this when autumn comes and tell me if I was wrong or not.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on June 12, 2024, 03:51:49 AM
Meanwhile mempool fees on Liquid network for L-BTC and L-USDT are around ~0 sat/vB or $0.00  8)
https://liquid.network/

I think fees on main chain is acceptable again with around ~30 sat/vB, but I am expecting big changes in next few months.
We could see major crash in all markets including stocks and bitcoin, but this is going to be bigger crash than 2008.
That usually means chaos in mempool and possible bear market, so better prepare for this, but let's wait and see what happens.
Remember this when autumn comes and tell me if I was wrong or not.

Do you really think we will,super crash?

I can tell you that the Fed's refusal to lower rates in 2008 push the crash back then.

Maybe the feds will drop rates this Wednesday June 12.  I feel that pushing the rate drop down the road out into the future time after time is a sign we will crash like we did in 2008.

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on June 12, 2024, 09:49:57 PM
Do you really think we will,super crash?
Not now, but probably in next few months, September and October are their favorite months for things like this.
I think they are preparing stage for big war and maybe new round of scary flu propaganda, as excuse for that huge crash in all countries.
If that happens than Bitcoin will also go down, but I hope that I am totally wrong about this.
Prepare your BTC accordingly in case this happens.

we will crash like we did in 2008.
This could be much much worse than 2008.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on June 12, 2024, 10:33:20 PM
we will crash like we did in 2008.
This could be much much worse than 2008.

When you look back, every crash looks small. Even covid crisis look small now when we look at charts.

But when we are living it,  and our money is at stake, those crashes are all terrible and make people afraid.

I see many people saying that a crisis is expected in usa. I hear that for a long time alread (like 10 years).. personally,  I hope it doesn't come, what we had is enough
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on June 12, 2024, 10:58:35 PM
When you look back, every crash looks small. Even covid crisis look small now when we look at charts.

Bitcoin proved to be quite resistant to the COVID crisis. On the day of the declaration of the pandemic, the value dropped to $5k, but recovery soon began and the value of Bitcoin grew constantly until the end of the year, I think it was around $30k.
At a time when everyone was working hard, due to the lockdown, the values ​​of digital goods like Bitcoin came to the fore.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on June 13, 2024, 11:50:40 AM
When you look back, every crash looks small. Even covid crisis look small now when we look at charts.

Bitcoin proved to be quite resistant to the COVID crisis. On the day of the declaration of the pandemic, the value dropped to $5k, but recovery soon began and the value of Bitcoin grew constantly until the end of the year, I think it was around $30k.
At a time when everyone was working hard, due to the lockdown, the values ​​of digital goods like Bitcoin came to the fore.

Although it recovered soon, I was quite scared because I was losing money everywhere...

I lost basically 30% of my overall portfolio (of all had) in the beginning of the pandemics.  I was much better later on  in the end of 2020... and amazingly better in 2021
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on June 13, 2024, 01:10:36 PM
Bitcoin proved to be quite resistant to the COVID crisis. On the day of the declaration of the pandemic, the value dropped to $5k, but recovery soon began and the value of Bitcoin grew constantly until the end of the year, I think it was around $30k.
At a time when everyone was working hard, due to the lockdown, the values ​​of digital goods like Bitcoin came to the fore.

If you look strictly at the covid crisis almost everything recovered from that, Microsoft shares crashed from 170 to 130, by 2022 they were at 300 and now 400 (euros) and of course that's nothing compared to oil that went negative  ;D The troubling thing is that high inflation didn't influence the price the way we wanted and expected, we all look to low inflation and fed cuts to boost prices when normally it should have been high inflation that would have driven it.

Although it recovered soon, I was quite scared because I was losing money everywhere...


A real crisis not just what happened there won't be good for anyone, you're not going to have unemployed, homeless, and bankrupt people invest money in crypto the way you do when there is economic growth and everyone has something to spare.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: NotATether on June 13, 2024, 01:35:26 PM
Although it recovered soon, I was quite scared because I was losing money everywhere...

I lost basically 30% of my overall portfolio (of all had) in the beginning of the pandemics.  I was much better later on  in the end of 2020... and amazingly better in 2021

Was that only in Bitcoin or in other ventures as well?

Because most people who had YOLO'd into Bitcoin and went all in also lost about a third of their net worth by March 2020 at the height of the pandemic.

I suppose everyone who took advantage and bought the dip at that time period were really happy at their gains in the end.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on June 13, 2024, 04:07:50 PM
Although it recovered soon, I was quite scared because I was losing money everywhere...

I lost basically 30% of my overall portfolio (of all had) in the beginning of the pandemics.  I was much better later on  in the end of 2020... and amazingly better in 2021

Was that only in Bitcoin or in other ventures as well?

Because most people who had YOLO'd into Bitcoin and went all in also lost about a third of their net worth by March 2020 at the height of the pandemic.


Basically all assets lost value at the beginning of the pandemic, even Gold was hit

The point is that  looking back, every crisis looks smaller than it was. Probably the next crisis will be also as hard as the other ones for those who will live it, but looking back at charts they will look but fine like a big V.

Quote
I suppose everyone who took advantage and bought the dip at that time period were really happy at their gains in the end.

The point is that one time the money ends. I am basically 100% bought already in thinks I think will have a positive valuation over the next years (mostly BTC, Sp500, some ETFs, some treasuries and bonds from 5-6% APY, some brazillian bonds 15-20% APY, etc). I will not have money to buy more stuff in a crisis if it comes soon.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on June 25, 2024, 03:02:26 PM
Fees are low, it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/03/17/JE3lN.png)
Fees are low, it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php?&currency=USD&hex=000000) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: 0t3p0t on June 25, 2024, 03:38:12 PM
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/06/25/hJyXJ.jpeg)
It's going up again this time, all I thought it will stay at around 10sats/vb or lower but yeah it started to rise and I don't know how high it will be going and I have this question in mind like is there a possibility of fees going down to 1 sats/vb? If there is a chance would you still hodl or withdraw?
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on June 25, 2024, 06:14:39 PM
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/06/25/hJyXJ.jpeg)
It's going up again this time, all I thought it will stay at around 10sats/vb or lower but yeah it started to rise and I don't know how high it will be going and I have this question in mind like is there a possibility of fees going down to 1 sats/vb? If there is a chance would you still hodl or withdraw?

Spikes happen now and then because of random block time, we had two blocks coming over 30 minutes apart in the last 7 and 5 hours, for example right now the block is late by 10 minutes, minimum fee for the blocks is 22sat/vb but min fee for the next one is just 8 sat/vb so it's just about patience right now.

There is simply no demand for backspace anymore, despite them being full of runes and ordinals they are not willing to pay that much, and neither are exchanges that consolidate huge amounts so most likely if nothing out of the ordinary happens we will hit 5 sat/vb by next weekend.

As for the 1sat/vb....that's a bit different, already at 4sat/vb it costs just a few thousand dollars to inscribe a full block with your "project" or put a game in there so we might hit a wall where spam is just to cheap to let fees go even lower.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on June 25, 2024, 10:34:43 PM
This is very good time for consolidation of coins or for opening Lightning Network channels if you are using that.
Currently estimated fee in in mempool.space is around 8 sat/vB or $0.69, and this could change if bitcoin price changes and drops again.
I think this is quiet time before the Bitcoin storm.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on June 26, 2024, 01:09:11 PM
I don't know how high it will be going and I have this question in mind like is there a possibility of fees going down to 1 sats/vb? If there is a chance would you still hodl or withdraw?
Currently, some nodes allow you to broadcast a <2.67 sat/vB transaction, some may accept 2 sat/vB, but you can broadcast a transaction for 3 sat/vB. If the fees continue to drop, you may be able to get 1 sat/vB.

The contents of the next block are Consolidation data (combine all inputs), a few coinjoin, which means that fees may decrease in the coming hours.

(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/06/26/h1fCH.png)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dwyane36 on June 26, 2024, 04:55:04 PM
This is very good time for consolidation of coins or for opening Lightning Network channels if you are using that.
Currently estimated fee in in mempool.space is around 8 sat/vB or $0.69, and this could change if bitcoin price changes and drops again.
I think this is quiet time before the Bitcoin storm.

Recently, the main reason why the fee has increased or decreased was not because of the BTC price but because of spamming by ordinals and rune transactions in the BTC network. I think you saw what happened in the BTC network right after the halving. However, now, the number of rune transactions is only 8.2% of the total transactions in the BTC network. Therefore, the fee is more or less adequate at the moment.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on June 27, 2024, 02:55:55 PM
Recently, the main reason why the fee has increased or decreased was not because of the BTC price but because of spamming by ordinals and rune transactions in the BTC network.
ordinals and rune transactions are not the majority of the data that is included in the last blocks. https://ordiscan.com/blocks will help you to review the latest ordinals that were included in blocks. most of currently mined data is Consolidation data and therefore the network is in good condition.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on July 15, 2024, 01:56:30 PM
I don't know how high it will be going and I have this question in mind like is there a possibility of fees going down to 1 sats/vb? If there is a chance would you still hodl or withdraw?
Currently, some nodes allow you to broadcast a <2.67 sat/vB transaction, some may accept 2 sat/vB, but you can broadcast a transaction for 3 sat/vB. If the fees continue to drop, you may be able to get 1 sat/vB.
1 sat/vB, If you have any pending transaction, it will be confirmed and it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/07/15/4aGyJ.png)

(https://bitcoindata.science/api/bitcoinfees.php?&currency=USD&hex=000000) (https://bitcoindata.science/bitcointalk-api.html#bitcoin-fees)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on July 16, 2024, 02:41:51 PM
1 sat/vB, If you have any pending transaction, it will be confirmed and it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/07/15/4aGyJ.png)

1 sat/vb won't be confirmed soon and it's still risky, one wave of consolidations dropped and you might be again kicked out of the mempool, if you really want 1 sat/vb there is no point broadcasting it now, even if everybody would stop sending tx you won't get a confirmation by tomorrow.

But if you have a normal tx probably the savings don't matter anymore, 50 cents for next block versus the cheapest technically possible of 10 cents, no point waiting.


Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Fivestar4everMVP on July 16, 2024, 03:46:00 PM
This is very good time for consolidation of coins or for opening Lightning Network channels if you are using that.
Currently estimated fee in in mempool.space is around 8 sat/vB or $0.69, and this could change if bitcoin price changes and drops again.
I think this is quiet time before the Bitcoin storm.
After a long time, like 3 to 4 weeks, I decided to do some bitcoin transactions this morning, and I think I've never had a smoother experience, vbyte was at 8 satoshies, and for a transaction of about $200, I paid a total of $0.9 in fees, and it did not end there, I was literally expecting the transaction to take atleast, up to 30 minutes before I get a confirmation, but amazing, I got my first and second confirmation in less than 4 minutes, I was like "wow, so bitcoin transactions can a get confirmation this fast" 😍, I loved it to be honest, and wish It can only remain that way.

But I guess it's never going to remain this way since the bull run comes wit a lot of on chain activities, so, I guess it's OK to expect the fees to start to rise again as we enter another bullish season.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on July 16, 2024, 04:11:01 PM
1 sat/vB, If you have any pending transaction, it will be confirmed and it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
Don't tell people to send any bitcoin transaction using minimal fee of 1 sat/vB, especially not for consolidation of their coins!
Using fee around 5 sat/vB is acceptable and it's not going to make anyone poor for paying few cents more.

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on July 17, 2024, 01:01:27 PM

1 sat/vb won't be confirmed soon and it's still risky, one wave of consolidations dropped and you might be again kicked out of the mempool,
Don't tell people to send any bitcoin transaction using minimal fee of 1 sat/vB, especially not for consolidation of their coins!
Using fee around 5 sat/vB is acceptable and it's not going to make anyone poor for paying few cents more.
I did not recommend this, but a month ago 0t3p0t asked about the possibility that we would see 1 sats/vb. I had predicted that it might happen in the coming weeks, and yesterday it was possible to broadcast a transaction with 1 sats/vb.
We have an average of ~9.6 minutes and DIFFICULTY ADJUSTMENT will occur in the next 30 hours so during July I don't think we will see the ability to broadcast a 1 sats/vb transaction again.


I don't know how high it will be going and I have this question in mind like is there a possibility of fees going down to 1 sats/vb? If there is a chance would you still hodl or withdraw?
Currently, some nodes allow you to broadcast a <2.67 sat/vB transaction, some may accept 2 sat/vB, but you can broadcast a transaction for 3 sat/vB. If the fees continue to drop, you may be able to get 1 sat/vB.
1 sat/vB, If you have any pending transaction, it will be confirmed and it is an opportunity to group your inputs and/or open LN channels.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on July 17, 2024, 03:02:29 PM
I did not recommend this, but a month ago 0t3p0t asked about the possibility that we would see 1 sats/vb. I had predicted that it might happen in the coming weeks, and yesterday it was possible to broadcast a transaction with 1 sats/vb.

You will broadcast at 1 sat/vB

It will be propagated, but it will probably drop after a few days... it won't get confirmed anytime soon.
I agree that we will see 1 sat vB again, but it might take months...
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on July 17, 2024, 03:13:21 PM
I did not recommend this, but a month ago 0t3p0t asked about the possibility that we would see 1 sats/vb. I had predicted that it might happen in the coming weeks, and yesterday it was possible to broadcast a transaction with 1 sats/vb.
We have an average of ~9.6 minutes and DIFFICULTY ADJUSTMENT will occur in the next 30 hours so during July I don't think we will see the ability to broadcast a 1 sats/vb transaction again.

You could have broadcasted a 1sat/vb even months ago, the purge limit does not mean all nodes will reject it or drop it, there are hundreds of nodes with way higher mempool sizes than standard (mine is one), and a lot of clients would still re-broadcast your transactions to nodes if they see it's dropped.
But just as broadcasting one two months ago and one now, is just as futile,  it would be nearly impossible at this pace to get a confirmation even in two weeks unless something really, but really out of the ordinary happens and I can't even think of such an event.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Yamane_Keto on July 18, 2024, 02:03:03 PM
But just as broadcasting one two months ago and one now, is just as futile,  it would be nearly impossible at this pace to get a confirmation even in two weeks unless something really, but really out of the ordinary happens and I can't even think of such an event.

It will be propagated, but it will probably drop after a few days... it won't get confirmed anytime soon.
I agree that we will see 1 sat vB again, but it might take months...
Many last blocks included transactions with 4 SAT/VB There are still 5 hours before Adjustment and with the number of transactions, there is a good possibility that 1 SAT/VB is accepted in the upcoming blocks (12-40 block)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on July 18, 2024, 02:10:34 PM
Many last blocks included transactions with 4 SAT/VB There are still 5 hours before Adjustment and with the number of transactions, there is a good possibility that 1 SAT/VB is accepted in the upcoming blocks (12-40 block)
It looked like that a few days ago, so I sent some transactions with 3sat/vb, but they are still in pending status. I think it can only be expected during the weekend when there is less activity and fewer transactions on the network in general. Unless something unplanned happens.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: NotATether on July 18, 2024, 03:11:41 PM
Many last blocks included transactions with 4 SAT/VB There are still 5 hours before Adjustment and with the number of transactions, there is a good possibility that 1 SAT/VB is accepted in the upcoming blocks (12-40 block)
It looked like that a few days ago, so I sent some transactions with 3sat/vb, but they are still in pending status. I think it can only be expected during the weekend when there is less activity and fewer transactions on the network in general. Unless something unplanned happens.

The standard fee rate right now is still 6 sats/vbytes, and I believe there are hundreds - if not thousands - of transactions queues up at that fee rate, so they all have to be processed, and quickly, before you can think of the fee rate going down to 3, 4, and even 5 sats per vbyte.

The same will happen for the lower fee rates until (if?) it reaches 1 sat/vbyte.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on July 18, 2024, 03:23:47 PM
Many last blocks included transactions with 4 SAT/VB There are still 5 hours before Adjustment and with the number of transactions, there is a good possibility that 1 SAT/VB is accepted in the upcoming blocks (12-40 block)
It looked like that a few days ago, so I sent some transactions with 3sat/vb, but they are still in pending status. I think it can only be expected during the weekend when there is less activity and fewer transactions on the network in general. Unless something unplanned happens.

The standard fee rate right now is still 6 sats/vbytes, and I believe there are hundreds - if not thousands - of transactions queues up at that fee rate, so they all have to be processed, and quickly, before you can think of the fee rate going down to 3, 4, and even 5 sats per vbyte.

The same will happen for the lower fee rates until (if?) it reaches 1 sat/vbyte.

according to mempool.space, 70% of the next 152 blocks are all filled with 2 sat/vB or more.

(https://talkimg.com/images/2024/07/18/4Mg8T.png)

Which means, if nobody makes a new transaction with fee rate higher than 1 sat v/B in the next 1000 minutes (100 blocks, aprox. 17 hours), you will get a confirmation of 1.99 sat v/B in the next 17 hours.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on July 18, 2024, 05:30:29 PM
Quote
~
Many last blocks included transactions with 4 SAT/VB There are still 5 hours before Adjustment and with the number of transactions, there is a good possibility that 1 SAT/VB is accepted in the upcoming blocks (12-40 block)

Impossible, even assuming 1.99 sat and the lowest mempool point in the last week you would still need no new transactions and 40 blocks, so around 6 hours with nobody sending one damn tx to reach just under 2sat/vb not full 1.00 sat/vb.
But every time the fees drop to a new low you have an influx of consolidations, I watched yesterday someone dumping 20 tx with 1000+ inputs in a few seconds, those will just keep on happening as we drop lower and lower.

It looked like that a few days ago, so I sent some transactions with 3sat/vb, but they are still in pending status. I think it can only be expected during the weekend when there is less activity and fewer transactions on the network in general. Unless something unplanned happens.

We hit 3.98 early Monday, and I'm quite confident we might get to 2.98 next Monday morning (GMT time), I have a feeling everyone knows the fees will go down and just waits on the side, much like they wait for the next 4 years cycle.


Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on July 18, 2024, 05:51:11 PM
I paid 5.1 a day ago.  All shit is consolidated at this time.

1) biggest wallet
2) second biggest wallet
3) third wallet

all of the above are my wallets. All are narrowed to 1 tx
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: pieppiep on July 18, 2024, 07:23:28 PM
After several months of not really observing the movement of transaction fees using the mempool network, I was very surprised to see that transaction fees had become very cheap. This is a very good opportunity to do arbitrage, but remember we have to move quickly because we take advantage of price differences between exchange places.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bayu7adi on September 09, 2024, 11:14:10 AM
(https://i.ibb.co.com/Z2m82CH/Screenshot-2024-09-09-161431.png)

Are unconfirmed transactions an indication of the density of transactions occurring on the Bitcoin blockchain network?

I see the number of unconfirmed transactions between when the transaction fee is high and also between the current low transaction fee is not much different... I remember very well when I had to use a fee of 70 sat/vB when a dust attack occurred, the number of unconfirmed tx was listed there around 230k-240k too, the same as now where the current transaction fee is 2-4 sat/vB.

Is the conclusion, unconfirmed tx on the mempool does not present the density of transactions on the Bitcoin blockchain network?
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dragononcrypto on September 09, 2024, 12:05:32 PM
I paid 5.1 a day ago.  All shit is consolidated at this time.

1) biggest wallet
2) second biggest wallet
3) third wallet

all of the above are my wallets. All are narrowed to 1 tx

Just to say I did this last week at 3 sats, although this is obviously not a competition  :P

I need to remember this 0.1 scheme in future though, I see a lot of it around. Even 0.01 to jump in the queue.

I also did the same consolidation wise, last time I did it was about a year ago I think.

1) Main wallet - few inputs put together from some change
2) DCA wallet - numerous inputs consolidated from years ago
3) Bounty wallet - consolidated remaining unconsolidated txs

As far as I can tell it's otherwise been a month or so that 3 sats has been processing relatively quickly per:
https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#BTC%20(default%20mempool),30d,count
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on September 09, 2024, 03:34:30 PM
Are unconfirmed transactions an indication of the density of transactions occurring on the Bitcoin blockchain network?

Not really, you can have 1 tx occupying the same space as 5000 others, and that number of tx in the queue is quite irrelevant, it's just waiting transactions, that can change at any time with a dump or go down with a few fast blocks full of runes and the average fees won't change by even 0.1 sat/vb The size would be more relevant to see how much pressure is put on the mempool but yet again, if that's 90% in 1sat/cv is of no impact to the fees.

What really matters is the next 6 blocks in line to be confirmed and their fee structure, that's a more reliable indicator of what's happening at the moment.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Mia Chloe on September 14, 2024, 11:51:16 PM
Nice to see this topic here too. Anyways today I experienced something a little funny on the MEMPOOL. Though it wasn't a big deal I just thought I'd share it here probably we'll have a couple opinions about it.  Before I make any transaction I usually check the MEMPOOL just to know what fees are like in the current block and most recent block. I'm aware that fees on the MEMPOOL are dynamic, however today before I made my transaction I could see 7 sats/vbytes as the highest priority fees so I just decided I'd use 4.5 sats /vbyte. Anyways I was a little surprised when I came back to observe few seconds after I made my transaction that fees dropped to 3 sats /vbytes.

Anyone experienced this kinda shift before?
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: joniboini on September 15, 2024, 02:38:14 PM
Anyways I was a little surprised when I came back to observe few seconds after I made my transaction that fees dropped to 3 sats /vbytes.
There's no way your published transaction fees change randomly. You need to replace your transaction if you want to change the fee (e.g., bumping fee on an RBF-enabled transaction). CMIIW.

 Are you sure you don't misread the mempool info? Some explorers use different ways to show transaction fees so you might see some differences here and there. That being said, some websites may be slow to update so they show the wrong info. How does your tx look on your wallet?
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dragononcrypto on September 15, 2024, 03:59:54 PM
Nice to see this topic here too. Anyways today I experienced something a little funny on the MEMPOOL. Though it wasn't a big deal I just thought I'd share it here probably we'll have a couple opinions about it.  Before I make any transaction I usually check the MEMPOOL just to know what fees are like in the current block and most recent block. I'm aware that fees on the MEMPOOL are dynamic, however today before I made my transaction I could see 7 sats/vbytes as the highest priority fees so I just decided I'd use 4.5 sats /vbyte. Anyways I was a little surprised when I came back to observe few seconds after I made my transaction that fees dropped to 3 sats /vbytes.

Anyone experienced this kinda shift before?

It sounds like you might of transmitted the transaction just before a block was found? This would explain the drop in expected fee from 7 to 3 within seconds. Either that or it was just a bad estimate, maybe based on the past minute or so of transactions, as opposed to the past 10 minutes. Lot's of different reasons why estimates can be inaccurate basically.

That's why I prefer using something like mempool.space if it's not high priority transaction and you're willing to wait 10-30 minutes. You can then avoid paying the price of the current block that is in progress, and go with the cost of the previous few blocks (assuming the current block fee cost is an outlier). I otherwise wouldn't pay too much attention to the predicted fees in future blocks (excluding the current one), as naturally these will increase with more transactions submitted (as it's based only on the current mempool, not the developing mempool).
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on September 15, 2024, 04:04:02 PM
Anyways I was a little surprised when I came back to observe few seconds after I made my transaction that fees dropped to 3 sats /vbytes.
There's no way your published transaction fees change randomly. You need to replace your transaction if you want to change the fee (e.g., bumping fee on an RBF-enabled transaction). CMIIW.

Average fees not the fees that he paid!
It is a common occurrence because of either a dump from some exchange or long time between blocks
https://mempool.space/block/00000000000000000000c63d0ef9faedfa4eec5d9138207713c7b19000436f78
https://mempool.space/block/0000000000000000000206087b5e88b87e2b89e05ba6108036a366e1d7eff1ee

First block was at 03:08:34  the next one at 04:17:57 , more than one hour instead of 10 minutes so the fees went from 2sat/vb to 7sat/vb, and 5 blocks later back to 2sat/vb.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Mia Chloe on September 16, 2024, 10:33:10 PM
It sounds like you might of transmitted the transaction just before a block was found? This would explain the drop in expected fee from 7 to 3 within seconds. Either that or it was just a bad estimate, maybe based on the past minute or so of transactions, as opposed to the past 10 minutes. Lot's of different reasons why estimates can be inaccurate basically.
I think you get my point. The fact is I understand what happened and it was quite awkward to me because of the shift it the fee rate were quite large and judging from the whole scenario that they i was kinda skeptical about the fees anyways like I said before I still proceeded to making use of it simply because I just thought like it was still within the working hours of the US and during those periods fees are usually kinda high.
Anyways I experienced something almost similar today but it was just a few SATs in difference. I think I'll stick to making use of 3 sats/byte since for quite some time now that has been the average fee though sometimes fees dance up and down that value.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 28, 2025, 12:44:39 PM
1 sat/vb are real now!

Just got a transaction confirmed!! I am warning everyone so you guys can make your consolidations!

I remember so many people saying it was never going to happen! Here are we are! Bitcoin is amazing!
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Findingnemo on January 28, 2025, 01:25:15 PM
1 sat/vb are real now!

Just got a transaction confirmed!! I am warning everyone so you guys can make your consolidations!

I remember so many people saying it was never going to happen! Here are we are! Bitcoin is amazing!

1sat/vb transactions are quite common now but it's better to use 1.1sat/vb to skip the long queue of 1sat.vb transactions. It's the best time for consolidation because we never know when the network will be clogged and fees could skyrocket for short term.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 28, 2025, 03:32:17 PM
1 sat/vb are real now!

Just got a transaction confirmed!! I am warning everyone so you guys can make your consolidations!

I remember so many people saying it was never going to happen! Here are we are! Bitcoin is amazing!

1sat/vb transactions are quite common now but it's better to use 1.1sat/vb to skip the long queue of 1sat.vb transactions. It's the best time for consolidation because we never know when the network will be clogged and fees could skyrocket for short term.

You are right.

I sent one 1.0 sat v/b which took about 5 days to get confirmed (only today). Now I have consolidated more than 200 UTXO into 2 outputs for 1.1 and 1.2 sat v/B :)

I spent a total of 16 usd to make all that consolidation, which is quite amazing!

There were so many UTXO that my ledger nano took aboutr 5min to process it. I detailed it in BTT , in a topic about that problem here:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5527981.msg65001098#msg65001098
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: rdluffy on January 28, 2025, 03:51:00 PM
You are right.

I sent one 1.0 sat v/b which took about 5 days to get confirmed (only today). Now I have consolidated more than 200 UTXO into 2 outputs for 1.1 and 1.2 sat v/B :)

I spent a total of 16 usd to make all that consolidation, which is quite amazing!

There were so many UTXO that my ledger nano took aboutr 5min to process it. I detailed it in BTT , in a topic about that problem here:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5527981.msg65001098#msg65001098

I bet you consolidated the payments from the forum campaigns hehehe

I already had to do that a few months ago and managed to pay a good price, I think it was 2 sat v/b
A few days ago I made 2 transactions and managed to pay 3 sat v/b

I think this period of BTC's rise in price is excellent and the fees are so good, without absurd spikes
200 txs and 16USD  :o It's cheap
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 28, 2025, 05:41:42 PM
You are right.

I sent one 1.0 sat v/b which took about 5 days to get confirmed (only today). Now I have consolidated more than 200 UTXO into 2 outputs for 1.1 and 1.2 sat v/B :)

I spent a total of 16 usd to make all that consolidation, which is quite amazing!

There were so many UTXO that my ledger nano took aboutr 5min to process it. I detailed it in BTT , in a topic about that problem here:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5527981.msg65001098#msg65001098

I bet you consolidated the payments from the forum campaigns hehehe

Yeah, basically forum payments. Campaigns, contests, reviews, avatar, etc etc... It is impressive how many UTXO we can accumulate with such activities.

Quote
200 txs and 16USD  :o It's cheap

Basically 200 transations for 16 usd :)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 28, 2025, 08:35:56 PM
1 sat/vb are real now!
Your dream came real  8)
It is incredible we are holding around $100k in fiat value and there are almost no real activity mempool...something doesn't feel right to me.
Note that this is not the result of any protocol or code improvements, just less transactions on blockchain.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: rdluffy on January 28, 2025, 09:48:09 PM
1 sat/vb are real now!
Your dream came real  8)
It is incredible we are holding around $100k in fiat value and there are almost no real activity mempool...something doesn't feel right to me.
Note that this is not the result of any protocol or code improvements, just less transactions on blockchain.

I believe that with institutional investment the values have increased, larger purchases, large holders and without so many transactions from ordinary users, like us hehehe
ETFs must also have helped in this regard, since you can buy and sell ETFs without having to make transactions
It also helps that nothing is happening in Bitcoin like it did with the runes

It's time to make the most of it and get everything consolidated  ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on January 28, 2025, 11:44:17 PM
Quote
200 txs and 16USD  :o It's cheap

Basically 200 transations for 16 usd :)
quiet!
Don't say this to stompix, he's not happy when the miners aren't happy.  :D

Note that this is not the result of any protocol or code improvements, just less transactions on blockchain.
Trump's inauguration did not bring a spectacular ATH, so now we have a lot of holders who buys the high.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 29, 2025, 12:39:00 AM
1 sat/vb are real now!
Your dream came real  8)
It is incredible we are holding around $100k in fiat value and there are almost no real activity mempool...something doesn't feel right to me.
Note that this is not the result of any protocol or code improvements, just less transactions on blockchain.

previous spikes of 500 sat/vB weren't scalability problem. They were just a spam in the network caused by a misuse of the network (as cloud storage)

I also think that the price is now drive by activity that happens outside the blockchain: ETFs and trades inside the exchanges, without necessarily meaning people withdrawing or depositing bitcoin
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Mr. Magkaisa on January 29, 2025, 07:49:40 AM
         -      Maybe about 2 weeks ago I noticed that the fee that is being deducted recently is quite low when you make a transaction with bitcoin. And I'm sure those who also make transactions with bitcoin are also in favor and happy.

I just hope that when the price of Bitcoin rallies, its fee won't suddenly increase, which will surprise most bitcoin holders like what happened last year when
it was really expensive.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 30, 2025, 12:41:15 PM
I just hope that when the price of Bitcoin rallies, its fee won't suddenly increase, which will surprise most bitcoin holders like what happened last year when
it was really expensive.

We are very close to ATh now, so bitcoin is already in a rally... and the fees are ok!

I believe ETF are working somewhat as a second layer, as transactions there won't affect the blockchain, and there is a lot of volume there
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: 0t3p0t on January 30, 2025, 01:53:43 PM
         -      Maybe about 2 weeks ago I noticed that the fee that is being deducted recently is quite low when you make a transaction with bitcoin. And I'm sure those who also make transactions with bitcoin are also in favor and happy.

I just hope that when the price of Bitcoin rallies, its fee won't suddenly increase, which will surprise most bitcoin holders like what happened last year when
it was really expensive.
Right now, the fees are stable at 2sats/vb which is quite lower when I had my transactions a couple of days ago which cost me 7sats/vb and yeah hopefully this will stay on this range like 1-3sats/vb and not trigger a spike just like what had happened in the first quarter of 2024 if I am not wrong.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on January 30, 2025, 05:47:24 PM
quiet!
Don't say this to stompix, he's not happy when the miners aren't happy.  :D

Fees haven't been anything meaningful since the last rune fomo, so the fees dropping from 5 to 1 sat/vb on average means close to nothing in the revenues, fees in total reward were below 1%, even if they were 5 times higher they would still compete with daily trends.
Anyhow, I don't care that much financially since I don't mine anymore, but I'm still curious how things will work since those fees were the ones supposedly keeping the network safe once the reward is gone, and what we see is that usage is gone way before that.


Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on January 30, 2025, 05:54:15 PM
quiet!
Don't say this to stompix, he's not happy when the miners aren't happy.  :D

Fees haven't been anything meaningful since the last rune fomo, so the fees dropping from 5 to 1 sat/vb on average means close to nothing in the revenues, fees in total reward were below 1%, even if they were 5 times higher they would still compete with daily trends.
Anyhow, I don't care that much financially since I don't mine anymore, but I'm still curious how things will work since those fees were the ones supposedly keeping the network safe once the reward is gone, and what we see is that usage is gone way before that.



Well 3.125 + 0.025 is 3.150

And 3.125 + 0.005 is 3.130

2000 dollars more


The last 50 blocks ranged from 400 to 10,000 in fees.  Or say 0.004 to 0.100 btc

If you mine 20% of the blocks and are a major company 10,000 x 28 blocks is 280,000 and 400 x 28 blocks is 11200 a day

So the bottom line is that difference means big money.

BUT if you add and average those numbers it's about a steady 3,000 a block or 84,000 a day. These lower fees hurt major mines that are private.

If I earn 84,000 a day in fees vs 280,000 a day it is 1 million in 5 days

Or over 70,000 for the biggest mine.  Of course price is over 100k so they are fine.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: NotATether on January 30, 2025, 09:36:25 PM
What, no FeeBuddy blasting this thread bitmover?  ;D

I have tax-proofed my Bitcoin transactions from exorbiant miner fees by opening a bunch of Lightning channels. I'm in the process of starting a second node too. I've also got Electrum trampoline routers in the works. I will never ever pay $20 to get a transaction confirmed again. 8)
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 30, 2025, 09:56:35 PM
I will never ever pay $20 to get a transaction confirmed again. 8)

Neither will I!

I just paid 16 usd to consolidate 90% of my inputs (200+), so I am fine now , at least for some years lol
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on January 30, 2025, 10:24:54 PM
Anyhow, I don't care that much financially since I don't mine anymore, but I'm still curious how things will work since those fees were the ones supposedly keeping the network safe once the reward is gone, and what we see is that usage is gone way before that.
Yes, it's a long-term dilemma.
Don't you think that over time some hardware will be developed that will be significantly more energy efficient? As mining hardware has changed during these 15 years, from that point of view 2035 is very far away.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on January 30, 2025, 11:16:36 PM
I believe that with institutional investment the values have increased, larger purchases, large holders and without so many transactions from ordinary users, like us hehehe
ETFs must also have helped in this regard, since you can buy and sell ETFs without having to make transactions
It also helps that nothing is happening in Bitcoin like it did with the runes
Sure, we have some institutional money, but I think that the hype around the Trump was making people wait to see what will happen after he comes in office.
Don't get me wrong, I think that low fees are great to have, but this looks like to me like a quiet time before the storm.

Trump's inauguration did not bring a spectacular ATH, so now we have a lot of holders who buys the high.
I think we already had Bitcoin ATH around $108,786, that is not much different than current price.
There are multiple factors like monetary policy and rate cuts and also affect the price, and maybe the fees.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on January 31, 2025, 06:28:11 AM
~
Yes, it's a long-term dilemma.
Don't you think that over time some hardware will be developed that will be significantly more energy efficient? As mining hardware has changed during these 15 years, from that point of view 2035 is very far away.

Hardware efficiency is meaningless.
Right now you have ~750Exahash protecting the network because each TH/s is making 5 cents.
If efficiency grows 1000 times you will have machines that mine in petahashes instead of ths/s but doing the same profits for pt/s instead of th/s.

What matters in terms of security is how much miners make a day, the network is protected by that amount, not by hashes.
If miners make 100$ a day that means 34k a year someone who can invest half a million will be able to do a  90% attack, lol.
If miners make 100 million a day it means they can invest at least 36 billion in gear to protect the network.


Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on January 31, 2025, 09:46:56 AM
Hardware efficiency is meaningless.
Right now you have ~750Exahash protecting the network because each TH/s is making 5 cents.
If efficiency grows 1000 times you will have machines that mine in petahashes instead of ths/s but doing the same profits for pt/s instead of th/s.
I wasn't thinking about hardware power but about lower costs for the same work.
How much does it cost TH/s until it realizes that 5 cents?
If electricity consumption were to be halved, wouldn't that have a direct impact on the miner's total profit?
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on January 31, 2025, 01:55:56 PM
Anyhow, I don't care that much financially since I don't mine anymore, but I'm still curious how things will work since those fees were the ones supposedly keeping the network safe once the reward is gone, and what we see is that usage is gone way before that.
Yes, it's a long-term dilemma.
Don't you think that over time some hardware will be developed that will be significantly more energy efficient? As mining hardware has changed during these 15 years, from that point of view 2035 is very far away.

Mining rewards are still high enough. Miners are receiving 330 thousand dollars per block, even with 1 sat vb fees.

That is not a problem now.  High fees now could even cause a price drop, making this mining reward smaller in usd value.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 02, 2025, 10:10:04 AM
~
I wasn't thinking about hardware power but about lower costs for the same work.
How much does it cost TH/s until it realizes that 5 cents?
If electricity consumption were to be halved, wouldn't that have a direct impact on the miner's total profit?

Doesn't matter!
You have 100 guys with S9 mining, doing each 14th/s and burning 1.3kw, spending 10$ for 1% of the profits.
There comes a guy with an s19 and he makes 10% of the pot while spending 3$, everyone will do the same
100 guys with an s19 mining, each generating 100th/s, burning 3kw spending 3$ and getting 1% of the profits.

Energy consumption for the network will always be somewhere around 75-90% of the reward, that is the only thing limiting it, and if it drops to 10$ we're back to CPU mining.  ;D

You can check the electricity consumption for the network, we went from 1th per kw to 30th per kw in efficiency and despite that the consumption has grown because the pot was bigger.

That is not a problem now.

Reminds me of the electricity problem in Germany.
2022 What can we do, we can't build back nuclear power plants, it takes 10-15 years!
2023 What can we do, we can't build back nuclear power plants, it takes 10-15 years!
2024 What can we do, we can't build back nuclear power plants, it takes 10-15 years!
...
2080, if only we would have started building those nuclear plants back in 2022!

 
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 02, 2025, 11:20:12 AM
That is not a problem now.

Reminds me of the electricity problem in Germany.
2022 What can we do, we can't build back nuclear power plants, it takes 10-15 years!
2023 What can we do, we can't build back nuclear power plants, it takes 10-15 years!
2024 What can we do, we can't build back nuclear power plants, it takes 10-15 years!
...
2080, if only we would have started building those nuclear plants back in 2022!

I don`t think bitcoin protocol should be changed because of bad decisions made by German politicians years ago.
Domestic esg and woke policies made by one country are irrelevant. Innovation and technology will simple come from other countries

There is plenty energy in the world to make a secure financial system, even AI is consuming more power than bitcoin right now.


Bitcoin fees will adapt to the current mining reward... Probably more people will be using bitcoin in the future, and common people will use L2 for cheaper tx if they need.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: rdluffy on February 02, 2025, 12:17:04 PM
(https://i.ibb.co/4ZdcvWz1/xxxxx.png) (https://ibb.co/XZ890X1Y)
Source (https://x.com/i/bookmarks?post_id=1885790346199650641)

I didn't know the mempool hadn't been empty for two years
Impressive  :o :o :o
BTC at 100k and mempool empty
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 02, 2025, 12:38:33 PM
(https://i.ibb.co/4ZdcvWz1/xxxxx.png) (https://ibb.co/XZ890X1Y)
Source (https://x.com/i/bookmarks?post_id=1885790346199650641)

I didn't know the mempool hadn't been empty for two years
Impressive  :o :o :o
BTC at 100k and mempool empty

technically, nodes shouldn't propagate 0 sat/vbyte fees

I believe those 0 sat/vbyte are probably miners transactions, which they added by themselves
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: SmartGold01 on February 02, 2025, 01:29:26 PM
(https://i.ibb.co/4ZdcvWz1/xxxxx.png) (https://ibb.co/XZ890X1Y)
Source (https://x.com/i/bookmarks?post_id=1885790346199650641)

I didn't know the mempool hadn't been empty for two years
Impressive  :o :o :o
BTC at 100k and mempool empty

technically, nodes shouldn't propagate 0 sat/vbyte fees

I believe those 0 sat/vbyte are probably miners transactions, which they added by themselves
I have never met with 1 sat/vbyte before while doing transactions, the least I have ever meet is 3 sat/vbyte and i see that fair enough for transactions since is not up to 50 cent in the transaction I sees it fair enough. But I believe I will target 1 or 2 sat.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 03, 2025, 01:26:55 AM
I have never met with 1 sat/vbyte before while doing transactions, the least I have ever meet is 3 sat/vbyte and i see that fair enough for transactions since is not up to 50 cent in the transaction I sees it fair enough. But I believe I will target 1 or 2 sat.

You can try now!

You can make some consolidations of your signature campagins earnings.

Select all your inputs from the same address and make a 1 sat/vb transaction to another (or the same) address.

This way you will save a lot of money in the future. Because each input basically counts as a new transaction in terms of cost and fees
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on February 03, 2025, 01:33:29 AM
I have never met with 1 sat/vbyte before while doing transactions, the least I have ever meet is 3 sat/vbyte and i see that fair enough for transactions since is not up to 50 cent in the transaction I sees it fair enough. But I believe I will target 1 or 2 sat.

You can try now!

You can make some consolidations of your signature campagins earnings.

Select all your inputs from the same address and make a 1 sat/vb transaction to another (or the same) address.

This way you will save a lot of money in the future. Because each input basically counts as a new transaction in terms of cost and fees

going to consolidate right now using 1.23 sats
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: SmartGold01 on February 03, 2025, 10:42:04 PM
I have never met with 1 sat/vbyte before while doing transactions, the least I have ever meet is 3 sat/vbyte and i see that fair enough for transactions since is not up to 50 cent in the transaction I sees it fair enough. But I believe I will target 1 or 2 sat.

You can try now!

You can make some consolidations of your signature campagins earnings.

Select all your inputs from the same address and make a 1 sat/vb transaction to another (or the same) address.

This way you will save a lot of money in the future. Because each input basically counts as a new transaction in terms of cost and fees
I didn't know about this as well.. you know I don't really know much about technical knowledge of wallet and transaction. But I just understand the sat/vbyte of a thing, so while doing transaction I make sure it's not stuck halfway where I would have to bump fee to come confirm so quickly.
Maybe I will try out what you said in the morning,  but while doing this I have to use my pc to avoid mistake.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Stompix on February 04, 2025, 06:48:58 AM
I don`t think bitcoin protocol should be changed because of bad decisions made by German politicians years ago.

It was just an example of not acting and thinking that things will resolve on their own by god knows what miracles.
Right now everyone is banking on these solutions:
- big players running this at a loss to protect their investment (why should they and goodbye decentralization)
- people paying more just for unknown reasons...

Bottom line to have the same level of security as previously the fees must match the reward, I don't see blocks full with 100$ per tx to cover that, not to mention that with every increase in BTC price you have a bigger target. I said it before, nobody really cared on attacking it while it was a 1 billion network, when it becomes a 10 trillion one, perspective do change!

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 04, 2025, 12:36:20 PM
while doing transaction I make sure it's not stuck halfway where I would have to bump fee to come confirm so quickly.
Maybe I will try out what you said in the morning,  but while doing this I have to use my pc to avoid mistake.

Maybe you could try a better wallet, which will help you understand things better.

I use Electrum, download it from electrum.org

Bottom line to have the same level of security as previously the fees must match the reward, I don't see blocks full with 100$ per tx to cover that, not to mention that with every increase in BTC price you have a bigger target. I said it before, nobody really cared on attacking it while it was a 1 billion network, when it becomes a 10 trillion one, perspective do change!

I think fees should match the block subside in USD values, not in BTC value.

So, when subside becomes irrelevant BTC price may be something like 1 million dollars or even more. In this situation, even a small fee such as 10-100 sat/vB might be enough to match the total block reward from today's time.

There are some developers which defend smaller blocks. This would skyrocket fees.

(https://talkimg.com/images/2025/02/04/eNwG5.png)
https://x.com/LukeDashjr/status/1884095432613396564
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: SmartGold01 on February 04, 2025, 01:50:20 PM
while doing transaction I make sure it's not stuck halfway where I would have to bump fee to come confirm so quickly.
Maybe I will try out what you said in the morning,  but while doing this I have to use my pc to avoid mistake.

Maybe you could try a better wallet, which will help you understand things better.

I use Electrum, download it from electrum.org
I have Electrum already downloaded with my pc, so what I meant is that while doing such transaction I would have to use my PC as I am not that comfortable using my Smartphone for any transaction to avoid series of mistakes or sending back payment to the same address that sent me payment.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on February 05, 2025, 08:08:55 PM
Now is the good time to consolidate transactions, don't think for a second fees will remain like this for a long time.
I am expecting to see big price changes for bitcoin in next few months and this will affect state of the mempool and transactions.
And I would reject any stupid softfork propositions by Luke.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: philipma1957 on February 06, 2025, 05:31:19 AM
 I used my trezor set fees to 1.23 sats just in case. they all cleared in under an hour
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bayu7adi on February 06, 2025, 05:48:46 AM
I used my trezor set fees to 1.23 sats just in case. they all cleared in under an hour
A few hours ago, 2 sat/vB completed my transaction in less than 10 minutes...a perfect time to secure the balance in another wallet and lock it in a savings wallet for holding...we will never know when bitcoin fees will skyrocket again...because I don't want to feel trapped again to be reluctant to make a transaction at that time when the fee war is so crazy..

Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: Baofeng on February 11, 2025, 11:55:43 AM
I used my trezor set fees to 1.23 sats just in case. they all cleared in under an hour
A few hours ago, 2 sat/vB completed my transaction in less than 10 minutes...a perfect time to secure the balance in another wallet and lock it in a savings wallet for holding...we will never know when bitcoin fees will skyrocket again...because I don't want to feel trapped again to be reluctant to make a transaction at that time when the fee war is so crazy..

Yes, so far that's also the lowest that I will to avail. I don't know, I'm not that confident to bring back and used 1 sat/vB although right now, it's the lowest and I have seen the mempool almost clearing itself the last couple of days.

Perhaps I have that trauma on the 1 sat/vB as we have experienced the fees really go up high last year and so I still have that mentality that it might go up again anytime and my transaction going to be stuck.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: examplens on February 11, 2025, 03:53:31 PM
Yes, so far that's also the lowest that I will to avail. I don't know, I'm not that confident to bring back and used 1 sat/vB although right now, it's the lowest and I have seen the mempool almost clearing itself the last couple of days.

Perhaps I have that trauma on the 1 sat/vB as we have experienced the fees really go up high last year and so I still have that mentality that it might go up again anytime and my transaction going to be stuck.
Hold is trendy.
Nobody wants to become a funny meme like Laszlo, so they overpay for some minor things today.

Interestingly, there are no more Runes, BRC tokens, etc., it seems that crowd psychology is omnipresent among crypto enthusiasts.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: dkbit98 on February 15, 2025, 12:08:23 PM
Quote from: Baofeng link=topic=315483.msg1714474#msg1714474
Perhaps I have that trauma on the 1 sat/vB as we have experienced the fees really go up high last year and so I still have that mentality that it might go up again anytime and my transaction going to be stuck.
That is not such a big problem nowadays if you are sending transactions with RBF (replace-by-fee).
If mempool gets stuck with lot of transactions you can just increase the fee onyour specific transaction and it should be confirmed soon after that.
I would not recomend using minimal 1 sat/vB fee in case you need fast confirmation.
Title: Re: Mempool Observer - Discussion about Bitcoin Fees
Post by: bitmover on February 15, 2025, 12:45:30 PM
I would not recomend using minimal 1 sat/vB fee in case you need fast confirmation.

We can see many empty blocks getting mined, mempool is getting empty from time to time (yesterday it was empty).

So I would recommend 1 sat/vB if you can wait a few hours or a day, you will get confirmed. Good opportunity to get 1 sat/vB consolidations